An Allegheny County judge has denied a request by the Gateway School District to arm police officers in its schools.

Common Pleas Senior Judge Timothy O’Reilly issued a nine-page opinion Thursday saying “it’s not a good idea” to implement an independent, private, 11-officer police force, that not enough thought was put into the district’s plan and that giving the officers full arrest and citation powers would lead to “super discipline” and potential abuses.

“In a nutshell, I will NOT sign the petition because more thought needs to be put into this proposition and more training needs to be developed for those who will be armed school police officers,” he wrote.

District solicitor Bruce Dice said whether Judge O’Reilly thinks it’s a good idea or not “is none of his business.”

Advertise with us

Petitions like the one submitted by Gateway are always signed by the courts “as a matter of course,” Mr. Dice said.

In 43 years, Mr. Dice said, “I’ve never experienced this before. He’s an esteemed jurist, a good guy, but I’m flabbergasted.”

He expects the board will appeal and possibly seek emergency relief from the Commonwealth Court.

Gateway filed its petition July 19 and argued the issue Aug. 22, including testimony from two school board members, the district’s human resource manager and two recently hired officers.

Judge O’Reilly noted that no one objected to the request.

Advertise with us

The district board voted 7-2 to authorize the petition’s presentation and hired 11 officers, including two supervisors, in August. They earn between $18 and $23 per hour. The board also approved spending $18,000 for uniforms and equipment.

The officers currently work as security guards, Mr. Dice said, have no arrest powers and cannot carry firearms.

Previously, the district employed two armed school resource officers who were detailed from the Monroeville and Pitcairn police departments.

The district requested that the program be in place by the time school started in August, Judge O’Reilly wrote, and he was repeatedly urged to issue his decision, including what he called a “new and imaginative ‘hurry up, judge’ pleading never before seen by me.”

He noted, too, being contacted by prominent Gateway alumni to act.

Advertise with us

“[T]he politically charged atmosphere surrounding this issue leads me to conclude that these private police may well be used to further particular school board goals and desires beyond child safety,” Judge O’Reilly wrote.

In Allegheny County, he said, only six districts have armed police officers, and in those districts, there are only eight individual officers who carry firearms. With Gateway’s proposal, he continued, the number would increase by 11.

“I find this somewhat arresting,” he wrote, “particularly when neither Pittsburgh nor Philadelphia, densely populated urban areas, have any [school police officers] carrying guns.”

The judge listed a number of concerns, including that on the school board committee that considered the issue there were no educators, mental health professionals or child development specialists, nor was input sought “as to how the presence of armed police would impact the student body and the educational mission.”

Judge O’Reilly called it a “dereliction” by the state Department of Education for failing to offer guidance on the issue.

Advertise with us

Gateway’s attorney argued that the court really has no discretion in the matter, but Judge O’Reilly said he disagreed.

“I think the Legislature invites any judge hearing matters like this to bring to bear his knowledge and life experience formed over years of practice and adjudicating with a knowledge of the county in which that judge serves.”

Judge O’Reilly wrote that he has practiced law for 30 years, including labor and municipal law. Also, he continued, he raised two children in the Mt. Lebanon school district.

“Once this private force is approved and put in place, it can never be disbanded except by herculean efforts by succeeding school boards. I also have not seen any evidence that the existing police forces serving Gateway are not up to the task.”

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.