When I first applied to join the Post-Gazette editorial team back in 2021, U.S. Steel had just canceled its planned $1.5 billion investment in its Mon Valley Works, which consists of the Edgar Thomson Plant in Braddock, the Irvin Plant in West Mifflin and the Clairton Plant.

As a writing sample, I drafted an editorial bitterly complaining about U.S. Steel’s abandonment of the city that made it (and which it made in turn).

That piece never saw the light of day, which was probably for the best. I’m sure it was a little overwrought. After all, as I’ve previously written, I have a familial connection to U.S. Steel that has left me feeling pretty chilly toward the company.

Like most observers, I figured that canceled investment had started the countdown to the end of steelmaking in the Mon Valley, probably within a decade. U.S. Steel’s gaze — at least in part due to its dysfunctional relationship with the Allegheny County Health Department, whose air quality permits the company needed to move forward — had decisively shifted to more compliant jurisdictions, such as Arkansas.

Advertise with us

Events appeared to be favoring those who predicted and preferred a post-steel future for Pittsburgh.

Until December 2023, when the sun rose on new possibilities.

And this week, with the confirmation of up to $2.5 billion in upgrades, the rays have reached the Mon Valley.

Saving not stealing

I didn’t like the Nippon Steel deal at first. Who could? A foreign buyer for not just the greatest legacy Pittsburgh corporation, but also the greatest legacy American corporation — it just felt bad.

Sure, U.S. Steel had declined to become a bit player in the global steel industry and the regional economy. Even if you double the roughly 3,000 jobs at the Mon Valley Works to account for co-located suppliers and clients, as well as other businesses supported by the mills, that still only gets you to about one-tenth of UPMC’s regional employment. At the end of 2025, according to the commonwealth, U.S. Steel was the 19th-largest employer in Allegheny County.

Advertise with us

But U.S. Steel’s meaning goes well beyond the numbers, and losing it to an overseas owner felt like the final surrender of an idea of America, and of Pittsburgh, that I still held dear — even if I knew it was of the past.

Quickly, however, my view changed. After talking to experts and reading up on the industry, it became clear that Nippon wasn’t stealing U.S. Steel from us but was offering the only chance to save it for us.

I stuck to that analysis throughout the painful acquisition process, even as two presidents and the international United Steelworkers politicked and scare-mongered. U.S. Steel on its own was on a glide path to liquidating the Mon Valley (and maybe the entire company). Cleveland-Cliffs would have done it sooner. Nippon had the track record and the means to reverse course.

And that’s what the new owners are doing.

Stay of execution

Let’s not overstate what the new U.S. Steel’s investment means. It’s not going to make steel a tentpole industry in Pittsburgh once again. It doesn’t even appear, after needing several thousand workers during construction, that the upgraded Mon Valley Works will employ more people than it does right now.

Advertise with us

The big move is shifting hot steel rolling operations from the aging Irvin Plant to a new facility at Edgar Thomson. At this point it’s not clear what work (if any) will remain in West Mifflin. This will likely result in more emissions from Edgar Thomson, fewer from Irvin and — crucially — fewer overall.

Overall, it’s a stay of execution for Mon Valley steel, one that should buy at least a generation. It’s a chance to plan for a more complete post-steel transition decades from now. And it’s better than any other realistic outcome.

Still, there are those who will deplore Nippon’s infusion of capital into the old industry.

They’d rather see steelmaking eliminated than preserved because it’s physically dirty and culturally lowbrow, because it doesn’t represent the proposed pristine Pittsburgh of the future. Some see propping up Mon Valley steel like enabling an addict who needs to be weaned: That is, the stay-of-execution postpones a necessary economic transition.

Not yet beyond steel

I would find this all, especially the last one, more compelling if there were actually a transition plan in place. Or even a compelling and workable proposal that would ensure several thousand steel and steel-adjacent workers and their families aren’t plunged immediately into crisis.

Advertise with us

Lacking such a plan or proposal, it’s hard to see the anti-steel position as anything more than posturing. If you’re going to advocate, implicitly or explicitly, for the elimination of an industry, you’re responsible for figuring out how to replace it.

With this in mind, it will be essential for Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato’s administration — specifically her health department — not to place unnecessary roadblocks in U.S. Steel’s path.

Government must provide oversight, to be sure, but a spirit of partnership rather than antagonism should prevail. Whatever Innamorato and other progressive figures may feel about steel, it is in no one’s interest — least of all her own political interest — to delay this investment and the upgrades it will fund.

This investment won’t renew the Mon Valley economy all by itself, but it will keep several thousand jobs there. And that’s worth fighting for.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “We gotta regatta once again.”