The sale of a grassy lot in Greenfield that for more than 60 years provided public access from the dead end at Coyne Terrace to Winterburn Avenue is still being contested two years after a private buyer won a bid on it at treasurer’s sale.
A neighborhood dust-up ensued when Beth Cronin bought the 97-by-40-foot lot in 2013. It sits between her house and another on Winterburn.
Some nearby residents contend it was sold in error, and Pittsburgh Councilman Corey O’Connor proposed legislation in July to nullify the sale and dedicate as public right of way the lot, steps and a turnaround for cars at the end of Coyne Terrace. But assistant city solicitor Nicole Manison stated in an October 2014 letter to the purchaser’s attorney that the lot was correctly included in the sale.
The city’s legal department is leery about trying to get it back, said Curt Conrad, chief of staff to Mr. O’Connor.
Ms. Cronin’s husband, Ray, strung orange netting and “no trespassing” signs across the steps for liability reasons and to keep people from using it as a shortcut, he said.
Residents of Coyne Terrace took their grievance over the loss of public access to City Council last week. They say the lot should never have been sold because it was a public right of way for pedestrian access to Winterburn.
One resident, Moshe Marvit, said neighbors have been talking to city officials “and everyone admits a mistake was made. It was a paper street mistaken for a yard.”
City officials would not comment, citing Mr. O’Connor’s pending legislation.
An October 2013 memo from the city finance department states that Allegheny County illegally assigned a lot-and-block number to the lot between the houses and to the turnaround, which provides access to the backs of three homes on Winterburn. “Only if the right of way had been vacated by council resolution can a number be assigned,” the memo reads. The county’s action “created a problem to this present day.”
Darren Gessler, a geographic information system analyst in the county’s Department of Real Estate, said the county in 2008 actually corrected a mistake it made in 1948, when the original 1930 developers of Coyne Terrace, John and Mary Coyne, ceded the street to the city but not the 97-foot lot. The county didn’t recognize that distinction and took the lot off its books.
In 2008, “someone notified us that the city doesn’t own it,” Mr. Gessler said. “We don’t know if the Coynes had a handshake agreement with the city” that it could be used as a public right of way, “but we had to put it back on the books.”
That meant the property was taxable. With liens of about $800, the city sold it in a treasurer’s deed, he said, adding, “I felt comfortable that what we did in 2008, we did it correctly.” The purchase price included the liens.
The sale was legal, said Mr. Conrad, adding, “so we are in a bind.”
The bind is felt on both sides. Ms. Cronin, who paid more than $1,000 for the lot, said she has suffered harassment from neighbors. She said neighbors call the police to complain about her occupation of the property, believing it to be a mistake.
“I have been paying taxes on the land for two years but I can’t use it,” she said.
Ray Cronin, Ms. Cronin’s husband, said he spoke to someone at public works to offer a walkway at the property’s edge for public access, “but they didn’t want it. They said they can’t insure something that wasn’t theirs.”
“Our biggest fear,” Mr. Conrad said, “is that people will be blocked off from public transit. We think the sale should never have happened but we’re at a loss as to what authority we have.”
Diana Nelson Jones: djones@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1626.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.