Allegheny County Police believe they have a violent serial rapist in custody, claiming Friday that evidence — including DNA — indicates he has raped three women at gunpoint in Wilmerding since 2014 and sexually assaulted another woman in Georgia more than a decade ago.
But questions linger about why it took nearly two years for a DNA match to be made between the Georgia rape and the earliest Wilmerding rape in February 2014; whether North Versailles police, who initially responded to the rapes, immediately contacted county police; and why authorities did not alert the public about the assaults.
Suspect Lawrence Jim Cook, 31, was already in the Allegheny County Jail on Friday since being held for trial in March in connection with a November rape in Wilmerding when detectives hauled him out of the lockup and brought him to police headquarters in Point Breeze. There they arrested him in two other rapes in Wilmerding in February 2014 and last July.
As he was led to a police car for the ride back to jail, Mr. Cook told reporters that he did not rape anyone.
“I’m innocent,” Mr. Cook said, calling the case a “set-up.” Asked his connection with the cases, he said “It was a drug transaction gone bad” — apparently referring to the November incident, in which the victim told police that Mr. Cook picked her up so she could buy marijuana before he allegedly raped her.
During a news conference to announce the additional charges, county police acting Superintendent James Morton and Medical Examiner Karl E. Williams detailed the investigation supervised by Sgt. Kenneth Ruckel that led detectives to Mr. Cook.
They said the DNA from an unknown suspect in the two earliest Wilmerding rape cases was put into a national DNA database overseen by the FBI. At that point, police said, it was not known that the cases were related, though the circumstances bore similarities.
On Nov. 11, a third rape occurred in Wilmerding in which the attacker wielded a gun. A month later, the national DNA system matched the genetic material of the unknown suspect in the 2014 rape to that of an unknown suspect in a 2005 rape in Savannah, Ga. and one in a 2010 auto theft in Garden City, Ga. Dr. Williams could not say why it took so long for the match to be made.
Detectives here contacted Georgia authorities and learned that the Savannah rape victim had identified her attacker as either “Law” or “Lawrence,” Sgt. Ruckel said. Using court records, crime databases and the name, detectives put together a small pool of possible suspects. They further narrowed the group by including only people born in Georgia. Eventually, Sgt. Ruckel said, Mr. Cook — who had connections in Georgia and Wilmerding — surfaced as the prime suspect.
On Jan. 19, county police contacted police in North Versailles, which covers Wilmerding, to inquire about any recent sexual assaults, Superintendent Morton said.
North Versailles police Chief James Matrazzo had previously said the victim initially was reluctant to cooperate — the county said she feared for her life — but that his department faxed information about the rape on the day it occurred to county police. Superintendent Morton on Friday disputed that account.
Investigators got a DNA swab from Mr. Cook in March and say they matched it to the 2014 case. Authorities are confident that there will also be a match to the November case within the next few weeks. As for the July case, however, Sgt. Ruckel said they will not be able to establish a match because “we don’t believe that the DNA [from that incident] is recoverable.”
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.