Voters in Monroeville and Pitcairn will decide next week whether a judge should be a lawyer.
One candidate for magisterial district judge runs a car repair shop and works on the side as a constable. One is a retired police officer. One runs an excavation company. One is a lawyer.
The lawyer says her credentials are crucial. The non-lawyers say judging is a matter of common sense.
District judges resolve local disputes. They handle traffic citations, civil cases involving $8,000 or less, protection from abuse petitions, search warrants, criminal arraignments and preliminary hearings. And weddings.
In 2001, the last year reported, District Judge Walter Luniewski presided over 5,830 cases, and traffic charges accounted for more than half of the work.
District judges are elected to six-year terms and are paid $65,000 a year. Judge-elects who are not lawyers must complete a training course.
Luniewski, who is retiring at the end of the year, was Monroeville's chief of police.
Here are the candidates in this year's primary:
Mark Dale, 47, runs Gemco Pipeline & Excavation Co., but he is best known as Monroeville's 5th Ward councilman.
He has been elected twice so he cannot run for another term.
"My passion for serving the public is what has driven me to seek this seat," he said, "since I can't run for council anymore."
Dale studied natural science at Louisiana State University and graduated in 1982. He sold medical equipment and then formed Gemco with his brother, George, in 1987.
Gemco did work for Monroeville when their father, the late George Dale, served on council. He said that work was proper because their father had no connection to the company.
Now that he is on council, Dale said, Gemco does no work for Monroeville. But it subcontracts for developers who have received regulatory approvals from council, like Eckerd Drugs and Sheetz.
"I'm not expected to quit my operations because I'm on council," he said, "as long as its done above-board and it's bid out properly.... If I have a track record of working for companies, I abstain from voting on those projects. And there is no guarantee that I will get any of those projects. Typically, they are not put out to bid until they've been approved."
He said he would no longer run Gemco if elected. His brother is still a partner but has taken a job with the Monroeville Municipal Authority.
Numerous court judgements and tax liens have been filed against Dale, his wife and their companies. They have satisfied about $225,000 in debts in the past two years, according to court records, but still owe about $100,000.
One of the companies, Huntar Development Corp., is not listed on Dale's financial disclosure form.
The company was formed in 1999 by his wife, Cindra, and, according to some records, she is the president, director and sole owner.
"I'm not the president. My wife is the president," Dale said last week. "Look on the incorporation papers. My name is not on it."
But Dale signed a contract in 2002, as Huntar's representative. A federal lawsuit identifies him as a "key principal." And in December he signed a lawsuit for Huntar as its president.
Huntar filed for bankruptcy in 2003, declaring $158,681 in assets and $520,469 in liabilities.
Huntar did about $1.6 million in excavation and site work from 2001 to 2002, and it leased equipment from Gemco for $111,600.
Huntar also listed "one filing cabinet, Dell computer (and) printer" owned by Monroeville and kept in its office at the Auto Bath House.
Council members are given computers, printers and filing cabinets for council business. Dale said he doesn't know how municipal property got listed in the bankruptcy case.
A bankruptcy trustee reported that Huntar had no funds or property to pay creditors. One of the unpaid creditors is the Monroeville Municipal Authority, which was owed $39,494 for pipe and other materials.
When the case was closed in 2003, the trustee reported that a Huntar representative, unnamed, stated that no one owed it money.
But in December, Huntar sued Monroe Meadows Housing Partnership, claiming that the partnership owed Huntar $53,000 on a $106,000 contract in 2002.
Monroe Meadows is a new 48-unit subsidized housing development near MacBeth Road in Monroeville. It claims that Huntar failed to get water, sanitary and storm sewer certifications from Monroeville and its work led to landslides. In January, seven units were declared unsafe when a hillside collapsed.
The developer also has been trying for the past year to get Monroeville to accept responsibility for the entrance road. On Tuesday, council finally denied the request.
Dale has abstained on several votes concerning Monroe Meadows but hasn't disclosed his reason for doing so.
Dale blamed his debts, in part, on the vagaries of contracting.
"Like any other business, I shell out a lot of money, I pay off loans and debts, I buy a lot of materials, and some contractors take several months to pay. It's hard being the bank and the developer at the same time."
