Mother’s Day, as usual, sneaked up on me. Happily, my wife is not super enthusiastic about compulsory consumption. She reminded me, though, that in recent years her favorite Mother’s Day treat has been getting a few hours to herself to read at a cafe. That I could manage with no forethought, so last Sunday I piled the seven kids in the oversized van and started driving — somewhere.
Normally, I’d take them hiking, but despite the beautiful weather the kids nixed that idea. I couldn’t let them avoid the outdoors entirely, though, so I charted a course for the Golden Triangle.
The gang goes Downtown
For kids, the appeal of Downtown is similar to the appeal of the woods: It’s an excursion to an environment you don’t experience every day, full of impressive structures and tiny details and spaces to discover and explore. As a dense downtown — more comparable to New York or Chicago than Buffalo or Indianapolis — tucked into a distinctive geographic setting, the Golden Triangle lives up to its magical-sounding name.
We were somehow able to squeeze the big van into a spot abutting Point State Park. Rather than make a beeline for the fountain, we walked toward the Fort Pitt Museum, then through the restored wooded area — a sight that would have seemed miraculous to Pittsburghers at the time of the Second World War, when the area was occupied by heavy industry.
We lingered around the fountain for the obligatory family photo, then I guided the gang down to the Allegheny Riverwalk. The mile to the David L. Lawrence Convention Center shifts from utilitarian concrete to more nicely landscaped environs, including boulders that double as climbing opportunities and, I suspect, discouragements to tenting.
The watery walkway beneath the convention center was unfortunately dark and dry, but it made emerging onto Penn Avenue all the more pleasant. As we approached Ninth Avenue, the younger kids shrieked with delight upon discovering the new playgrounds at Arts Landing, and all the complaining about how hot it was (it wasn’t) and how hungry they were faded away.
The kids spent a solid half-hour there and gave it rave reviews for its playability and natural feel. (They are connoisseurs of playgrounds.) Then we picked up some artisanal lemonades at the new De Fer coffee location, mostly fending off a new wave of whining. (They are not connoisseurs of lemonade, but I am, and this one was excellent.)
After that, we moseyed through Gateway Center, where they declared the fountain to be a pale imitation of the Point’s. All in all, we walked over 2 miles and gave my wife more than three hours of alone time. Plus I sneaked in a hike, even if an urban one, after all.
People first
It’s fair to say there have been times when I might’ve hesitated to bring the brood to Downtown, at least by myself. But on this Mother’s Day, the only thing that made me uncomfortable was when they would wander too close to the Allegheny River.
This seems to me a measure of a good public space: Can a dad who can’t possibly watch seven kids, ranging from toddler to pre-teen, at every moment enjoy it with confidence? Downtown, at least the parts we enjoyed, passes the test.
But why? It comes down to two main factors: design and rules. While the parts of the Riverwalk near the Fort Duquesne Bridge were patchy concrete with no buffer between people and the deep, most of our excursion involved spaces that were well-designed with people — specifically pedestrians and cyclists — top of mind.
But design only goes so far. The more important lesson for everyday governance is that keeping good public spaces truly public — that is, enjoyable by as many people as possible — requires making rules about what is tolerated in those spaces. And those rules must be enforced without sentimentality.
What empathy requires
Point State Park remained an oasis during Pittsburgh’s recent homelessness crisis because state authorities enforced camping rules. I could let my kids explore the Allegheny riverfront because it is now posted with rules about tenting, which the city enforces.
To be clear, my first concern is not that the people camping would be dangerous, but that there would be dangerous paraphernalia around and that the space occupied by tents would become off-limits to the public, especially curious kids. Tents turn a public space into a private one, and that capture tends only to spread.
Which brings us to Arts Landing, Downtown’s newest public space. The park has a long list of rules posted, which the Cultural Trust must be unsentimental about enforcing. It is the job of others, preeminently the county Department of Human Services, to ensure that adequate provision is made for people who struggle in public spaces. It is the job of the stewards of those spaces, on the other hand, to ensure they remain truly public.
Making and enforcing rules about anti-social behavior isn’t a violation of empathy: It’s required by it. And the future of Downtown as a safe public space — for kids and grown-ups — depends on it.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Catena and Bartolotta are targets of convenience for grassroots activists.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.