It was Friday, it was sunny, and Alex Fisherman felt good.
The University of Pittsburgh junior was perched on the edge of a porch railing at a backyard party on Semple Street in Oakland. Below him was a crowd of hundreds dancing and swaying to the pulsating music, kicking off a weekend of St. Patrick’s Day celebrations.
Suddenly, he felt a strange sensation; the porch’s metal railings were curving underneath his feet. He jumped from the structure seconds before it collapsed.
“It all happened pretty quickly,” Mr. Fisherman said. “I just turned around, saw it falling, and then everybody was screaming and running around.”
He was among more than a dozen people injured after a roof crowded with partying young people collapsed on a building in the 300 block of Semple Street on Friday. Three of the injured were listed in serious condition the next day, said Pittsburgh Public Safety spokesperson Emily Bourne. Their conditions were unknown as of Tuesday afternoon.
The day after the incident, Mr. Fisherman was focused on recovering from a concussion. But hundreds of other students had a different outlook — it takes more than a porch roof collapse to stop the parties on Semple Street.
Read More
“Spirits were pretty high, honestly, I think because there weren’t any fatalities [from the collapse],” said Lauren Schulz, a Pitt junior living on Semple Street.
Early Saturday, the street was flooded with hundreds of revelers, most of them decked out in St. Patrick’s Day green and holding gallon-sized water containers filled with green liquor. They partied for hours in the street, in backyards and on various roofs until the city and campus police shutdown the festivities around 2 p.m.
After the police cleared the area, they issued a news release indicating a previously issued permit for an event in the area was revoked “due to the crowd size being significantly higher than what the event was permitted for.” Officials didn’t elaborate.
Pitt junior Evelyn Capobianco said Semple Street has been known as Pitt’s party hub for years.
“Anyone in any year can just go to Semple Street and there you are, at a party,” said Ms. Capobianco, who has herself taken part in festivities on Semple Street since she was a freshman.
It’s also the place to be during big events, like St. Patrick’s Day. There’s a “sense of tradition” behind Semple Street parties, Ms. Capobianco said. A roof collapsing and sending nearly 30 people crashing to the ground isn’t likely to deter that.
“[I give it] two weeks before people start going on the roofs again,” Ms. Capobianco said.
Problems along Semple Street have been recorded for decades. In 2008, 64 people were arrested — including 18 Pitt students— at the notorious “Semple Fest,” festival, which occurs each spring.
At the time, Pitt leadership vowed to crack down on the event and Semple Street parties in particular.
“The permanent residents of Semple Street are terrified by the actions of unruly students, and their options are to stay in their house or leave the neighborhood,” John Wilds, assistant vice chancellor for community and governmental relations, said at the time.
Nearly two decades later, those same problems persist.
Semple Street, lined with multiunit brick buildings where students live in off-campus apartments, has been a party scene for years, said Janice Markowitz, an Oakland resident for five decades.
“Two, three thousand students, they go from party to party to party on that street,” she said. “Binge drinking is the enemy. You can’t just keep making laws and not enforcing them. There needs to be enforcement.”
Ms. Bourne said there were no citations issued on Friday or Saturday on Semple Street, and any further action is not anticipated. Sarah Ayer, assistant vice chancellor for communications at the university, referred questions to city police. University police did not respond to requests for comment.
In addition to the lore of Semple Street, Mr. Fisherman said the area is almost entirely occupied by students, leaving few residents to complain and push for more oversight.
He doesn’t foresee that changing anytime soon.
“I think all things considered, people were feeling pretty lucky,” Mr. Fisherman said.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.