Dov Ratchkauskas quickly doubled his investment when he sold a Penn Hills house to Tiffany Webb in 2008. On the same day he took title to the previously foreclosed three-bedroom Cape Cod on Universal Road for $25,000, he sold it to Ms. Webb, a private duty nurse, getting what investigators say was $54,939.

The quick and profitable transaction put a family in a house that had stood vacant. But it also led to the draining of Ms. Webb's savings, as electrical and plumbing problems, undisclosed prior to closing, mounted.

After two years of home ownership, she could no longer pay the mortgage, and the lender foreclosed, scuttling her credit rating and forcing her and her son, now 8, back to renting. "I'm going to have to live with this on my credit, because they got me," said Ms. Webb, 29, as she held her second son, 4 months old, in their Sheraden rental home.

PDF

Advertise with us

See a list of property transactions, as documented in public records, involving Dov Ratchkauskas and George Kubini.

From 2007 through June 2010, Mr. Ratchkauskas and his then-partner, George Kubini, bought 170 local properties for "over $4.5 million," and sold them for "over $10 [million]," according to documents in a U.S. Secret Service investigation that resulted in federal indictments of the two men for fraud last month. The investigation provides a glimpse into the world of post-foreclosure property deals, where a fast-cash mentality creates investor windfalls and buyer pitfalls.

Post-foreclosure properties have become a meaningful part of the real estate market. In Allegheny County, for instance, the sheriff's office sold 8,967 foreclosed properties at auction from 2007 through 2010 -- an average of 2,242 a year, and nearly one-seventh of total house sales. That volume has attracted many investors.

"Post-foreclosure schemes are just one of the many manifestations of 'fraud for profit' type mortgage schemes that we see," said Eric Zahren, special agent in charge of the Secret Service's Pittsburgh office. "In the course of investigating many of these cases, specifically in reviewing property records, we often see the same properties show up again and again."

Ms. Webb said she was renting in the Hill District when she saw an ad reading, "Why pay rent when you can own?" She called, and soon met with Dov Ratchkauskas, whose customers know him as "Dave," at the Universal Road house. She did not know it then, but until the day of her closing, title to the home remained with Wachovia Equity Services, which took it in foreclosure in 2007.

Advertise with us

She found windows that wouldn't open, moldy caulking around the sink, dirty rings on the garage floor. "He asked me to write down a list of things," she said, and she did so, thinking that he would fix them.

'You can have it'

Ms. Webb wondered why the price on the paperwork was $79,000, when she was paying much less. Mr. Ratchkauskas "said, 'Don't worry about it; that number means nothing,' " said Ms. Webb.

Seeking to avoid another rent payment, Ms. Webb agreed to close on the property with the understanding that Mr. Ratchkauskas would address the to-do list in the days that followed. But at the closing, she said, the attorney flipped on a recorder and announced that the sale was "as-is," with no warranties.

According to Secret Service special agent Daniel Fisher's 42-page affidavit in the case against Mr. Ratchkauskas and Mr. Kubini, that official $79,000 sales price included a fictitious, $18,856 down payment listed on the paperwork in order to give false confidence to the bank issuing a mortgage to Ms. Webb. The Secret Service is part of a 3-year-old, 11-agency Mortgage Fraud Task Force, led by the U.S. Attorney's Office, that has charged more than 100 brokers, appraisers, property buyers and sellers, and attorneys.

Advertise with us

The lack of down payments is central to the case against Mr. Ratchkauskas and Mr. Kubini, which alleges that in dozens of cases, banks were told of buyer payments that did not exist. According to the affidavit, they prepared two sets of mortgage papers, one set for the banks, showing buyer down payments ranging from $9,140 to $31,527, and another, secret set showing what the agent called the "reality down payment" of zero.

Ms. Webb confirmed that she made no down payment -- a rarity when buying a house. But any sense that she'd gotten a deal quickly evaporated. She had to spend thousands of dollars fixing the electrical system. The central air didn't work. The upstairs plumbing leaked into the walls.

Her pleas to Mr. Ratchkauskas, and once to Mr. Kubini, for help were brushed off, she said.

Then the sewage backed up.

"It hurt my son's feelings that we had to be standing out in the freezing cold, with the firemen all around" pumping foul water out of her house, she said.

Advertise with us

When she ran through her savings, and missed a few mortgage payments while scrambling to pay for fixes, Chase Home Finance foreclosed on her mortgage, on which she owed $60,848. An agent for the lender called her to ask whether there was a way to work out the debt.

"I said, 'Ma'am, for all of the trouble this place has been, you can have it,' " Ms. Webb said.

It now sits empty.

Back to foreclosure

Mr. Ratchkauskas, who pleaded not guilty Jan. 19, declined to be interviewed for this story.

Advertise with us

Mr. Kubini, approached in the driveway of his Penn Hills home, said, "They just charged me recently. I pleaded not guilty, so I can't comment right now."