He also bemoaned a "capricious world" in which work that once was done by handshake is handled by lawyers.
"I find them a necessary evil," he said. "That's why I think the district judge is geared to common people. I've been through the problems that most of my constituents face."
Dale also served on the board of the Monroeville Water Authority for four years and on the zoning board for two years. Zoning and council positions are quasi-judicial, he said, and have afforded him more training than his opponents have.
He said the district judge training course "gives you the basics of what you need to know to be a successful judge."
"The main criteria is that you have to have common sense for dealing with common issues with common people."
He said he would educate the elderly about unscrupulous people and he would educate youths about the dangers of drugs and alcohol.
"I'm a local guy who deals with common problems every day," he said. "I tell people about my love for Monroeville and ask, Do you want somebody up there judging you who knows you?"
Jack Backus, 58, runs J.B. Motors, an auto repair shop, but it's his 22 years working as a constable that he says qualifies him for judge.
He took the district judge course around 1993 and has kept his certification current. He said he works up to seven days a week, serving court papers and transporting prisoners for six district judges.
"I do 50 to 75 writs per month," he said. "You name it, I do it."
Backus graduated from Point Park University, where he studied business. He also served on the Monroeville planning commission for several years in the 1980s.
He sees no connection between a law degree and effective judging.
"It's about interpreting the law, not making the law, with fairness, common sense and compassion," he said.
"I work the streets every day. I actually have a pulse on the community and I know where the problem areas are."
He said he would counsel youth about the ramifications of their actions and hold them, not their parents, accountable.
He would close his auto repair shop.
Backus has a history of tax liens and late payments. Most of the property taxes have been paid but he still owes the state for unpaid sales and employee withholding taxes. The debt on record is about $26,734 but he said it is closer to $11,000 or $12,000. He blamed the debt on an accounting mistake.
His financial disclosure form does not list Century Construction Management Corp., of which he is president, or income from rental properties in Monroeville, North Braddock, Pitcairn and Wilmerding.
He said Century was created in the early 1980s for a condominium deal that fell through. Now it is the parent company of J.B. Motors. He said he didn't disclose the rental properties because he doesn't make any money from them, in that the rents go back into repairs.
"I think the important thing is that I've kept abreast with the laws," he said. "I have first-hand knowledge of the needs of the district, and I'm qualified by schooling and education to serve with fairness and dignity."
Jeffrey Herbst, 50, retired this year as a Monroeville police officer after 25 years of service.
He got an undergraduate degree in criminology in 1977 and a masters degree in the same field in 1997, from Indiana University of Pennsylvania. He teaches criminal justice at the International Academy of Design and Technology, Downtown.
He said his various duties, from K-9 to community safety officer to DARE officer, have given him a broad exposure to people.
"I have the unique experience of dealing with the public on a daily basis, and knowing how people are I think I am able to judge the character of people before me."
He said he has "full knowledge of the workings of the court," having gone before judges as a police officer. He said he has more training on the criminal side of the law than any of his opponents, and he would learn the civil side from the classes that non-lawyers must take.
"I have practical experience," he said.
All four candidates have cross-filed as Democrats and Republicans, but Herbst is the only registered Republican.
Though he knows it is difficult for a Republican to win in Monroeville, he is confident.
"I just believe I'm the most qualified."
Laura Cohen, 47, is the only lawyer running for the position.
"If you're sick, would you go to someone with six weeks training or to someone with several years of rigorous training and a license? It's the same thing with judges."
Cohen was a housewife for several years. Then she studied political science at Chatham College and law at the University of Pittsburgh.
The day she passed the bar examination in 1996, she started Family Legal Center in Monroeville, a two-lawyer firm that handles estates and domestic relations cases.
She has wanted a judgeship for a long time, but she is quick to note that she has no ambition to use the position as a stepping stone to Common Pleas Court. If she is elected, she will lose about $20,000 a year in income. She would keep the law firm open but would hire a lawyer to replace herself.
Cohen pledged evening hours at least once a week and holding juvenile cases after school. She wants to educate the elderly about fraud and start a community service program for juveniles.
"Adults can give the kids an opportunity to get their act together and at the same time the kids can give something back to the community," she said.
"People can be sure when they leave my courtroom that they had a fair hearing," she said. "I think that's what sets me apart."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.