Almost exactly 270 years ago, the British admiral John Byng was ordered to relieve a garrison besieged by the French on the Mediterranean island of Minorca. He didn’t succeed, and while the defeat wasn’t unusually embarrassing, the British command — feeling its ability to command the seas against the French slipping — charged Byng with cowardice, court-martialed him and executed him.

Just a few years later, in 1759, the French author Voltaire parodied this episode in his novel “Candide”: Dans ce pays-ci, il est bon de tuer de temps en temps un amiral pour encourager les autres. “In this country, it is good from time to time to kill an admiral to encourage the others.”

If there were a single mantra to describe the left- and right-wing electoral bases of America’s two political parties, this would be it. During this year’s primary season in Western Pennsylvania, each side has an admiral in its sights: Democratic Allegheny County Council President Patrick Catena and Republican state Sen. Camera Bartolotta.

To the left

Catena is running in the 45th State Legislative District, which contains several of the city’s western suburbs. The seat’s current occupant, the retiring Rep. Anita Kulik, is one of the last remaining Democrats in the state legislature to identify as pro-life. Which means this is one of the last remaining blue districts in the state open to classic blue-dog Democrats.

Advertise with us

Kulik’s retirement was met with jubilation among local progressives, who saw a chance to purify the party of its vestigial conservatism. The candidates to replace her are Catena, the longtime lawmaker from Carnegie, and Brittany Bloam, an attorney from Robinson. Bloam has been favored by the party’s progressive wing — and, notably, is endorsed by Kulik. Catena, however, won the party’s official endorsement.

The campaign has been marked by the usual shenanigans of local races, but those tensions were significantly heightened in the past two weeks. The Catena campaign dropped a mailer alleging that Bloam is “supported by an extreme left group that advocates for transgender athletes in our sports.”

The artless attempt to stigmatize Bloam and to situate himself as a common-sense moderate has inflamed the left. Catena was accosted by a crowd of activists during this week’s council meeting, and half the council’s Democrats have pledged to seek his removal as president of the chamber.

The reaction, though, is out of keeping with public opinion, with opposition to male-to-female transgender participation in women’s sports increasing to 79% in a 2025 New York Times poll. It is fair to assume the figure is even higher for youth sports.

The intensity of the response to Catena, therefore, is about generating a strong enough incentive to counteract the growing unpopularity of trans issues. The target is only partially Catena himself; it’s mostly other Democrats whom progressives don’t want to bow to public pressure to abandon their causes.

Advertise with us

To the right

The expensive campaign in Bartolotta’s rural Senate district — all of Greene and Washington counties and a bit of Beaver — has a quite different fact pattern, but the underlying dynamic is similar.

The 12-year Senate veteran is being challenged by relative neophyte Al Buchtan, who held office in Greene County. Financially, the record-breaking $2.7 million race is almost entirely a proxy battle between gambling interests, with skill games operators supporting Buchtan and traditional (including sport) gaming groups backing Bartolotta.

But this wouldn’t be a gambling proxy fight if there weren’t existing right-wing grievances against the incumbent ready to be deployed by a challenger.

Simply put, Bartolotta has not always echoed President Donald Trump’s priorities and is clearly not comfortable with his rhetoric. Most notably, she defended her Haitian constituents in and around Charleroi when the Trump campaign stoked fear about them during the 2024 campaign. This marked her as unreliable among committed MAGA voters.

While the Buchtan campaign is funded by skill games, its political oxygen is provided by MAGA grassroots seeking to punish Bartolotta’s perceived unsoundness. But, as with Catena, the Republican incumbent is at least partially a target of convenience: The purpose and effect of making her life difficult, and possibly ousting her, is to dissuade others from breaking with the president even a little bit — especially on issues that aren’t popular.

Advertise with us

The hassle, they want to communicate to other Republicans, just isn’t worth it.

Stuck in the middle

The effect of these strategies is to push elected officials of both parties into increasingly unpopular political positions. They ensure that the path of least resistance in primaries is to veer to the fringes, and then to stay there to avoid trouble in future primaries.

And that leaves average people who hold complicated views confounded with their options at the general election ballot box, further eroding trust and confidence in the system.

Pour encourager les autres. Whatever the results of these primaries, and of the attempt to oust Catena from council leadership, these tactics have already succeeded: They’ve signaled to others how to avoid trouble. And that’s to appease the base, no matter what.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Market Square needed rules, but Pittsburgh youth need places to be.”