Pittsburgh police Chief Larry Scirotto will retire from the bureau, officials said Friday, just 16 months after he was sworn in and a week after he announced he would return to officiating college basketball on the side.

His retirement will be effective Nov. 1. Police generally receive a pension that’s equal to 50% of their pay — in the chief’s case, $185,400.

Public Safety Director Lee Schmidt praised the changes and initiatives the chief brought to the table over the past year and a half but said his departure shouldn’t be seen as a setback.

“The chief didn’t do that alone,” Mr. Schmidt said. “He had strong assistant chiefs under him … plus the entire command staff and all the officers every day helping move this bureau forward.

Advertise with us

“Any department, any bureau, is more than just one person,” he said.

The chief said in a press release Oct. 17 that he planned to return to refereeing NCAA basketball games — an announcement that surprised some city officials who were under the impression he’d given up the side gig when he was tapped as chief in May 2023.

Mayor Ed Gainey gave the chief his blessing to return to officiating, insisting that Chief Scirotto had improved the bureau to the point where he could do both.

“He had to do what was best for him and his family, and I’ll leave it at that,” the mayor said of his chief’s departure.

Earlier this week, the mayor indicated he’d accepted the chief’s offer to take a $20,000 pay cut to help pay for a new position of deputy chief — the person who would be in charge of the department while Chief Scirotto was on the basketball court.

Advertise with us

That person was set to be current Assistant Chief Chris Ragland, who will now become acting chief while city officials decide in which direction they will take the search for a permanent chief.

"Though I imagine his administration will try to find a way to twist it into a positive, it looks like Mayor Gainey was played on this one,” Councilman Bob Charland, who represents the South Side, said in a statement on Friday. “This is just another in the long list of incompetencies that my neighbors are fed up with."

Mr. Schmidt said Chief Scirotto’s announcement wasn’t necessarily a shock, noting that the potential for his retirement had been in discussions as the week progressed. He said that if they decided the chief’s dual jobs wouldn’t work out, Chief Scirotto would step away.

“I think I knew it was likely to happen in the next couple of days, but we were still going back and forth talking through nuances and some choices and decisions,” Mr. Schmidt said. “And this is where we landed.”

Mr. Gainey and Chief Scirotto both indicated that this had been the plan all along — that the chief could use his nine weeks of vacation and his normal three-day weekends to officiate while leading the police bureau.

Advertise with us

“That is the focus of my every day, and it doesn’t change whether I’m in Madison, Wis., or Portland, Ore., or I’m in Pittsburgh at my desk,” he told KDKA Radio last week.

Chief Scirotto told officers in an email Friday morning that his decision was what he thought was best for the bureau as well as himself and his family, something Mr. Schmidt said the chief echoed in giving his notice early Friday.

“Sometimes you make decisions and realize that wasn’t the best one and you have to change your mind and pivot a little,” Mr. Schmidt said. “We all do that every day, and I think that’s just what occurred in this case.”

Fallout from return to reffing

Mr. Gainey said Friday that there had always been a deal in place that Chief Scirotto could revisit officiating — and the idea of a youth sports program centered around his second job — once the department was in a better place than it was in May 2023.

“We talked about the homicides coming down and if he wanted to run this program where he was taking kids to different activities as part of him reffing, we could talk about it, and we did,” Mr. Gainey said.

Advertise with us

At least some council members were unaware that such a deal was in place, though Mr. Schmidt said he didn’t believe the chief was hired under false pretense nor did he think council members were misled.

In May 2023, as Mr. Gainey introduced Chief Scirotto as his pick for top cop, he said of the chief’s officiating: “We had a conversation about this, and at this time, he will not being doing that.”

Two weeks later during city council’s public interviews with Chief Scirotto, Mr. Coghill asked him to confirm his commitment to putting that job to the side.

“I know that you have committed to not pursue that profession while you’re here as a Pittsburgh police chief, correct?” Mr. Coghill asked.

Chief Scirotto replied: “Correct.”

Advertise with us

A post-agenda, or information-gathering meeting, was scheduled by council members for Tuesday afternoon. It was unclear Friday if that meeting would stand.

Chief Scirotto officiated an exhibition game Oct. 13 in Michigan. He publicly announced his return to officiating four days later. He told WESA that that game was on the up and up.

“There are no secrets, and there never have been,” he told the station Wednesday. “And there never will be. I’m very clear with my schedule, the mayor and the director of public safety know the days I’m away.”

How we got here

Chief Scirotto’s hiring was a homecoming of sorts. He had spent 23 years serving in the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police in multiple roles, including the commander of the major crimes unit and later assistant chief.

He came back to Pittsburgh from Fort Lauderdale, Fla., where he served as the city’s police chief before he was fired for allegedly favoring non-white candidates for promotions.

Advertise with us

The process to choose Chief Scirotto was lengthy — he was announced nearly a year after former chief Scott Schubert had announced his retirement — and fraught with criticism.

Mr. Gainey’s administration had conducted a nationwide search but kept much of the process under wraps. The city spent $80,000 to contract with the firm Public Sector Search & Consulting to assist in the search.

Additionally, three committees, including the union that represents the city’s police officers, interviewed the candidates. Only one of the committees — made up of community members — was listed publicly, and they have all signed non-disclosure agreements regarding the process.

In April 2023, the city narrowed the search down to three finalists: Chief Scirotto; Jason Lando, a former Pittsburgh police officer who is the chief of police in Frederick, Md., and Ryan Lee, the former chief of police in Boise, Idaho.

Though never charged, Mr. Lee had faced multiple complaints from his officers and severely injured a fellow officer while demonstrating a suspect-control movement.

Advertise with us

Between Mr. Schubert’s departure and Chief Scirotto’s swearing in, Tom Stangrecki had served as the acting chief. He has since left the city police bureau.

Correction, posted Oct. 26, 2024: The chief’s pension has been corrected.