The early headlines do not inspire confidence. Ivory Mathews, the unanimous choice of the board of the Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh to replace longtime director Caster Binion, “is being investigated by the Oregon Government Ethics Commission.”

In three years at Portland’s public housing agency, called Home Forward, Mathews had spent over $100,000 on travel. Further, according to the Oregon news site Willamette Week, the ethics commission’s initial report found evidence that Mathews’ expenses regularly exceeded limits set by the federal government and Home Forward.

The obvious first reaction: Here we go again. Once again, Pittsburgh celebrates someone who treats the public trust as a plaything. Once again, we settle for mediocrity (or worse).

But this column has been pretty dire recently, so let’s consider an alternative, more optimistic analysis. And that starts with looking closely at the status quo of public housing in Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

Dysfunctional agency

Every knowledgeable person I have spoken with, left or right or center, agrees that the Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh is the most dysfunctional public agency in Pittsburgh. More specifically, the authority is the single biggest hurdle to developing affordable housing in the city.

HACP has a waitlist thousands of names long while it sits on numerous unlivable properties it has the money but not the wherewithal to repair. The agency takes several months to process vouchers, leaving landlords trying to participate in the Section 8 system waiting for tenants and for rent. The problems have left it bereft of the partners — from large developers to small-time landlords, not to mention philanthropies and other government agencies — it needs to function effectively.

Improving the city’s housing authority, even marginally, would improve the city’s livability for lower-income residents more than anything the Urban Redevelopment Authority or the city itself could do on their own.

And this moment of leadership transition, especially with a new director from outside the region unbound by the delicate and complicated politics of the authority, is the best opportunity to achieve serious change in many years.

Glass half full

Is Ivory Mathews the person to bring this change? And will the HACP board give her the freedom to get the job done? There’s reason to be skeptical. But there’s also reason to believe the answer to both is in the affirmative.

Advertise with us

It’s clear that, despite the ethics probe, Mathews is considered a genuine catch in the public housing leadership community.

When Wasi Mohamed, HACP board chair and chief of staff to U.S. Rep. Summer Lee, described the hire as a “home run,” the dominant reaction among the public was disdain and incredulity.

But the truth is that experienced public housing executives — especially those familiar with HACP’s distinctive “Moving to Work” designation from the Department of Housing and Urban Development — are hard to come by. And Mathews’ controversial travel typically involved spending extra time at national conferences where she sought leadership roles and was sought after for her expertise.

Indeed, one read of her hiring — admittedly not the most natural one, but I think a very plausible one — is that the ethics inquiry caused her stock to tumble like a college football player with “character concerns” at the NFL draft. Those picks can sometimes blow up, but they can also be among the best deals an organization can make.

And the fact that the board made this choice may be a sign of desperation — but it may also be a sign it sees the need for radical change and was willing to take a chance on a flawed but tough outsider.

Advertise with us

Cleaning house

Here’s how HACP and Ivory Mathews can improve on her first impression.

First, directly address the allegations, as far as possible given the limitations on discussing an ongoing investigation.

Most importantly, that should include a statement from the board affirming and strengthening its executive expense policies and one from Mathews pledging to abide by them. She should also promise not to attend national conferences in-person for at least a few years while she focuses entirely on Pittsburgh.

Second, take a scorched-earth approach to incumbent HACP personnel. It must be clear that Mathews has a mandate for change from the board and the boldness to execute it. While even the most dysfunctional agencies need to keep some staff to maintain institutional memory, Mathews must be empowered to fire anybody and everybody who resists her revolution.

If these measures are not taken — if it seems either Mathews or the board is too proud to address the Oregon probe or too timid to do what needs to be done at the authority — then Pittsburghers will be justified in their first reactions: Here we go again.

Advertise with us

More than that, it would justify Mayor Corey O’Connor to seek legislation in Harrisburg to allow him to remove housing authority board members, a power that the mayor of Philadelphia has enjoyed since 2012.

For now, I’m willing to offer the benefit of the doubt. Because change at the Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh needs to happen, quickly, and Ivory Mathews is the only person available to achieve it.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “How being a one-party town warps Pittsburgh’s politics.”