PRIMARY 2005

A state Supreme Court ruling on Tuesday has derailed a bitter mayoral contest in Monroeville.

The court struck Harold Katofsky's name from the ballot for filing an incomplete financial disclosure statement. The decision leaves incumbent James Lomeo unopposed in the May 17 Democratic primary.

No Republican has filed for mayor, but Katofsky could try to run a write-in campaign in the primary or in the November general election.

Advertise with us

"My wife and my family and myself are going to sit down and evaluate it," Katofsky said. "We'll take a couple of days to decide what to do."

"I would be surprised if he doesn't do it," Lomeo said. "He has the political establishment behind him. He knows politics and he knows how to campaign. I don't discount him at all."

Katofsky asked the Supreme Court to reconsider its decision.

The case concerns the financial interest statement that all candidates must submit when they file for an election.

Katofsky failed to list several sources of income, creditors and business interests. Lomeo petitioned Common Pleas Court to remove Katofsky from the ballot for filing an incomplete form.

Advertise with us

The omissions were inadvertent, Katofsky said. But Lomeo argued that they were too numerous and too significant to overlook.

Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Joseph James ruled on March 22 that Katofsky had substantially complied with the Ethics Act requirements and that the omissions were technical defects. He ordered Katofsky to file an amended financial statement.

The policy of the state, noted James, is to preserve a candidate's right to run for office and to not limit the citizens' electoral choices.

Lomeo appealed to Commonwealth Court, which upheld the lower court ruling, and then to the Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court ruled that Katofsky failed to list sources of income that could not otherwise have been ascertained.

Advertise with us

"Legally, it makes sense," Lomeo said. "What good is the ethics form if there is no incentive to fill out the form fully? You may not fill it out properly if you have a chance to amend it if someone catches you. But a lot of things are not public records, so how would you know?"

Katofsky reiterated yesterday that there was no attempt to deceive. He said the financial interest form is confusing, and he thought he had filled it out correctly.

The incomplete financial statement is of more than theoretical interest.

Katofsky owns ServPro of Monroeville, a fire and water damage restoration business. He listed ServPro on the original financial statement but did not list MKS Services Inc., which owns ServPro, or One Source Drug Testing, a fictitious name owned by MKS.

Shortly after he formed One Source in 2003, Monroeville signed a contract with the company. The town's ethics code bans business dealings with elected officials.

Advertise with us

Katofsky said one of his employees signed up Monroeville without his knowledge. When he learned of the deal, he recommended a competitor, Steel City Drug Testing.

"I sleep at night because I haven't taken any money," Katofsky said. "We never ever did a test. We never billed the municipality. We never did a service. There's never been a check written to us."

Still, Lomeo said, there are discrepancies. Test forms list One Source as the specimen collector. The Secretary of State has no listing for Steel City Drug Testing. And business directories show both companies at the same address in Butler.

Lori Bortmas, a partner in Steel City, said she and Katofsky are "friendly competitors."

One Source has a telephone line that she answers at Steel City's Butler office. She provides services to One Source, and she uses a specimen collector employed by One Source.

Advertise with us

Her accountant handled Steel City's partnership papers, Bortmas said, and she will check on why the company is not registered with the state.

A municipal employee tipped off Lomeo to the One Source contract, after Lomeo challenged Katofsky's financial statement.

"Harold's situation with drug testing never would have come to light if the court didn't require him to amend the form," Lomeo said. "No one would have questioned One Source and its cozy relationship with Steel City without the ethics form."

Lomeo conceded that the facts are too murky to determine if Katofsky benefited from the deal. He said he will report his findings to the state Ethics Commission and the federal Task Force Against Public Corruption, so they can subpoena records and get answers.

Katofsky said he has filed an ethics complaint against Lomeo with the Supreme Court.

Advertise with us

Katofsky said Lomeo was privy to his private financial records when he bought ServPro from a client of Lomeo's. He said Lomeo disclosed that confidential information when he challenged Katofsky's election filings.

Lomeo said he has never done legal work for Katofsky and that the details that he did handle for his client were a matter of public record.

The two men have vastly different political styles.

Katofsky, who has represented the 7th Ward for more than seven years, is an energetic facilitator. From helping residents solve problems to financing public works projects, he finds ways to match resources to needs.

Lomeo is more cerebral. He takes a philosophical approach to government, setting goals and offering guidance. He doesn't mind losing a political argument as long as the issues are fully considered.

Advertise with us

The prize they were fighting over is mostly ceremonial. The mayor presides over council meetings but has no vote unless there is a tie. He can veto legislation and declare emergencies. Otherwise, he attends a lot of ribbon cuttings.

But for a candidate who enjoys setting lofty goals (Lomeo) or working with the public (Katofsky), being mayor is desirable.