If choice is the essence of an election, this is quite a time in Monroeville.

Voters will have the opportunity on Nov. 8 to choose among candidates for the first time in several years.

They can shift the balance of power by choosing new people to replace the four council members who may not run again.

And they will make their choices as Monroeville faces critical decisions that will shape the town's future for years to come.

Advertise with us

The population has stagnated at around 29,350, and the median age is getting older. The tax base is strong, but the commercial district faces strong challenges from newer developments outside of Monroeville.

The big issues in Monroeville are about managing patterns of growth -- balancing commercial interests against residential interests, expanding the tax base and attracting new residents without compromising the quality of life.

Wal-Mart recently lost a rezoning request for a superstore, but another developer won the right to build townhouses next to single-family houses.

A large park is being built, but officials haven't found the $8.5 million to $14 million needed for the centerpiece, a community recreation center.

A proposed streetscape beautification program and a new comprehensive plan have stalled. Companies are pressuring Monroeville to allow larger billboards and colorful electronic signs.

Advertise with us

Previously, voters have had few choices. No Republicans ran for council and Democrats were unopposed in five out of seven primary race, in the 2001 and 2003 elections.

This year, only 5th Ward Democrat Marshall Boone has had no competition. The other Democrats had opponents in the primary, and three Republicans are running for council.

The mayoral and tax collector races, which will be covered in future articles, also have two candidates.

1st Ward

The 1st Ward is ground zero for development issues. The new park is being built there. Wal-Mart tried to build there. Haymaker Pointe townhouses will be built at the edge of the district.

Advertise with us

Democrat Frank Franci, 47, is running against Republican Peter Titus, 50. Neither candidate responded to telephone requests for an interview.

Mr. Franci is a regional manager for East Coast Salon Services, where he supervises 11 salespeople. Mr. Titus is a self-employed real estate salesman.

The park is a "done deal," Mr. Franci said in an interview before the primary. He said he will reserve judgment on the proposed community center until he can evaluate how much stress the new park puts on the neighborhood.

Mr. Titus lives next to the park, and he has spoken out against it at public meetings. He preferred a scaled-down version, with greater emphasis on passive activities like hiking than on active sports like soccer.

He criticized council for rezoning land for Haymaker Pointe. Before the developer asked for new zoning, he noted, council condemned an adjacent property for flood control, and the developer agreed to cover the costs.

Advertise with us

"It's pretty tough to be objective when the developer had already contributed funds to the municipality,' he said.

3rd Ward

Both 3rd Ward candidates have represented the municipality in official capacities -- Republican Peter Bobich Jr., 54, as a code enforcement officer and Democrat Deborah Hartwick, 44, as a member of the planning commission.

Mr. Bobich resigned his position in 1999, after state police charged him with running a gambling operation. He pleaded guilty to four misdemeanor counts of bookmaking and paid a $1,000 fine.

He went to work for a family beer distributorship. That business failed and he opened Pete's Monroeville Beverage. It closed a year ago.

Advertise with us

Before the May primary, he owed the state $14,293 in unpaid sales taxes and penalties. Since then, the state has assessed another $3,561 for unpaid sales taxes, Citibank has sued for $9,451 on a credit card debt, and Parkvale Bank has sued for $41,236 for an unpaid loan.

"What's happened in my personal life has nothing to do with my candidacy," Mr. Bobich said. "I'm a good person and a good Christian. ... I don't like being bashed. All my issues are in court and they will be resolved.

He said he can't change the past but he has learned.

"Maybe my mistakes in business show me how not to let the same mistakes happen again."

Mr. Bobich said he probably would have followed the wishes of the public and opposed the Wal-Mart zoning. He favored the Haymaker Pointe rezoning because many people prefer townhouses to traditional houses.

Advertise with us

Billboard and business sign issues can't be addressed, he said, until the zoning ordinance, written in 1984, is updated. Zoning should be revised to attract small business, he said before the primary election. Sign laws, for example, should be made less restrictive.

"We're 22 years behind the times," he said yesterday.

Ms. Hartwick is a dental hygienist. She has served on the planning commission, an advisory board that reviews land use proposals, since 1996.

As chairwoman of the commission, she has been in the forefront of revising the town's comprehensive plan.

She voted against the Wal-Mart and Haymaker Pointe rezoning.

Advertise with us

Wal-Mart was a tough decision, she said, because the proposed store was the landowner's best shot at developing the property. The store would have produced tax revenue, she said, but it would have created too much traffic.

"We cannot create another Route 22 down there," she said. "Putting all that commercial development there would destroy that intersection."

She would have preferred a mixed-use development at Haymaker Point that would put new houses next to the existing houses and then allow patio homes and townhouses farther away.

She has opposed easing up on business signs and billboard regulations.

"I don't see a need for bigger billboards," she said, and she doubted that billboards would produce much tax revenue. But she wouldn't comment on a proposed billboard ordinance because she had not yet deliberated with the rest of the planning commission.

Advertise with us

7th Ward

This contest is a reprise of the May primary, when Barbara Masters, 59, and Clarence Ramsey, 62, opposed one another for the Democratic nomination. Mr. Ramsey won, but Ms. Masters got enough write-in votes on the Republican ballot to qualify for the general election.

She changed her registration to Republican, though not required to do so.

"Those people were nice enough to write me in and I've opted to show them the same respect," she said. "But party affiliation means nothing. If someone asks you to do something for them, you don't ask their party."

She is retired as a school bus driver and has worked as a bookkeeper. She has been an energetic community volunteer, most recently as treasurer of Monroeville Night Out.

Advertise with us

She would have opposed Wal-Mart because of the traffic burden and Haymaker Pointe because the property is surrounded by single-family housing. She thinks billboards would be acceptable on the Parkway East.

Frugality is an overriding issue. Taxpayers are struggling to make ends meet, she said. So she would support a community center at the park to provide programs for children, but she would pay close attention to the costs of building and staffing the facility.

Mr. Ramsey is retired from Westinghouse as an electronics technician. He has volunteered as a firefighter and served on the planning commission and human resources board.

He would have voted for Wal-Mart, to create jobs and clean up an eyesore.

He would not take a position on other issues.

Advertise with us

"I don't want a fixed position on anything," Mr. Ramsey said. "Too many things can change."

Instead, he promised to keep an open mind, listen to all sides, weigh the facts and work out a positive course of action.