It’s the suburban resident’s nightmare scenario, and it happened in Moon this week. A periodically unhoused person migrates to the suburbs and allegedly knifes to death a jogger — Benjamin Brallier, a husband, father and state law enforcement officer — along a popular trail, after having skipped a lenient bail on another charge.
It’s a tragedy seemingly designed in a laboratory to shatter the sense of security that draws people to suburban life, while appearing, fairly or not, to be another example of the metastasis of urban disorder from the city to the rest of southwestern Pennsylvania — and of the failure of the city’s public officials to address and contain it.
For that reason, it presents a major problem for the party on whose watch social disorder has visibly increased, while governing competence has visibly declined. In other words, the failures of Pittsburgh’s Democratic politicians are hurting Kamala Harris’ bid to lead in Washington.
Law and disorder
Ms. Harris’ closing argument to voters appears to be focused entirely on the obvious deficiencies of her opponent. The problem with this strategy is that it’s been tried since Donald Trump emerged as a political force nearly a decade ago, and it’s hard to imagine there are many voters left who will be swayed by one more person calling Trump a fascist.
More importantly, this claim is abstract when convincible voters’ concerns are specific and concrete.
In southwestern Pennsylvania — where, it must be remembered, nearly 90% of people live beyond Pittsburgh’s borders — those concerns include hearing about (in sometimes sensational terms) and personally experiencing a decline in social conditions in the region’s urban core. That includes stark increases in unsheltered homelessness and open drug use, as well as generally crass and unruly behavior in public spaces.
Read More
This kind of generalized disorder — very noticeable but not very quantifiable — helps make sense of the disconnect between everyday people’s impressions of crime (that it’s going up) and the statistical reality (that it’s stable or going down). To quote writer Charles Fain Lehman, social disorder involves the “domination of public spaces for private purposes,” which leaves people unable to enjoy places and experiences they have a right to enjoy.
And it leaves people outside the city worried about what will happen to their own communities if the kind of politicians running the city are allowed to run the country.
Breaking containment
That’s the natural political consequence when public authorities appear unable or, worse, unwilling to fulfill their responsibility to maintain social order.
Take the shambolic last 10 days at the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police. It began last Thursday with Chief Larry Scirotto’s surprise announcement that he would spend much of the next five months, with Mr. Gainey’s approval, jetting around the country officiating Big Ten basketball games. And it culminated this Friday with the chief’s retirement after only 16 months on the job, leaving the bureau in shambles and the people abandoned.
It’s a mortifying turn of events for a city that claims to be, and should be, a major American city, but whose leaders are clearly not capable of, or even interested in, maintaining that stature.
And it’s yet another episode — about exhibit No. 73 in the evidence catalog — that makes city government look incompetent and heedless of the basic duty to preserve order. Alongside continued struggles to address unsheltered homelessness, clumsy attempts by lone magistrates to reform criminal justice and an empowered activist class that insists on telling anyone made uncomfortable by all this that they’re the real problem, it adds up to a system that simply does not care about everyday people’s everyday concerns.
It’s one thing when these problems are sequestered largely within the city’s borders. It’s quite another when they appear to break containment, and in a violent way, as they did along the Montour Trail this week. Then it becomes clear that disorder can and will spread, that no one is fully safe from the problems associated with the city’s careless leadership.
Reverse coattails
Is it fair to blame an entire political party for the incompetence of one cohort of leaders? Of course it isn’t. Indeed, Pittsburgh has a rising class of much more impressive Democratic figures, such as controllers Corey O’Connor and Rachael Heisler, waiting just off stage. And County Executive Sara Innamorato is growing into her role in a way others have not.
But politics isn’t fair, and many voters — especially those suburbanites Ms. Harris is so desperately counting on — will be asking themselves in the coming days: Do I want the kind of governance I see in Pittsburgh applied across America?
It doesn’t help that the Harris campaign has settled on stoking speculative fear of Trump’s leadership as opposed to addressing the concrete fears of the voters she needs. It’s a strategy that may well remind people in southwestern Pennsylvania of the distant lack of concern they see in Pittsburgh’s leaders. And it may confirm for them that for their families right here and right now Trump is, despite his flamboyant flaws, the safer choice.
In other words, Pittsburgh’s leadership might deliver Donald Trump to the White House.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Are Pa. Democrats overreaching on abortion?”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.