A month before she was named to lead CBS News as editor-in-chief, Bari Weiss hosted an event in Pittsburgh, her hometown, asking whether expectant parents should use the latest genetic technologies to “design their babies.”

Ms. Weiss, 41, who grew up in Squirrel Hill and attended Shady Side Academy, took on the role of moderator, positioned between experts debating whether the genetic tinkering of babies is “unethical — or a moral imperative.”

It was a bold topic, but more surprising to some of the 230 attendees at the Greer Cabaret Theater was the balanced way it was discussed.

“It’s not like what you see on TV, where they just, like, yell at each other and make stuff up. It was very high quality,” said audience member Jim Busis, CEO and publisher of the Pittsburgh Jewish Chronicle. “It was a real pleasure to hear intelligent, knowledgeable people speak civilly about an issue in which they disagreed and they were okay with that, and the audience was okay with it. And that’s, unfortunately, pretty rare in our society today.”

Advertise with us

For Mr. Busis, the event was an illustration of how Ms. Weiss might lead the storied newsroom at CBS, which broadcasts shows such as “60 Minutes” and “CBS Sunday Morning” to affiliate stations, including KDKA, across the country.

A former New York Times and Wall Street Journal columnist, Ms. Weiss is returning to traditional media at a time of record distrust and decline in the news industry. Her media startup, The Free Press, which hosted the Pittsburgh event, is expected to continue operating as part of a $150 million purchase by CBS parent Paramount.

Read More

“Bari’s famous for bringing the conversation to the center, and I think that if she can do that, she should attract a lot of people that have left [traditional media],” her father, Lou Weiss, said from the family’s home in Squirrel Hill.

Weiss family culture

Before the Shabbat dinners, there were the carpool rides in an old Ford Taurus station wagon. As a teenager, Bari Weiss would pick up friends throughout Squirrel Hill — until the day the car finally broke down at Fifth and Negley.

She was her friends’ unlikely chauffeur, shuttling neighbors out to the suburb of Fox Chapel.

Advertise with us

It was a “motley crew of kids” who lived nearby and weren’t part of her friend group, sister Casey recalled. But the experience left so much of a lasting impression that Bari mentioned it in her 2004 graduation speech, Casey said.

It was more than a ride, Casey said. It was “a time of fellowship, connecting, and debating the current events of the day.”

“They would just have these, like, unbelievable conversations together,” Casey said. And once Bari pulled into the parking lot, they would each go their separate ways.

Casey credits much of the sisters’ upbringing to her parents and to the broader Jewish community in Pittsburgh. “That’s a teeny, micro world compared to the world that she’s helping mold and craft,” she said, but it has a “tremendous” impact.

“As girls, as young women, we were told to conquer the world,” she said.

Advertise with us

Bari and her three sisters went to Community Day School in Squirrel Hill, where their mother Amy served as board president and middle sister Casey currently works as head of school. It was there that Bari made her acting debut.

She played various roles in “Cinderella” and “Fiddler on the Roof” and later starred as Maria in “West Side Story” during her gap year before Columbia University. But she also threw herself into basketball and swimming.

One of the hallmarks of “Weiss family culture” was Friday night Shabbat. Instead of partying with friends, the sisters would help to host a parade of high-profile guests. Israeli soldiers, graduate students, rabbis and politicians all got the same treatment: “I remember vividly, like, constant debate,” Casey said. “Sometimes it got really heated.”

The sisters were treated like adults and equals by their parents and their dinner guests, and they held their own in discussions about politics and culture. Occasionally, someone’s stance could prompt genuine anger, Casey said. But on the whole, the tradition became a “sacred” way to shape the family’s values, faith and identity.

They were the kinds of conversations father Lou says are becoming increasingly rare in modern American households — and the kind that need to come back “if we’re going to get back to a better place” as a nation.

Advertise with us

The couple’s political disagreements have been well-documented over the years. Lou is a staunch conservative, while Amy leans liberal. In 2016, she threatened to go on a “sex strike,” if her husband voted for Donald Trump.

But the pair have largely been a model for how differences can coexist, even get along. Mr. Weiss said their debates around the dinner table offered a proving ground for Ms. Weiss, the eldest daughter, to sharpen her ideas.

