We bought our Brookline house in 2015, and if Zillow is to be trusted, it has doubled in value since. More importantly for the purposes of this column, that Zillow value is more than three times the assessed value, on which Allegheny County, the city of Pittsburgh and Pittsburgh Public Schools tax the property.
We didn’t get hit by the infamous “newcomers’ tax” because the difference between the 2012 assessed value and the 2015 sale price didn’t merit the city’s or the school district’s trouble. I suspect today’s Brookline buyers aren’t as lucky.
This means that when a reassessment comes — and that is a definitive “when,” not an “if” — our taxes are likely to go up. They won’t climb as much as those for properties in hot neighborhoods like Lawrenceville and Bloomfield, but in all likelihood the difference between our assessed value and today’s fair value is above average in Allegheny County. That, very roughly, is the comparison that matters.
Our coming tax hike is not unfair. My family isn’t freeriding, but we do have discounted tickets for the use of local government services. That can’t last forever, and county leaders shouldn’t try to make it last, because it means the burden of funding the services we all need is being shouldered by others, typically those who can afford it less than the system’s beneficiaries.
Stupid system
As an editorial writer, I’ve made this case over and over again. I’ve become knowledgeable (true expertise in this area requires making a pilgrimage to a mountaintop in Tibet and I just haven’t had the time) about the common level ratio and the coefficient of dispersion and numerous other incredibly nerdy aspects of real estate valuation and taxation, and tried to communicate what I’ve learned to the public.
This time, however, I’m going with the simpler version: Allegheny County’s property assessment system is radically, appallingly, almost unfathomably stupid. And fixing it, at least the worst part of it, is very easy.
Read More
You don’t need to spend a decade with a guru to understand this: Countywide reassessments are necessary. Without them, property values become stuck in the past, while actual values, driven by the market, diverge farther and farther from the mark.
All attempts to sort this out without resorting to a full reassessment are, by definition, remedial. It’s like patching a leaky roof while water damage accumulates underneath: The patches aren’t helping the rot.
Remedial fixes can last a long time, even decades, in rural counties with a relatively small number of parcels and slow turnover. But that’s not the case in an urban/suburban county like Allegheny, with 600,000 parcels, rapid turnover and a dynamic market.
So, full-scale reassessments are an unavoidable part of property taxation. Yet they are, for very obvious reasons, extremely unpopular. Necessary but unpopular governmental actions are precisely those which should be insulated from electoral politics. Yet in this county, and around Pennsylvania, we have made elected officials responsible for doing something important that people hate.
Of course: They just don’t do it.
Beyond politics
The obvious solution: Don’t make them responsible for doing it.
The every-three-year regular reassessment bill that’s currently before Allegheny County Council is coded as a left-wing measure because it’s being pushed by progressives like Bethany Hallam and Bethel Park’s Dan Grzybek. (Good for them, by the way — this is politically treacherous.) But the bill is also supported by the right-of-center Allegheny Institute for Public Policy.
More importantly, it’s hardly a matter of ideology to recognize that turning an essential government function into a political time bomb handed to every county executive makes no sense.
To hammer this home: Imagine how bad the polling on reassessments must be for Sara Innamorato, who ran as a young left-wing disruptor, to run away from them as quickly as she has. If this county executive won’t do it without a court order and maybe a papal bull, none ever will.
And that’s terrible for Allegheny County, and for Pennsylvania as a whole. While every state and region has their own governmental oddities, this one constantly threatens the very basis of local governance — a stable taxation system.
Simple but not easy
Wednesday evening in West Mifflin, County Council hosted its first public hearing on the regular reassessment bill. This column went to print before the event, so I can’t report on the mood among residents in the room.
But I can say this: Bringing this bill to the people was the right move by its sponsors, for two reasons. First, the event gives experts a chance to demonstrate why the bill is important. Second, the very fact these hearings are happening is putting reassessments in the news, driving home an essential reality: A countywide reassessment is inevitable, and will happen soon whether we all like it or not.
Regularly scheduled reassessments won’t change that fact because it can’t be changed. What the measure will do is make sure they happen in a timely manner, which will make each one less painful. Quickly they will become regular annoyances, the consistent housekeeping of the taxation system, rather than irregular cataclysms.
No house in Allegheny County, let alone one in sleepy Brookline, should ever get to three times its assessed value. Fixing that won’t fix everything about our assessment and taxation system, but it’s necessary to any further reform.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “What is the story of a city?”







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.