The candidates for mayor of Monroeville agree on a number of issues, but significant differences separate them.
Incumbent James Lomeo is an outsider who puts a premium on procedure and ideas. Richard Buxter is an insider who acts on instincts.
Both are Democrats, but Mr. Buxter, the councilman from the 3rd Ward, is on the ballot as a Republican. He mounted a last-minute write-in campaign after the state Supreme Court, at Mr. Lomeo's prompting, struck 7th Ward Councilman Harold Katofsky from the Democratic primary ballot.
The candidates have been on the same side on recent issues.
Mr. Buxter voted against Wal-Mart's plans to build a store near Pitcairn. Mr. Lomeo was opposed to the store.
Mr. Lomeo vetoed the Haymaker Pointe townhouse rezoning. Mr. Buxter was one of only two councilmen to support him.
Mr. Lomeo is opposed to large billboards on the Parkway East. Mr. Buxter was the only council member to vote against a request by Interstate Outdoor Advertising, but he is open to a proposed zoning change that would allow large billboards "if it is done properly."
Both would like to lower the 1.5 percent earned income tax.
Their backgrounds, however, are very different.
Mr. Buxter went into the workforce after graduating from Gateway High School in 1976. He started out in construction, and he has worked for Monroeville Mall for 24 years, making his way up to operations director. He supervises 60 employees who handle maintenance, security, landscaping, snow removal and power systems.
Mr. Buxter was appointed to council in 1999 to fill in for the 3rd Ward councilman who resigned. He won a special election to finish the term and then won re-election.
Mr. Lomeo graduated from Serra Catholic High School, Washington & Jefferson College and the University of Pittsburgh School of Law.
He has worked as an assistant solicitor and assistant prosecutor for the county, but most of his career has been in real estate law.
He worked in his parents' mortgage business but sued them in 1994, claiming they had fired him and reneged on a deal to sell the business to him. The case was settled in 1996; he went to work for a bank and then for himself.
"We all have things we'd like to do over," he said. "It's not easy to talk about."
He compared the family drama to a divorce with complicated emotional and financial issues, and he said the damage has been repaired.
He said the dispute has no bearing on his fitness for mayor. But he also said it made him less judgmental and thus a better lawyer and mayor.
"It gave me perspective," he said. "I like to look at all sides and to treat people fairly."
Mr. Lomeo served on the planning commission for eight years, and he was unopposed when he ran for mayor four years ago.
This time, the Monroeville Democratic Committee endorsed Mr. Katofsky, and when he was knocked off the ballot, a subgroup of the committee encouraged Mr. Buxter to run.
Mr. Katofsky, Councilman Dave Kucherer, Councilman Mark Dale and state Sen. Sean Logan, D-Monroeville, have contributed to Mr. Buxter's campaign.
Mr. Lomeo is cordial to council members but shuns their one-party clubbiness. He considers his outside status an advantage in doing the public's business.
One issue they have clashed on is employee benefits. Last year council passed an ordinance to require nonunion employees to contribute to their health care insurance. Mr. Lomeo vetoed the law, and Mr. Buxter voted to override the veto.
Rising health care costs are straining the budget, Mr. Buxter said, and it would be better for employees to share the burden than to lay them off.
"We have the greatest workforce in Monroeville," he said, "and I'd like to see everyone gainfully employed until retirement."
Mr. Lomeo agrees that employees may have to contribute to health care eventually, but he said it is bad policy to deduct for health insurance when Monroeville spends $800,000 a year on outside attorneys and engineers.
He said legal fees, for example, could be cut by $200,000 by hiring a staff lawyer or setting a flat rate with the outside solicitor.
"It's not fair that the politically connected people are not questioned, but the guy who works on a garbage truck and has no voice is asked to make a contribution," he said.
The mayor runs council meetings but has no vote except to break a tie or veto legislation. But both men say it is a ceremonial position worth fighting for.
"My role is to set the vision and make constructive comments," Mr. Lomeo said. "This is what we should be doing. This is where we're going."
"The mayor instills policy," Mr. Buxter said. "He needs the cooperation of council, and I can work with whatever council is in place."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.