“And I think that what [Bari’s] done with her various writing, both at the Journal and at the Times and with The Free Press, has tried to have that kind of generosity of spirit that can listen to both sides of an argument and still love the other person.”

“I mean, my wife claims that she still loves me after we’ve been together about 50 years now, so it can work,” he said.

Harry Litman, the former U.S. attorney, and his mother, Roslyn, a well-known local attorney who had argued before the U.S. Supreme Court, would each take a seat at the table and “very sweetly, very socratically, would try to tear me apart,” Mr. Weiss said.

Advertise with us

“She witnessed a lot of warm discussion, some not-so warm discussion,” Mr. Weiss said. “Lively,” mother Amy chimed in.

Carl Kurlander, a Hollywood screenwriter, University of Pittsburgh professor and fellow Shady Side alum, got a taste of Ms. Weiss’ wit when she was just 17. “I remember vividly… leaving that house wondering who was that teenager who just cleaned our clocks,” he wrote in a recent blog post celebrating her appointment to CBS News.

Yet it was a moment when Ms. Weiss brought people together that her father recalled as an early example of leadership.

“She got kids at Shady Side involved in some kind of a pro-Israel Independence Day… and she had all these kids that were not Jewish at our house painting signs on behalf of Israel. I was very touched by that,” Mr. Weiss said.

Zipora “Tsipy” Gur, the former vice principal of Community Day School, who later launched Classrooms Without Borders, a Pittsburgh nonprofit that brings teachers to Poland and other countries, remembers Ms. Weiss as an “amazing” community organizer who once put together as a student, a large event with Jews from different denominations — orthodox, reformed, conservative — to foster understanding.

Advertise with us

“She was never afraid to speak up,” Ms. Gur recalled.

She attributed much of that light and enthusiasm to Ms. Weiss’ parents, who were “pro-Zionist, community people” and “amazing role models.” The broader warmth of the community also made a “big difference,” Ms. Gur said.

Rachel Marcus, who led the Jewish Community Center’s children’s department, remembered Ms. Weiss’ enthusiasm as she taught a cooking class there as a senior in high school.

“She cared about the kids, gave them very good directions and she made very good chocolate chip cookies,” Ms. Marcus said.

Tzippy Mazer, a former teacher and administrator at Community Day School, remembers the Weiss sisters as bundles of energy.

Advertise with us

Ms. Weiss was in the same class as Ms. Mazer’s son and was “always a go-getter.” Sometimes her outspokenness could run wild, Ms. Mazer recalled. “Being very opinionated doesn’t mean that you always do what you’re asked to do.”

Ms. Mazer taught Ms. Weiss Hebrew and Jewish studies for just one year, but it left an impact:

“Bari was a power to reckon with, even in second grade.”

The pair also traveled together on an eighth grade trip to Israel. The three weeks spent traversing the country brought up “challenging moments” for everyone: including roommate drama and reluctance to schlep luggage up several flights of stairs.

Ms. Weiss’ grandmother had been an early mentor to Ms. Mazer when the pair taught at Hillel Academy in Squirrel Hill. But Ms. Mazer never expected Ms. Weiss to follow in the family footsteps of being an educator: “I think conquering the world was more Bari,” she said.

Advertise with us

CBS News may well be a step in that direction.

Finding an audience

For most of her career, Ms. Weiss has had broad latitude to pursue the stories she was most interested in. Her Free Press podcasts, launched shortly after a high-profile exit from the Times, have hosted J.K. Rowling, the Harry Potter author and transgender critic, as well as Mark Cuban, a Pittsburgh billionaire famous for his role on “Shark Tank”.

Mr. Cuban is among those from Ms. Weiss’ hometown rooting for her.

“I’m looking forward to see what she does and how she does it,” he said in an email. “It’s a unique opportunity that she has earned. And it’s nice to know that she is from Pittsburgh. It can only help!”

Ms. Weiss is tasked with running a newsroom that covers far more than her favored topics. She made headlines her first week on the job for sending staff an email asking them to explain “how you spend your working hours.” Union officials told staff not to respond to the memo, which mirrored language Elon Musk used to weed out federal workers, and CBS executives later clarified that responses were optional.

