Roberta Cook didn't intend for the next eight months to be her last on the Franklin Regional school board, but her term will end in November.
Until the middle of March, Cook considered herself a candidate for the upcoming primary elections. Those plans were squashed when she failed to file the proper paperwork -- a mistake discovered by fellow board member Mary Bach.
Each incumbent school board member must file a financial statement in January. Each candidate also must file a separate financial or "ethics" statement with the district in which they are running. Cook said she didn't check the "candidate" box on the first form. She then failed to file the second form.
"I made an honest error, but I did make it," admitted Cook, who has served as a board member for eight years. "The difference is a check mark and a date."
Bach discovered the mistake when on March 8, deadline day for candidates to file their forms, she went to the board secretary and asked to see the paperwork file. She did not notice a form filed by Cook, but the next day saw her name in a local paper as a candidate. Bach said that all 10 other candidates had filed correctly, including the other incumbents.
Well known locally as a citizen activist, Bach felt it her duty to pursue any mistakes made in the election process. After rechecking the file, inquiring about the law from five attorneys and "stewing" for a weekend about whether to challenge Cook's candidacy, she sought legal representation to file a formal challenge. Cook was served a subpoena on March 15.
"All the lawyers I talked to said election law was clear -- a no-brainer," said Bach.
The ethics statement Cook filed in January as a sitting school board member would not have counted, even if she had checked both the "incumbent" and "candidate" boxes on the form, said Paula Pedicone, Westmoreland County director of elections. Cook needed to file another ethics statement as a candidate and a petition with the school district by March 8.
"Unfortunately, it happens with people who are existing office holders ... . If they're not challenged, then they slip through the cracks. It happens every day," Pedicone said.
"The legislation says that failure to file at the local office is a fatal flaw," added Westmoreland Common Pleas Judge William J. Ober.
Bach acknowledged that as board members, she and Cook have agreed on the vast majority of votes, but on controversial issues the two have come down on different sides.
"I've always respected Mrs. Cook. She did a most outstanding job as chair of [Murrysville] community day," Bach said. "But she has been a negative influence on the board."
During her challenge hearing, Bach said that Cook used an "everybody does it defense," saying that she knew of two incumbent council members who did not file ethics statements as candidates.
"If I had known about it, I'd have gone after them, too," said Bach.
Since this episode, Cook said she has received an overwhelming amount of community support. Several district residents have said they plan to vote for Cook by "writing in" her name on the ballot.
"She's proven over and over that she's not afraid to speak up for the community and students. ... She makes decisions to the best of her knowledge," said Lynn Gurrentz, a parent and school board candidate. She added that the community recently has lost trust and support of the board with the exception of Cook.
Cook said that she's not thinking about what she'll do if nominated as a result of write-in votes or if she'll want to run in November as an independent. She viewed being taken off the ballot as a "kind of relief," mainly because of philosophical differences among school board members.
Meanwhile, she said she has much to accomplish before her time on the board in finished.
"It's going to be a crazy eight months. ... I want to get those [teacher] contracts settled," she said.
In addition, she plans to work on taking care of vacancies in the administration, the usual budget talks and a decision regarding Act 72, the legislation that is expected to provide taxpayers with property tax reductions from slots revenue.
"I had hoped with the new superintendent, we could have a new beginning and put petty differences behind and start fresh," she said. "I'm certainly going to try."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.