The primary election for mayor of Wilkinsburg is crucial, both Democratic candidates agree, and the quality of policing is the main issue in what has been a heated contest.
Challenger John Thompson says the incumbent meddles to the point of interfering with police. He claims officers are demoralized and a climate of lawlessness has overtaken the town.
Mayor Wilbert Young, who already has faced questions about his financial records, scoffed at accusations about his handling of the police force. He describes himself as a prudent overseer and he claims that morale is good and crime is down.
The primary duty of the $5,000-a-year mayor, under state law, is to run the police department, leaving open the question of how the police chief fits in.
Given that Wilkinsburg is on its sixth police chief in five years, the relationship of the mayor to the chief is a central issue.
Gerald Brewer, who resigned as chief in 2000, was convicted of stealing money from an evidence safe and of witnesses intimidation for demoting two officers who investigated him.
Young pointed out that Brewer was already chief when he became mayor in 1998. Council, not the mayor, has the power to hire and fire police chiefs, he said, and "the Brewer situation had nothing to do with me."
His critics say Young and Brewer worked together closely. And as far as the turnover and turmoil since Brewer, Young controls enough council votes to get what he wants.
Mark Springer resigned as chief in 2002 after less than a year on the job. He said Young interfered with an internal investigation. Young said Springer lacked experience and delayed federal grants.
Richard Dwyer was forced out as chief last year, and council bought out his contract for $62,000.
Dwyer said Young interfered with day-to-day operations and encouraged officers to circumvent him. The mayor has the legal right to run the department, he said, but Young was like the hospital administrator who tells the doctor how to do heart surgery.
Young said Dwyer mishandled an internal investigation of Lt. Thomas Proctor, by, among other actions, referring the case to the district attorney instead of to state police. He said Dwyer was a bad fit for Wilkinsburg.
Proctor's wife, Lt. Michelle Krempasky, was named acting chief and then chief. Proctor eventually pleaded guilty to molesting two women while on duty and was sentenced to jail.
Krempasky has sued Dwyer and the borough in federal court, claiming the former chief discriminated against her because she's a woman.
To understand how far the department has fallen, it is helpful to look to a previous period. In the early 1990s, gangs were warring in the streets, homicides were frequent, and public confidence in the police was low.
Paul Wood and Sylvia LaFranchi inherited the mess when he became chief in 1993 and she became mayor in 1994.
By many accounts, they attacked crime effectively. They beefed up local resources with state and federal grants. They welcomed outside law enforcement agencies to supplement their officers. They got the police more involved in community activities that built trust and steered youth away from crime.
"I had the support of council," said Wood, who is now chief of the Edgewood police department. "The mayor let me do my job because she felt I was the professional."
"I was there as a backup," said LaFranchi. "He ran the police department. He had the training and the background and he knew what he was doing."
The Democratic Party has endorsed Thompson. In March, Wilkinsburg Councilwoman Sandra Roberts filed a petition in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, asking that Young's nomination petition be set aside. She questioned his residency and contended he did not reveal the amount of back taxes owed to the borough, school district and county. A judge ruled that Young could run for a third term and ordered him to file an amended ethics statement.
No Republican is running but LaFranchi, a Republican, is organizing a write-in campaign for Thompson. That way, if he loses the Democratic primary he could still compete in the general election.
Meanwhile, Young said there is no truth to the accusation that he is a micromanaging mayor. He does not schedule officers. He does not question deployment. He does not ask about investigations unless there is a big drug case, a homicide or something that interests the news media.
"I can go days without seeing the police chief," he said.
Morale is better, he said, as evidenced by fewer sick days and union grievances. More arrests are being made, calls for service are down and reported crime is down in most categories.
Thompson said Young is taking credit for old crime statistics. "He's running on Dwyer's stats."
Drug dealers operate openly, he said. Panhandling and loitering are rampant, abandoned cars are everywhere, garbage and trash litter the sidewalks.
"The mayor sets the tone," Thompson said. "I don't believe we have a lot of bad officers, just bad leadership."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.