Advertise with us

The stakes could not be higher for Ms. Weiss. Already this year, “60 Minutes” was forced to respond to a lawsuit by Trump accusing the news show of editing an interview with Kamala Harris. Paramount agreed to pay Trump a $16 million settlement in July, and the company’s merger with Skydance Media was approved weeks later.

“Thank goodness that all happened before she got there,” her father said.

Two days after the CBS announcement, Ms. Weiss sat down with Palmer Luckey, a billionaire defense contractor, for a fireside chat in Washington.

She joked about being more attractive in D.C. than New York City, and Mr. Luckey said he hoped her proximity to CBS could get him on the show “Survivor.” From there the pair — one wearing heels, the other OluKai flip flops — discussed killer drones and other aspects of modern warfare.

The one commonality Ms. Weiss seized on was that both have been ostracized for their views: Mr. Luckey for supporting Trump as a Facebook employee, Ms. Weiss for opinions she has described as incompatible with The New York Times, such as her support of Israel. Her viral resignation letter in 2020 helped jump-start the publication she would later co-found with sister Suzy that became The Free Press. The letter is no longer available on her website.

Advertise with us

At a 2017 event in Pittsburgh, Ms. Weiss described being Jewish as the most important part of her identity. A year later, she wrote about the massacre at Tree of Life Synagogue, where she was bat mitzvahed, for The New York Times. The reflection later became a book on antisemitism.

‘A very interesting evolution’

By that point, Ms. Weiss already had a fan in Matt Weinstein, a longtime administrator at both Pitt and Carnegie Mellon University. Mr. Weinstein, 53, said he was drawn to her writings as a student at Columbia University, where she accused faculty of anti-Israel bias, and later followed her work at The Free Press. He’s been less tuned in to her current programming.

“Have I watched ‘60 Minutes’ regularly in the last decade? No, not at all,” Mr. Weinstein said. And there’s very little Ms. Weiss could do to change that, he said, “because I just have so many more different sources [of information now].”

“I don’t need to wait until Sunday evening to get a recap on whatever the latest news is.” And for deeper dives on a particular topic, he said “I think podcasts have actually, in some ways, done even a better job.”

Mr. Weinstein said one of the strengths of The Free Press was its positioning as “the alternative to legacy media.”

Advertise with us

“And now she’s going to be leading a key component of legacy media. So how is she going to do it? Is she going to be, like, helping legacy media become more independent? Or does she bring that independence that she had at The Free Press into CBS? I think it’ll be a very interesting evolution to watch.”

It hasn’t been the easiest start. The onboarding email and Ms. Weiss’ lack of broadcast experience have already made staff wary.

“They have no idea which direction she’s going to go,” said Roma Torre, a longtime broadcast journalist who grew up in Pittsburgh and has recently been in touch with friends at CBS News. “Personally, I can’t give you a judgment, because I think it’s only fair to see what she does. I just know that, speaking to my friends personally, they’re very, very concerned.”

Ms. Torre’s mother, Marie Torre, was a news pioneer in her own right. She became Pittsburgh’s first woman TV news anchor when she joined KDKA in 1962 after serving jail time for refusing to reveal a source. She sees this as a challenging time for America’s tradition of a free press and a time when those leading media organizations have a responsibility to fight for that.

“I think the time has come when we have to put our foot down and look at the fourth estate as something that it’s so necessary to be preserved in this country, as our forefathers intended,” Roma Torre said, referring to the free press.

Advertise with us

“This whole notion of fake news is terrifying to me,” she said. “Anybody who has a particular leaning one way or another, I think, is very dangerous for our times.”

The industry needs reporters and editors who tell the truth without fear or favor, and without any kind of spin, Ms. Torre added. “Sadly, the spin has become the rule, not the exception.”

Ms. Torre, 67, grew up a few decades before Ms. Weiss, but her high school in Mt. Lebanon was a fierce rival of Shady Side. She doesn’t hold that against the new executive.

“There’s no denying she’s very smart and she’s very shrewd,” Ms. Torre said. “I just hope that she follows the rules of journalism, as opposed to the rules of politics, or the politics of the people who hired her.”

That would be David Ellison, the Paramount Skydance CEO whose father Larry Ellison is one of the richest men in the world. Trump has called the men “friends” and “big supporters.”

“They’ll do the right thing,” Trump said earlier this month.