About three weeks ago, James Sapinsky's fiancee found him shot to death in his living room, with bracelets of blue rope around his wrists -- as if he had been bound -- and blood smeared around his Spring Church home.
He looked to be the victim of a gruesome homicide, perhaps by an intruder: A window had been broken, and his body was surrounded by papers related to his pending divorce, torn and spattered with blood.
But then the evidence started mounting -- against Mr. Sapinsky.
On Friday, Armstrong County District Attorney Scott Andreassi and state police announced that they determined that Mr. Sapinsky, a 43-year-old former nurse, had staged his own murder.
"Very odd. This is a first for me," Mr. Andreassi said.
Mr. Sapinsky's elaborate scheme led state police detectives astray, at least for a time. They searched his home, sorted through his trash and interviewed friends, family and associates.
"In my 14 years as district attorney, this was one of the most exhaustive investigations undertaken," Mr. Andreassi said. "As of today, we consider this matter to be closed."
On Jan. 16, police said Mr. Sapinsky's fiancee, Kimberly Peterson, called police at around 9 a.m. after finding him shot dead in the living room of his home on Birch Street.
When a Kiskiminetas police officer arrived on scene and saw that someone had been fatally shot, he turned and left, because such investigations are handled by state police. But he reported that Mr. Sapinsky was found bound to a chair and that there were scrawlings in blood on the wall.
Mr. Andreassi said the officer was mistaken. State police found Mr. Sapinsky lying on the carpet with his arms splayed out. Each wrist was looped separately with rope, but his hands were not bound together, and state police found no writing in blood.
The affidavit said police found blood-stained legal documents from his pending divorce from Mona Sapinsky, including some related to a custody dispute over the couple's 9-year-old daughter. He had been shot in the chest and had recent facial injuries. A .38-caliber revolver with a spent shell in its cylinder was found stuffed in a loveseat.
Investigators also found a small window had been broken near the front door, and someone had reported seeing a person walking by a picture window in the house about 2 a.m. the day the body was found. Mr. Sapinsky's blood was found around the house, smeared in the hallway leading to the living room and in the front doorway.
But Mr. Andreassi said Friday that investigators determined that "the location of the blood evidence was not suggestive of any kind of struggle."
Forensic pathologist Dr. Cyril H. Wecht determined that Mr. Sapinsky had been shot at an upward angle with the gun pressed to his chest and that he likely lived three to five minutes, giving him time to stash the gun. The loops of rope tied separately around his wrists made it appear he had been bound and had managed to free himself. But the section that would have bound his wrists together was cut with scissors, not torn.
"There was quite a bit of planning that went into it," Mr. Andreassi said. "That's what we discovered going through the evidence."
Searching through his trash, detectives found that since Mr. Sapinsky had been let go from his job at Forbes Regional Hospital in Monroeville, he had fallen behind on all of his bills -- his mortgage, his credit cards -- except for one: his life insurance policy.
And at a handful of days prior to his death, he had sent his son, a student at Indiana University of Pennsylvania, a few hundred dollars in cash. The son said the gesture was unusual. On the underside of the envelope's flap, a note was written -- "Work hard" -- that state police confirmed was in his handwriting.
Mr. Andreassi and state police theorized that Mr. Sapinsky was trying to avenge his wife.
But he admits that the suicide is puzzling. A calendar in the kitchen indicated he was to marry Ms. Peterson in June. His divorce proceeding was going amicably, his attorney indicated, though it had been marred by animosity in the past.
Mr. Andreassi said he met with Sapinsky family members Friday morning to explain the suicide ruling.
"The family had to accept that a loved one had done this to himself," he said. "It's something that they are going to have to live with."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.