District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr.’s office plans to refile charges against Pittsburgh police Sgt. Stephen Matakovich, who was accused of punching an inebriated fan at Heinz Field in November in an incident recorded on surveillance video.
District Judge Robert Ravenstahl dismissed the charges against the sergeant after a preliminary hearing Monday.
“Clearly, there’s probable cause a crime was committed,” Mr. Zappala said Thursday. “That matter should be decided by a judge or a jury.”
Mr. Zappala said there was no justification for using force on Gabriel Despres, the 19-year-old who was struck by the sergeant at Heinz Field.
“I know the community is troubled,” Mr. Zappala said.
The decision was hailed by Elizabeth Pittinger, executive director of the Pittsburgh Citizen Police Review Board, who said the matter ought to be resolved in a courtroom.
Read More
“I think we’re all relieved that the incident is going to be publicly vetted in the process established for these issues,” she said. “There was a question about whether the officer used reasonable force, and that question is going to be answered in court. It should be vetted just like it would be for anybody else.”
Sgt. Matakovich’s attorney, Blaine Jones, declined to say whether he was disappointed by the decision, but said he and his client were braced for a trial date.
“We’re prepared,” he said.
Mr. Zappala said his office also relayed concerns to police Chief Cameron McLay about behavior of dozens of uniformed officers who attended Sgt. Matakovich’s hearing this week and applauded when the counts were dismissed.
“That should not occur,” Mr. Zappala said, adding that Chief McLay was investigating whether those officers were on duty at the time.
On Wednesday, Chief McLay said he supported the original decision to charge Sgt. Matakovich and would support a decision to refile. “Police are finders of fact,” Chief McLay said in the statement. “In the present case, the [Allegheny County] DA reviewed and felt there was sufficient evidence to substantiate criminal charges. With the facts before me, I supported that decision then, and if they decide to refile, I will support that decision as well.”
Security camera footage from Heinz Field shows Sgt. Matakovich push Mr. Despres to the ground with two hands then strike him several times. Mr. Despres was treated at a hospital for a bloody, swollen nose before spending the night in the Allegheny County Jail.
Mr. Despres, who was trying to gain entrance to the stadium to watch a high school football game after he drank heavily, faces a preliminary hearing March 16 on summary charges of defiant trespass, public drunkenness and underage drinking stemming from the incident.
Sgt. Matakovich said at Monday’s hearing that he had to take action because Mr. Despres took an aggressive stance and made a fist. Mr. Despres and other witnesses disputed those claims.
A Pittsburgh police use-of-force instructor also testified that Sgt. Matakovich’s “use of force was not reasonable.”
District Judge Ravenstahl did not elaborate on his decision to drop the charges in court and has declined to speak further about the ruling.
The FBI and U.S. Attorney’s office also are investigating, which came as no surprise to Chief McLay.
“The role of the FBI in these situations is to ensure the civil rights of all are protected. Given what has been occurring nationally, I am not surprised the FBI would have interest in this case,” the chief said.
Sgt. Matakovich remains on unpaid leave and an internal review by the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police is underway.
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com.or 412-263-2620. Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352. Dan Majors contributed to this report.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.