Around the time that former Plum high school teacher Joseph Ruggieri was arrested for having an inappropriate sexual relationship with a student, that teen confided in another teacher, Drew Zoldak.
The student, then a senior in Mr. Zoldak’s forensics class, showed up to his room one morning in February 2015 crying. He tried to comfort her, moved her to a private room and told her to stay there until she had collected herself. He also called a police officer for the young woman to talk to.
Two months later, prosecutors allege, Mr. Zoldak intimidated that same student by calling her out in class as the victim.
Mr. Zoldak, 41, is charged with a single count of witness intimidation after the district attorney’s office dropped a second count on Tuesday, saying it couldn’t sustain the burden of proof. Trial began Wednesday before Common Pleas Judge David R. Cashman.
Assistant district attorney Brian Catanzarite told the jury in his opening that Mr. Zoldak, who had taken Friday, April 17, 2015, off to go fishing with his friend, was interviewed that same day by DA’s investigators at his home.
On the following Monday, his students asked where he had been.
Read More
“He told them ‘two men in suits from the DA’s office came to my house to interview me. And it’s because of her,’ ” Mr. Catanzarite related.
“This student, whose world was collapsing, was pointed out by her teacher — her authority figure.”
During his interview with detectives, Mr. Zoldak told them, “It takes two to tango,” Mr. Catanzarite said.
“That’s Mr. Zoldak failing to recognize his role, and teachers’ roles, as adults in the building. School and home are supposed to be a safe place,” the prosecutor said. “This isn’t a momentary lapse in judgment. It’s a crime.”
But defense attorney Alexander Lindsay told the jury that Mr. Zoldak did not point at the student or single out anyone in class.
“There are a whole lot of witnesses here who didn’t see it,” the lawyer said.
Instead, he continued, Mr. Zoldak simply told his students he had been absent the previous Friday because he was being interviewed about the ongoing investigation in the district.
“That’s all he said, ladies and gentlemen. That’s it.”
Mr. Lindsay described Mr. Zoldak, who will testify, as a well-liked teacher who loved his job. The case against his client, the attorney said, is “very, very weak.”
The prosecution began with testimony from Frances Laquatra and Perran Tansmore, the two DA’s office detectives who interviewed Mr. Zoldak. They both recalled the defendant’s describing the victim as a “good student” and “good kid,” and his saying that he liked her and felt bad for her. They also recounted the incident in February in which Mr. Zoldak comforted her.
The last witness called Wednesday was a student in the class in question. Megan Rengers, who graduated last week, said it was awkward when Mr. Zoldak referred to the situation that day, telling students he spent his weekend at the DA’s office.
“He was bothered that he had to go and talk about what was going on in our school district,” she said. “He said it was a waste of his time.”
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2620.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.