I was disappointed after reading Brandon McGinley’s column, “Pittsburgh can’t afford to be a trust-fund city anymore” (Sep. 17), particularly his assertion that the realities of the Housing Opportunity Fund (HOF) have been “disappointing.”

As the sponsor of the legislation that created the HOF, I welcome scrutiny of the fund and whether it is delivering results for Pittsburgh taxpayers. However, calling those results disappointing without providing any specifics is unfair to the program and, more importantly, to the Pittsburghers it has helped.

Since the HOF began its operations, it has helped at least 636 Pittsburgh households become first-time homeowners. And homeownership represents only one part of the HOF’s work. The fund has created and preserved affordable housing, helped existing homeowners make critical repairs, prevented displacement and provided legal assistance to residents struggling to remain in their homes.

In 2024 alone, the HOF helped create or preserve 204 affordable homes, assisted 52 homeowners with repairs, stabilized 1,545 households and helped 93 households purchase their first homes. These figures represent Pittsburghers building equity and generational wealth, seniors able to remain in homes and neighborhoods where they have spent decades, families avoiding displacement and residents choosing to put down roots in Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

Could the HOF be improved? Absolutely. We should constantly evaluate how effectively public dollars are being spent and demand measurable outcomes. Yet that conversation should begin with an honest accounting of what those dollars have accomplished.

There is also a larger point missing from the debate. Pittsburgh faces a fundamental fiscal challenge: We need to grow our revenue, and the most sustainable way is to grow our tax base. And if we want more people to call Pittsburgh home, we need more homes for them to live in — including homes that working families can afford.

Mayor Corey O’Connor has made increasing housing supply and attracting families to Pittsburgh an important part of his agenda. The HOF is one of the tools we already have to help accomplish exactly that goal. I understand why, during a difficult budget year, pausing a $10 million annual transfer can look like low-hanging fruit. But it also risks undermining one of the investments designed to address the very fiscal problem we are trying to solve.

The Housing Opportunity Fund was never intended to be charity. It is an investment — in housing, in homeownership, in neighborhood stability and ultimately in Pittsburgh’s tax base. At a moment when Pittsburgh needs more housing, more residents and more revenue, the HOF isn’t an investment we can afford to pause.

R. DANIEL LAVELLE

Advertise with us

Hill District

The writer is the president of Pittsburgh City Council.