Mr. Kubini's attorney, Kevin R. Zinski, noted that the one mortgage professional quoted in the Secret Service affidavit "made it very clear that my client never accepted any kickbacks and never wanted any kickbacks" from the loans.

Both men are out on $10,000 bond.

Mr. Ratchkauskas and Mr. Kubini were officers in Admiral Capital Management, Real Estate Choice Investments, Realty Choice Investments, Quality Homes Real Estate and Pittsburgh Capital Management, according to the affidavit. They operated out of offices in Squirrel Hill and Shadyside.

The businesses "purchased properties typically out of foreclosure and then quickly sold those properties at substantial profits," Agent Fisher wrote.

Advertise with us

When a mortgage goes sour, a foreclosing lender initially tries to recoup the amount it was due on the loan, but it may eventually settle for much less.

"As a property sits, the carrying costs to the bank increase -- taxes, insurance, maintenance, utilities, etc., and the risk of vandalism and copper/aluminum theft increases," said Dan Murrer, vice president of RealSTATs, a local real estate information service. "As time progresses, the bank drops the asking price in an effort to move the property, resulting in the disparity between market value and price."

Investors swoop in, seeking to buy low and sell high -- which is legal. The problem, according to the affidavit, was that Mr. Ratchkauskas and Mr. Kubini led buyers into mortgages that were "based on a number of false representations," including fake down payments and exaggerated accounts of the borrowers' assets. According to the affidavit and indictment, Mr. Ratchkauskas and Mr. Kubini worked with a network of mortgage brokers and attorneys, some of whom have since been indicted and some of whom have pleaded guilty, to arrange the mortgages.

Garfield Gray and his wife, Maria, planned to rent-to-own a home in 2008, but Mr. Ratchkauskas and Mr. Kubini told them they could qualify for a mortgage immediately, according to Mr. Gray. The Secret Service affidavit alleges that one set of mortgage papers underlying their purchase showed a $17,660 down payment on what was listed as a $67,500 sale, and the other set showed no down payment.

It wasn't until after the closing that they discovered the huge problems with their new home -- the first the couple had owned -- in Sheraden. It had a leaky roof, a backed-up toilet and electrical wiring so old that no electrician would repair it. "Dave" was unreachable.

Advertise with us

"There were a lot promises that weren't kept. It was just a disaster," said Mr. Gray, 62.

Real Estate Choice Investments had purchased the property from a foreclosing lender for $25,000, according to deed records. It got $37,075 at closing two months later, according to the affidavit.

Fears that the wiring would start a fire made the Grays abandon the house. Chase Home Finance filed for foreclosure in 2009. Government-backed firm Fannie Mae, which buys many mortgages, took the house through sheriff's sale in 2009 and sold it to an investment company for $11,400.

The affidavit lists 27 transactions on which lenders were told of down payments that, it alleges, did not exist. A Post-Gazette search of civil court filings shows that 11 of the mortgages underlying those 27 sales have been subject to foreclosure filings, all by Chase Home Finance.

Chase did not respond to a request for comment.

Advertise with us

International interests

According to the Secret Service affidavit, Mr. Ratchkauskas and his wife spent a lot of time away from their $332,500 Squirrel Hill home.

They bought a 2001 Cirrus single engine plane in 2003, according to the affidavit, and by late 2009 they still owed $152,206 on it. They flew repeatedly to Ukraine, the Bahamas, the Dominican Republic, Florida and Israel. Mr. Ratchkauskas is a naturalized U.S. citizen who also holds Israeli citizenship, according to court papers filed by his attorney, Stanley W. Greenfield.

The day after posting bond, Mr. Ratchkauskas, through Mr. Greenfield, filed a motion seeking court approval to travel to Hawaii the next day for a scheduled vacation for himself, his wife and their three children. According to the motion, they had booked two rooms at the Ritz Carlton Kapalua.

U.S. District Judge Nora Barry Fischer denied the request.

Advertise with us

The couple has sent money abroad, making four- and five-figure transfers to Israel and Ukraine, and a $50,000 transfer in 2007 to a Swiss bank account, according to the affidavit.

Although not part of the criminal case, records show the breadth of Mr. Ratchkauskas' business interests: The sale by Realty Choice Investments, since late 2009, of at least 20 rental properties to owners who appear to live outside of the Pittsburgh area.

Tenants at some of those properties said they still send rent checks to Mr. Ratchkauskas' P.O. Box, and did not know the actual owners of their homes. It is legal for a firm to manage a property for an out-of-town owner.

Colleen Stevenson does not believe she has met Josef and Dvora Malka, the owners since September of the Penn Hills house she rents through Mr. Ratchkauskas. She said Mr. Ratchkauskas brought by two people whom he described as "investors" for a tour during the recent Steelers-Ravens playoff game.

Mr. Greenfield said of the rental homes, "None of anything you are checking out in connection with those homes has a thing to do with the indictment."