Both judicial candidates in Monroeville-Pitcairn agree that experience matters and that theirs is the experience that matters most.
Democrat Laura Cohen, 47, cites her training as a lawyer. Republican Jeffrey Herbst, 50, points to 25 years as a police officer.
The winner Nov. 8 will replace Walter Luniewski, who is retiring, and preside over 5,800 cases a year.
Traffic infractions account for more than half of the court's work, but the new judge also will rule on civil matters involving less than $8,000, protection from abuse petitions, search warrants, criminal arraignments and preliminary hearings.
The position pays $65,000 a year and the term lasts six years.
"Voters should care a lot," Ms. Cohen said. "This court deals with their personal lives, their property, going to jail or not going to jail."
She came to the law after several years as a homemaker, graduating from University of Pittsburgh School of Law in 1996 and then opening the Family Legal Center in Monroeville.
"What drives me? I put myself through college as a single mom. For a long time, I've known that my goal is to be part of the judiciary. My personality, my temperament, my compassion, and now my experience are suited to that," Ms. Cohen said.
She wants to implement a more rigorous community service program for first-time juvenile offenders. Now, she says, teens do a few chores and then "hang out with the guys."
She promises to supervise more closely; coordinate the program with other governmental, civic, religious and business organizations; and divert teens from juvenile court.
"The purpose is to show them they have to conform with society, or else they're in a bunch of trouble. ... It's important when you do something wrong to give back to the community," she said.
Mr. Herbst retired this year from the Monroeville police department. He holds a master's degree in criminology from Indiana University of Pennsylvania and in June took the four-week minor judiciary course that non-lawyers are required to pass before they may serve as district judges.
"I've had close to 30 years dealing with the magistrate's office, as a police officer and in retail security for Kaufmann's," Mr. Herbst said. "I feel like I'm too young to retire completely and this is something I thought would be interesting and another way to continue serving the community."
He said his years as a police officer taught him how to weigh facts and circumstances and make decisions. "It's very similar to what a district justice does."
Mr. Herbst said the community service program for juveniles is already effective and teens accused of serious offenses may not be diverted from juvenile court.
He said he would provide evening hours once a week for people who are unable to go to court during the day. .
Of 550 district judges statewide, Mr. Herbst said, about 60 are lawyers. "This position was not set up with attorneys in mind," he said.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.