Wilkinsburg Borough Council declined to take action Wednesday against one of its council members who was arrested over the weekend and charged with assaulting a woman during a dispute.

Carl D. Lewis, 38, was arrested Sunday after a woman told police he punched her in the face and dragged her by the hair down a some steps in an argument over vodka. He declined comment through his attorney, Tom Farrell, who accompanied him to Wednesday night's meeting.

The council was divided on how to handle the charge against Mr. Lewis.

Borough code does not allow the council to vote to remove a member unless the member has missed meetings, said borough solicitor Isabel Storch. But council Vice President Jason Cohn said the councilman's legal troubles were counterproductive to council's efforts to dispel the perception that crime is rampant in Wilkinsburg.

Advertise with us

In an interview, Mayor John Thompson said that it could create a distraction.

"It is not conducive to the efforts of council," he said.

Councilwoman Pamela Macklin countered that it was unfair to judge Mr. Lewis, who denied that he struck the woman, before he's been convicted.

"I believe in due process. I don't believe we should usurp that," she said.

Mr. Cohn proposed a motion to request that Mr. Lewis step down, which failed 4 to 5. Mr. Lewis, council president Eugenia Moore and council members Barbara Ervin, Paige Trice and Pamela Macklin voted no. Mr. Cohn and council members Vanessa McCarthy-Johnson, Michael Lefebvre, and Tracey Evans supported it.

Advertise with us

Mr. Lewis is scheduled to appear next Thursday for a preliminary before District Judge Kim Hoots in Wilkinsburg.

According to a criminal complaint, Michaelann DiIorio, 47, told officers that she and her boyfriend, Timothy Doman, along with her two children, were visiting Mr. Lewis, their landlord and friend. She said they had dinner and decided to play a board game afterwards.

Ms. DiIorio said Mr. Lewis became angry when she poured herself a shot from a vodka bottle. When he told her she had to pay for it, they argued and he told her to leave.

She said he flipped the game over and shoved her from her chair. When she got up, she said, he punched her five times in the forehead and face, then grabbed her by the hair when she tried to fight back and dragged her down the stairs to the front door.

Ms. DiIorio said her boyfriend intervened and helped her leave the house.

Advertise with us

Police said she had three "large contusions" on her forehead and redness on her face. An ambulance took her to UPMC Shadyside.

Mr. Doman told police the same story, according to the affidavit, but Mr. Lewis said she was the one who attacked him. He said he had asked Ms. DiIorio to leave because she was drinking too much and "getting loud," and when he tried to escort her out of the house, she started swinging at him.

He said he and Mr. Doman physically removed her from the house but he denied hitting her and said he didn't know how she got the contusions on her head.

Police sided with Ms. DiIorio, based on the injuries and Mr. Doman's statement, and took Mr. Lewis to jail. He was released on a $5,000 bond.

It's at least the second time Mr. Lewis, who is in his second term, has been accused of assaulting someone while holding public office.

Advertise with us

In 2002, Wilkinsburg paid $22,000 to former borough clerk Betty Lofton to settle a complaint she brought against the borough with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission after she said Mr. Lewis harassed her when she spurned his sexual advances.

She said the harassment culminated in an incident on Aug. 28, 2002, in which he turned off her computer and smacked her on the shoulder for a delay in placing a call to the fire chief.

Police responded to the altercation but did not charge Mr. Lewis. Borough council took no action against him because there were no witnesses.

Ms. Lofton filed an emergency protection-from-abuse request afterwards, according to newspaper reports at the time.

She could not be reached yesterday.

Police Chief Ophelia Coleman has not returned messages seeking information about the current case.