On Election Day in McKeesport, voters showed what they thought of a recent lawsuit intended to block city employees from running for office.

In the contentious school board election, the electorate ousted incumbent President Ocie Paige and elected all four candidates who were targeted by the lawsuit to fill four of the five empty seats. Democrat Joe Chiaverini captured the fifth seat.

Jim Brown, Steven Kondrosky, Joe Lopretto and Christopher Halaszynski, all city employees, won over Republicans Jerome Halaszynski and Mr. Paige.

"It speaks volumes about what the public thinks of the lawsuit," said McKeesport Mayor Jim Brewster.

Advertise with us

Earlier this year, school board member Dave Donato sued Mr. Brewster over city employees running for office. Charging that the mayor was trying to take control of the school district by having city employees run, Mr. Donato invoked a provision of McKeesport's Home Rule Charter that prohibits city employees from soliciting or receiving campaign funds for public office.

Mr. Kondrosky, who is an administrator for the City of McKeesport, was the only city employee not named in the suit.

Late last month, Judge Eugene F. Scanlon Jr. dismissed the lawsuit, saying that nothing in the McKeesport Home Rule Charter specifically prohibits city employees from running for elected office.

Calling the lawsuit a crime and a waste of taxpayer money, Mr. Brewster said Tuesday night that the court rectified the problem by giving the public the ability to decide.

"It isn't the mayor saying they could run. It's the voting public," the mayor said. "Once the judge said the names stayed on the ballot, the people could have opted not to vote at all. They could have voted for the other two people that were on the ballot. The democratic process worked."

Advertise with us

The provision Mr. Donato cited also grants the mayor the right either to fire employees who are running for office or force them to give up campaigning. Mr. Brewster assured the candidates he would support them and never make them choose between their jobs and elected office.

"I kept telling the mayor, 'I don't want to run because I don't want to lose my job.' He guaranteed me I wouldn't lose my job," Mr. Lopretto said to a crowd gathered to watch the election returns and support the candidates.

Mr. Brewster responded that he didn't want to lose a good lieutenant, either.

Both Mr. Lopretto and Christopher Halaszynski are employed by McKeesport's Police Department. Mr. Brown is the Parks and Recreation director.

This election marks Mr. Brown's third attempt at running for school board while being employed as recreation director.

Advertise with us

"When I ran the first two times, I never had a problem as far as a lawsuit," Mr. Brown said. "Then when there are three other city employees that want to run for office, all of a sudden there's a big lawsuit."

In the 1980s, Mr. Donato also served as recreation director for the city while sitting on the school board, and in the years since, the debate over city employees running for office has continued. Most recently, current board member Mark Holtzman is the deputy chief of police.

Mr. Donato's lawsuit wasn't the only issue surrounding the school board elections. This spring, he and current board member Lori Spando sought to run for re-election before their present terms expires.

The Commonwealth Court upheld an order by the county Common Pleas Court to have their names removed from the election ballot because each member is only halfway through a four-year term.

Mr. Donato has previously acknowledged his suit against the mayor had elements of retaliation because of his and Ms. Spando's names being removed from the ballot.

Advertise with us

"When you have an election, there's always a lot of bitterness afterwards," the mayor said Tuesday night to the crowd of supporters. "That has to heal, and the people in this room have to take it away."

Mr. Chiaverini, a restaurant owner and civil site designer, felt that while the lawsuit treated the city employees unfairly, all the candidates ran a clean campaign. He also expressed optimism that the school board will unite to vote for "the best results for the city."

Mr. Paige could not be reached for comment yesterday.