The prosecution says the case against Tex Ortiz is simple.

There was a court order awarding interim custody of his 2-year-old daughter to her maternal grandmother, and instead of abiding by it, he took the girl and hid her from police and family for a week before the situation ended with a standoff in Altoona.

“Mr. Ortiz, not liking what happened, decided to take matters into his own hands,” said assistant district attorney Lee Goldfarb during opening statements in Mr. Ortiz’s kidnapping trial Monday.

“If the defendant didn’t like it, there were proper avenues to explore. He knew we were looking for him, and he just didn’t care because he doesn’t think the law applies to him.”

Advertise with us

But defense attorney Amber Owens said that the prosecution’s characterization of what happened isn’t right.

She told the jury that the case started long before the Dec. 19 court order awarding custody of Jaleeyah Ortiz to her grandmother. Mr. Ortiz, 32, of Wilkinsburg had been living with his girlfriend and their daughter when the girlfriend suddenly died Oct. 21. Her client had custody of the girl after that.

“He’s adjusting to losing the love of his life. He needed to learn how to be a single parent,” Ms. Owens said. “But that wasn’t good enough for the grandparents.”

Lori Clark, the girl’s grandmother, sought the interim custody order in December because she was concerned about the type of home environment being provided by Mr. Ortiz. She claimed that his home was filthy, and that he was known to use illegal drugs. He was on electronic home monitoring for a drug case out of Blair County at the time he allegedly took his daughter.

Ms. Owens told the jury that when Ms. Clark obtained the interim custody order from Common Pleas Judge Mark V. Tranquilli, her client knew nothing about it and was not present.

Advertise with us

“Did he know his parental rights had been taken away? Did he have notice? He never had his chance in court,” she said.

After he was told to turn over his daughter, Mr. Ortiz became fearful, Ms. Owens said.

“It is the commonwealth’s burden to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that my client didn’t have authority to take his daughter,” the defense attorney said. “Jaleeyah was his child. Jaleeyah lived with him. He didn’t remove a child from a home. That child was his. He had rights to her.”

Ms. Owens told the jurors that her client would testify.

Prior to opening statements, Judge Donna Jo McDaniel, who is presiding over the trial, ruled that several of the witnesses the defense planned to call to testify about Mr. Ortiz’s state of mind and his belief he still had custody are not relevant to the charges and would not be permitted to testify.

Advertise with us

“This case is not about whether Mr. Ortiz is a good father who loved his child,” the judge said. “This is about whether he kidnapped the child and concealed her whereabouts. This case is about these three charges and nothing more.”

Also before the jury was sworn in, the prosecution extended, again, an offer to Mr. Ortiz that would have called for a sentence of 2-1/​2 to five years in prison on the kidnapping count.

He rejected the deal.

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter @PaulaReedWard.