For students in the Plum Borough School District, a new school year with a clean slate begins today, but the fallout from a sex abuse scandal last year that exposed institutional failures continues to linger.

The last of three current or former teachers to be charged with having sex with a student awaits trial next month. Both superintendent Timothy Glasspool and high school principal Ryan Kociela remain on paid administrative leave with their status unresolved. And an outside law firm is still in the midst of an independent probe to determine whether either of them violated the state’s Public School Code in how they handled rumors, allegations and accusations of inappropriate conduct by teachers.

The men were criticized in an 89-page grand jury report issued by the Allegheny County District Attorney’s Office after Joseph Ruggieri, Jason Cooper and Michael Cinefra were arrested on charges of institutional sexual assault for having sex with female students. Ruggieri and Cooper have pleaded guilty, while Mr. Cinefra has a Sept. 28 trial date. A fourth teacher, Drew Zoldak, was found not guilty of intimidating Ruggieri’s victim in class.

“We haven’t really made any decision yet on the superintendent or on the principal. We have discussed what we should do, but we didn’t want to make a lot of changes like that the week before school,” board president Kevin Dowdell said Friday. “Once school starts, we’ll try to figure out what to do with the rest of the administration, the superintendent and principal.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Dowdell said the board has expressed frustration to the outside law firm conducting the probe — Levin Legal Group from Montgomery County near Philadelphia — that the report was not completed over the summer.

“We’re a little bit frustrated ourselves. We were hoping it would be done in a few weeks. But we do want the process to be thorough and accurate, and we’re trying to get the process moving along as quickly as possible,” Mr. Dowdell said.

The report will attempt to determine whether any grounds exist to terminate Mr. Glasspool or Mr. Kociela.

“There’s no legal findings from the grand jury report. Based on the grand jury report, we don’t have any grounds to terminate. We have to look at the school code. The Levin Group is looking for anything that would be a violation of the school code,” Mr. Dowdell said. “If they did not violate any of those, then there’s not much more we can do about it.”

In the meantime, assistant superintendent Guy Rossi will run the district, and students will try to get past the ugliness of the past year, which involved arrests, the high-profile seizures of documents from the district office, relentless media coverage and sordid details about teachers and fellow students.

Advertise with us

“The school board has been assured by administration that the faculty at each school is ready and waiting on the students’ arrival next week,” said board member Vicky Roessler, who has been critical of how the administration handled the sexual abuse allegations. “To the kids, it is business as usual and all efforts will be made to make them the top priority.”

The DA’s office spent nine months investigating how Ruggieri, described as a “suspected serial child predator,” was able to operate with relative impunity over the years, striking up allegedly inappropriate relationships with numerous female students and “grooming” them. The grand jury did not recommend any criminal charges, but it described institutional failures to properly investigate, document and report allegations of inappropriate relationships.

The school board in May placed Mr. Glasspool and Mr. Kociela on leave in the face of pressure from several members and irate parents. Around that time, they retained Levin Legal Group after some members expressed concern that the report was one-sided and incomplete.

To date, Mr. Dowdell said, the firm has interviewed Mr. Glasspool and Mr. Kociela “and maybe a couple of others.” The firm is being paid an hourly rate, which has amounted so far to between $5,000 and $8,000, according to Mr Dowdell.

“They still want to get in touch with some more people interviewed in the grand jury report. He didn’t really give us a firm timeline,” Mr. Dowdell said. “We wanted it ASAP. Originally, we thought it would be a few weeks, and it’s gone a lot longer than expected. But I guess setting up interviews with people has taken time. We were hoping to have it wrapped up before school starts, but that’s not the case. So hopefully in the next few weeks, we’ll hear something from them.”

Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.