The affidavit for the Gainey administration search warrant, served on the city of Pittsburgh earlier this year, is an odd document.

First of all, it has no real force without knowing what was seized using the warrant. As it stands, the affidavit is nothing more than a collection of insinuations and allegations.

For those who’ve followed the Gainey administration’s travails over the years, there’s not much new in the sworn statement. The Post-Gazette has covered most of what is alleged by the city officials who spoke with the District Attorney’s office. These were the subjects of some of the former Editorial Board’s punchiest editorials.

It was striking to see all this material laid out in a legal document. Even so, for a legal document, the affidavit was at times noticeably imprecise, including botching the name of City Councilman Khari Mosley and his role in 1Hood Media as well as conflating the local Cohen Law Group with the global firm Dentons Cohen & Grigsby.

Advertise with us

It leaves the informed reader wondering how much the DA’s office actually understands about what it’s investigating.

But it’s the scope of the affidavit, and of the corresponding investigation, that’s oddest of all. Typically, a probe like this clearly homes in on a single locus of lawbreaking, some specific act or collection of acts where money was stolen or rules violated.

Yet here, the target seems to be the entirety of Ed Gainey’s governance, from budgeting to procurement to spending to oversight — an entire culture of mismanagement and incompetence. Or of potential graft and malice.

The ultimate question remains unanswered: Which one was it?

Malice or incompetence

“Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by incompetence.” It’s a version of a rule of thumb attributed to the writer Robert J. Hanlon, and I have deployed it dozens of times when talking with sources about the Gainey administration — and governance in southwestern Pennsylvania more broadly.

Advertise with us

It is not credible that the Gainey administration was a well-oiled machine of corruption. That requires a level of coordination of which it was not capable.

Yet there are many laws that govern those who govern, and operating effectively within them requires deftness, experience and humility. These, too, were not in adequate supply among Gainey and his top deputies. It would not be surprising if District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. found some fire among all the smoke.

Ultimately it will fall to Zappala, or to a grand jury he empanels, to decide whether to bring charges. Any prediction on where the story goes from here, without knowing what the search warrant revealed, would be guesswork.

Civic failure

What we can say with confidence is that this entire drama shows governance in Pittsburgh — across the board — in a very unflattering light.

First of all, the affidavit alleges serious violations of the public trust. Unaccountable and arbitrary grantmaking. Abusing procurement waivers. Fudging budgets for political purposes. These are issues the Post-Gazette, both in its news and former opinion functions, has reported on for years.

Advertise with us

Again, whether they constitute provable lawbreaking is up to the justice system. But they do constitute dysfunctional governance.

At the same time, the affidavit itself has a slapdash quality that undermines its credibility. No civic institution seems to be firing on all cylinders here, not even close.

Which points to the bigger issue: The Gainey administration operated within a broader culture of carelessness and unaccountability.

The administration’s defenders argue that the scrutiny it received, first from the press and now from the DA, has been unfair because it behaved no differently from other city and county governing cohorts. This argument significantly understates the extent of Gainey’s struggles.

But it’s not completely fanciful. If bad governance were a crime, the region’s jails would be overcrowded with public officials. Gainey, in particular, inherited generations of bad habits in city governance, including an expectation of significant ethical leeway, if not impunity.

Advertise with us

Further, the systems — both formal, such as the other branches of government, and informal, such as private-sector and civic leadership — meant to hold the administration accountable proved incapable of or uninterested in enforcing higher standards.

Beyond Gainey

This is why I’m uncomfortable with indicting and convicting anyone from the Gainey years, unless bulletproof evidence of serious and specific lawbreaking is found: The administration’s struggles represented a full-system failure, far beyond the mayor’s office or even City Hall.

Indeed, I’ve come to see the Gainey years — not just the actions of the administration but the tentativeness and passivity and risk-aversion of leaders more broadly — as the full flowering of the worst habits of Pittsburgh’s civic systems, not a major aberration from them.

Whether the O’Connor years represent a real cultural shift or merely a return to a softer version of the same system remains to be seen. So does whether this search warrant represents a turning point in city politics or just a deepening of divisions.

But one thing I do know for sure: Zappala’s affidavit reflects not just on Ed Gainey and his team, but on Pittsburgh’s political culture as a whole.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Pittsburgh's sports malaise contributes to its civic stagnation.”