The Plum Borough School Board will wait to see whether residents petition a judge to weigh in on a board vacancy before deciding whether to take the issue to court on its own.

During a discussion meeting Tuesday, Plum solicitor Lee Price told the board that he believes the contested seat that opened when board member Michelle Stepnick abruptly resigned in September is vacant. But because a majority couldn’t agree on a candidate to replace her, Mr. Price said, the board could join Ms. Stepnick in asking a judge to decide whether she can have her position back.

“I am offering a potential solution,” Mr. Price said. “I have always maintained that there are issues going both ways.”

A majority of the board would need to approve such a move. Board members said Tuesday they will wait to see if a group of 10 or more resident taxpayers decides to petition a judge. If they don’t, the board intends to revisit the issue at its meeting next week.

Advertise with us

If the matter were brought to court, a judge would decide whether Ms. Stepnick could rescind her resignation or whether someone else should be appointed to her vacated seat, Mr. Price said.

Ms. Stepnick declined to comment.

She resigned from the board before a September meeting at which the board ultimately voted to reinstate superintendent Timothy Glasspool following an independent investigation of the district sex scandal. She changed her mind a few days later and argued that her resignation was never official because the remaining eight board members did not vote to accept it.

The board moved forward with finding a replacement to fill her seat, but failed in a 4-4 vote at its meeting in October to make an appointment.

Last week, Ms. Stepnick’s attorney sent a letter to the district saying she intended to resume her duties and would seek a surcharge against the board if it pursued litigation. Ms. Stepnick was present at the meeting Tuesday, but did not sit with the board members. She took notes and sat among the audience as the board discussed capital projects, next year’s budget and other topics.

Advertise with us

The option presented by Mr. Price was not welcomed by all board members.

“I’m not interested in filing with Mrs. Stepnick,” said board member Susan Caldwell, who voted to appoint another community member to the contested seat.

Board member Vicky Roessler, who also voted to appoint someone else, argued that the board should follow the legal advice of Mr. Price, who said he believes the seat is vacant.

“If Mrs. Stepnick disagrees with that, then she could go to court,” Ms. Roessler said.

But others, including Ms. Caldwell, said they would be willing to accept a judge’s decision because the seat won’t be up for election for another year.

Advertise with us

Board member Richard Zucco said several legal opinions were offered about whether there is a true vacancy, and settling the matter would help the board move forward.

“I’d rather the court make an opinion,” he said.

Elizabeth Behrman: lbehrman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1590.