When Devin Coyne returned to her childhood home in Hazelwood to spend Thanksgiving with her family, she was shocked to see what had become of the library she'd visited so often growing up.
Trash littered the steps of the now-shuttered entrance, and overgrown brush lined the building's sides. The words etched in stone above the main doors — "Carnegie Library, Free to the People" — were stained by layers of dirt.
A look inside the broken windows of the once-picturesque building where she spent hours lost in books now reveals graffitied walls and collapsing ceiling tiles of the auditorium. Dust and rubble cover the stage that hosted town shows and after-school programs.
“Everything is kind of falling apart, and it's depressing to the community as a whole,” Ms. Coyne said.
The 125-year-old building on Monongahela Street has been abandoned and vacant since 2004 — the same year the Historic Review Commission of Pittsburgh declared it a historic building. In the years since, the city-owned property has continued to worsen. Gaping holes in the roof allow rain and snow to seep in and damage the interior.

For Hazelwood residents, this isn’t just another vacant shell – it’s a potential lifeline in a long-neglected neighborhood. For the past decade, the community has been waging a relentless battle to restore and transform the historic site into a vibrant public space, but escalating repair costs and funding shortfalls make it a race against time to save a piece of their neighborhood’s heritage.
“I just think it really won't survive in a way that is viable over the next two or three years,” said JaQuay Edward Carter, the founder of the Greater Hazelwood Historical Society.
While a new Carnegie Library branch was opened on Second Avenue in 2014, many residents share concerns about the historic building that served the community for over a century.
In 2019, the Urban Redevelopment Authority sought proposals to redevelop the building and adjacent land into a high-quality residential or community facility. The request emphasized the need to preserve the historic character of the former library, and return the building to its prominence as a public asset for a community that has lost 10% of its population over the past decade.

Mr. Carter teamed up with developers Pittsburgh Gateways, Jendoco Construction, HQ LLC project managers and MacLachlan Cornelius & Filoni Architects & Planners to create a proposal to turn the library into a community center. The vision included an event space that the public could rent, and an outdoor area where community groups could gather.
At the time, Mr. Carter said it would cost more than $3.7 million to redevelop the building, including cleaning and repairing the masonry, repairing or replacing the roof, and fixing the windows and doors.
Then the pandemic hit.
As the economy contracted, the team was unable to secure grant funding for the project. In the years since, the cost has only grown.
The most recent estimates for the project came in at $4.2 million, with $1.2 million needed for the roof alone, Mr. Carter said.
“It’s just more and more money that has to be put into it,” Mr. Carter said. “So there have been people interested in it, but when they hear that price tag and all the work that’s required with the building, they don’t follow through with it.”
Another effort to save the library involves the Hazelwood Initiative, a nonprofit that supports small businesses and affordable housing projects to keep residents in the community.
Along with architect Rob Pfaffmann, who led renovations of the Heinz History Center and the Homewood Library, the group is working with the Pittsburgh Economic & Industrial Development Corporation, a branch of the URA, to develop a rehabilitation strategy.
The development corporation and URA did not respond to requests for comment.
Over the last several months, the groups organized a series of community meetings and workshops to bring people in the neighborhood into the planning process for the library’s redevelopment. Residents have suggested turning the building into a performance space, fitness studio or site for educational programs for children.
“You hear about libraries in other neighborhoods, higher income neighborhoods, and they have different classes and weekly activities for kids to have somewhere to go, something to do,” Ms. Coyne said. “When you take that away, you're taking that opportunity from kids that otherwise don't have it because a lot of them can't get out of the neighborhood.”
But with the building on the brink of condemnation, vital maintenance needs to be completed to make the historic structure safe. The library is among at least 1,300 city-owned properties — 120 of them in Hazelwood — that have been tagged with code violations in recent years, a Post-Gazette investigation found.
“We don't need a savior, we just need a partner that will help us work at saving these valuable assets — such as the library,” said Kristina DiPietro, a lifelong Hazelwood resident.
The building itself has been cited with at least four violations for its broken windows and overgrown grass, city records show.
In 2023, inspectors noted that a chair had been propped up against the broken window, allowing people to climb inside the structure. When a Post-Gazette reporter visited the building in December, the chair was still there.
Mr. Carter said he would like to see the city put more effort into maintaining the buildings it owns, especially historical properties such as the library.
“A broken window in an underserved community like this actually creates other forms of violence, crime, people littering,” Mr. Carter said. “People are just totally neglecting the area around this property just because a window was broken out.”







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.