A judge ruled yesterday that Monroeville Councilman Richard Buxter may not run for re-election this year.

Buxter, a Democrat, had asked the court to declare him eligible under Monroeville's home rule charter, which limits council members to two consecutive four-year terms.

Buxter has been elected twice, but the first time was for an unexpired term.

He was appointed in March 1999 after 3rd Ward Councilman Charles Mohan resigned. The appointment lasted almost 10 months. Then he won a special election for the remaining two years of Mohan's term, and he was re-elected to a four-year term in 2001.

Advertise with us

By the end of the year, Buxter will have served six years and 10 months.

The charter defines a term as four years, seemingly limiting councilmen to eight years.

The charter is inartfully written, President Judge Joseph James commented yesterday during oral arguments. For lack of a key word or sentence, he would have to interpret its meaning.

Isn't it clear, James asked, that the intent of the charter is to limit council members to no more than eight years?

James ruled that Buxter is ineligible to run for re-election.

Advertise with us

"I find that the prohibition against election to two consecutive terms includes this appointed period," he said. "I believe that that is the intent of the charter."

Janice Rawson, head of Monroeville's Democratic Party, was pleased.

"It was nothing personal," she said. "It was a matter of upholding the charter."

She noted that the ruling has implications for two other appointed council members, David Kucherer and Carol McDevitt.

Buxter said he was disappointed, "for the residents of the 3rd Ward, that I'm not eligible to be placed on the ballot to let the electorate choose who they want to choose."

He said he would discuss the possibility of an appeal with his attorney.