A North Braddock police sergeant responsible for monitoring an intoxicated woman in a police station holding cell left the building for an undetermined amount of time to “patrol the municipality” and returned to find her hanging in the lockup, District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. of Allegheny County said Thursday.
“The officer thought she was asleep or was in no distress at the time. He left the department to go out on patrol, and when he returned, she had committed suicide,” Mr. Zappala said.
While preliminary findings of an investigation by Allegheny County Police homicide detectives do not point to any criminality on the part of the sergeant or any other North Braddock officer in connection with Dana Thompson’s death Tuesday, Mr. Zappala said he is determined to improve monitoring of prisoners in holding cells throughout the county and plans to meet with the Allegheny County Chiefs of Police Association to hash out ideas.
“I think you can put protocols in place where you can take the feed from the camera in the cell block and send it back to your [mobile data terminal] in your car so you can continue to watch the person taken into custody, and somebody would be available — a firefighter, an EMT, just somebody — who could respond as quickly as possible to something like this,” Mr. Zappala said.
North Braddock police arrested Ms. Thompson, 43, of Turtle Creek on a charge of public intoxication. She was placed in a holding cell at the station at 11:50 p.m. Monday; 49 minutes later, Sgt. Brian Hodges, who was supposed to be monitoring her, found her hanging in the cell, a noose fashioned from her T-shirt around her neck and the cell bars.
The department’s chief, Dean Bazzone, said Sgt. Hodges was watching a camera feed of Ms. Thompson on a screen at a desk about 40 feet away from the cell. Chief Bazzone said earlier this week that the sergeant, whom he praised, “walked out the back door for a minute,” but he did not know why.
Mr. Zappala said he was briefed by a supervisor with the Allegheny County Police homicide squad, who told him that Sgt. Hodges had gone on patrol while Ms. Thompson — described by Chief Bazzone as “getting up and falling” — was alone in the holding cell. No other officer was in the station.
Chief Bazzone said he was unaware that Sgt. Hodges was on patrol. Sgt. Hodges could not be reached for comment.
Asked for clarification, county police Superintendent Charles Moffatt said: “Throughout this investigation, we have received numerous conflicting pieces of information. As we continue looking into this, we will try to resolve those conflicts.”
An autopsy showed that Ms. Thompson killed herself by hanging. Mr. Zappala said the police investigation reinforces that finding.
“The county police were satisfied that the camera feed showed her committing suicide,” Mr. Zappala said.
The district attorney said that from a legal perspective, police “generally do not have an obligation to keep somebody from committing suicide” unless there is a specific awareness of mental health issues, suicidal tendencies or an inclination or threat to hurt oneself.
“So there’s no indication that any of the officers on that shift were aware that she might hurt herself. Right now I don’t see any civil rights implications,” Mr. Zappala said. He added that police do have a responsibility for their prisoners’ welfare. He said, “It’s a practical consideration. If you have reason to believe that somebody could hurt themselves, then I expect you to keep your eye on them.”
Elbert Rucker, Ms. Thompson’s boyfriend, told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette that he told the arresting officer that she had been drinking and taking pills.
Mr. Zappala said he did not have enough information to determine whether Ms. Thompson’s death could have been avoided.
“My job is to assign whether circumstances lead to criminal conduct. I don’t see criminal conduct. But it’s not a result that anybody wants, and I think we can address that. It’s too late to help her, unfortunately, but there’s things we can do.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.