With the May primary election a month away, Machiavellian political maneuvering in McKeesport is in full swing.
The seven-candidate race for five open seats on the McKeesport Area school board has spawned three legal actions involving school board members and city employees.
The first two actions, filed by candidates James Brown and Joseph Chiaverini on March 13, were petitions to set aside the nomination petitions of board members Dave Donato and Lori Spando, who both have two years remaining on their four-year terms.
The third action is a lawsuit Mr. Donato has brought against the mayor of McKeesport over employees running for office.
The first two actions fall under a provision of Act 45 of 2006 amending the Pennsylvania Election Code. The provision says candidates are not permitted to run for an office they already hold if their terms do not expire in the election year.
Mr. Donato and Ms. Spando had submitted affidavits to the Allegheny County Department of Elections affirming their eligibility to run for the office, but each had crossed out language on the affidavit affirming they were not already holding the office to which they sought election.
A week after the legal petitions were filed, the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas ordered that Mr. Donato's and Ms. Spando's nominations be set aside.
The Elections Department has removed their names from the list of ballot candidates.
The two board members have appealed the decision to the Commonwealth Court and are scheduled to have a telephone conference with the Harrisburg court tomorrow.
"I think we're going to prevail," said Mr. Donato, who argues that the 2006 change to the Election Code is unconstitutional because it is unsupported elsewhere in state and federal law. He asserts that the code was changed by lawmakers in response to his and Ms. Spando's last successful run for office in 2005.
In 2005, both members had two years of their terms remaining. They chose to run for office, were re-elected and consequently gave up their existing seats. By doing so, they created two vacancies, which were filled by board appointments rather than district-wide elections. That gave him and Ms. Spando an opportunity to have a say in who was appointed, which Mr. Donato said they used to their advantage to appoint board members who did not have close ties to the City of McKeesport and who would vote independently in the best interests of the school district.
The terms of those appointed members, Ocie Paige and Paula Milko, expire this year. Mr. Paige is seeking election; Ms. Milko is not.
This strategy was so successful, Mr. Donato said, that he and Ms. Spando had hoped to do it again this year.
Though Mr. Donato defends the strategy as a way for candidates with outside chances of financing a campaign or winning an election to be appointed to a post on the board, not everyone sees the advantage as fair.
One of them is Mr. Brown, who in addition to being a third-time candidate for the board is also the recreation director for the City of McKeesport.
"Sure, they're going to be frontrunners," said Mr. Brown, referring to the advantage incumbent board members have over candidates who have yet to make names for themselves. He said he joined Mr. Chiaverini in bringing the action to prevent the two board members from running because, "I felt I got shafted last time and I didn't want to get shafted again."
While the election code so far seems to be in Mr. Brown's favor in keeping Mr. Donato and Ms. Spando off the ballot, another law may yet deflate his and other candidates' hopes of gaining a seat on the school board.
In the third lawsuit related to the school board race, Mr. Donato sues McKeesport Mayor James Brewster. The suit invokes a provision of McKeesport's Home Rule Charter that prohibits city employees from soliciting or receiving campaign funds for public office. That same provision also grants the mayor the right to either fire employees who are running for office or force them to give up campaigning.
Mr. Brown is one of the employees named in the suit. Joseph Lopretto and Christopher Halaszynski, both employed by McKeesport's Police Department, are also named. A fourth candidate, Steven Kondrosky, who is an administrator for the City of McKeesport, is not named in the suit.
The lawsuit asserts that the city employees running for the school board constitute a thinly veiled attempt by the city to take over of the school district.
Mr. Brewster has yet to file an answer to the complaint, which was dated March 23, and he would not comment on how he would respond to the suit.
The mayor, who has called for more partnership opportunities between the school system and the city, especially where the use of school facilities is concerned, has remarked on the field of current school board candidates.
"I am a proponent of making those [school] facilities available to the taxpayer," he said. "In this particular election, I think the people running for the school district understand that those barriers need to be broken down and these facilities have to be made available to the public. I think it makes perfect sense and that's the fair thing to do."
Mr. Brown said if he is forced to give up his job or a seat on the board, as the suit against the mayor would have him do, he would give up the unpaid school board position. He and others have noted the timing of Mr. Donato's suit, also remarking that Mr. Donato never raised legal objections about McKeesport Deputy Chief of Police Mark Holtzman being a board member.
Mr. Donato has acknowledged that there is a retaliatory component to his suit against the mayor because of his and Ms. Spando's names being struck from the ballot.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.