Attorneys for Pittsburgh and for the union representing city police made their cases for and against an arbitrator’s ruling earlier this year that Keith Edmonds, the officer at the center of the controversial death of Jim Rogers in 2021, should get his job back.

Officer Edmonds was fired alongside several other officers in early 2022, months after Rogers’ fatal encounter with police on Oct. 13, 2021. A neutral arbitrator, identified in court filings as Marc Winters, ruled in March that Officer Edmonds should be reinstated to the Pittsburgh police and receive back pay.

The city appealed the arbitrator’s ruling, which indicated that while Officer Edmonds didn’t follow policies to the letter, he didn’t violate them, either. Attorneys for the city said the ruling eviscerated the city’s right to enforce its own policies.

Attorneys for both sides detailed their arguments across hundreds of pages of court filings that laid the groundwork for a relatively brief, hourlong hearing Thursday in front of Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Alan Hertzberg.

Advertise with us

“There were a lot of pages,” Judge Hertzberg mused ahead of the hearing.

Arbitration panels are made up of three arbitrators: A neutral arbitrator, in this case, Mr. Winters, and one so-called “partial arbitrator” representing each side. In Officer Edmonds’ hearing, FOP President Bob Swartzwelder was the partial arbitrator for the union and assistant city solicitor Juan Rivera represented the city.

For a decision to be binding, at least two of the three arbitrators must approve the ruling. In this case, Mr. Swartzwelder agreed with Mr. Winters’ findings. Majority decisions are generally binding, and there are few circumstances that can prompt court review or a reversal.

“The arguments made by the city were spurious at best,” Mr. Swartzwelder said after the Thursday hearing. “They lost the case.”

Judge Hertzberg offered no timetable for his decision.

Advertise with us

The city has long held that the actions — and inactions — of officers in Bloomfield that morning led to Rogers’ death the next day. It is the opening line of its appeal: “Mr. Jim Rogers should be alive,” attorneys wrote, alleging that Officer Edmonds “instigated the circumstances that led to Mr. Rogers’ death.”

Mr. Winters noted in his ruling, though, that Officer Edmonds’ termination letter “did not cite or charge [him] with any aspect of Mr. Rogers’ death.”

In their response, attorneys for the FOP point to the autopsy report prepared by the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s Office. The filing offers, for the first time publicly, a closer look at what the medical examiner said caused and contributed to Rogers’ death.

The medical examiner’s office official ruled Rogers’ death an accident caused by a lack of oxygen to the brain. The court filing indicates the medical examiner found that “the brain injury was found due to his seizure disorder …” The filing cites UPMC Mercy records that reference diagnoses of bipolar and schizophrenia as well.

Each side makes a case

A portion of the city’s argument focuses on arbitration rules and procedures — and allegations that Mr. Winters violated those rules and procedures.

Advertise with us

Among them: That the award, or final ruling, was made public before all parties had signed and acknowledged the paperwork. Assistant city solicitor Irene Thomas said that, on its own, should render the arbitrator’s decision null.

Attorneys for the FOP waved off that assertion, noting that the city’s partial arbitrator still signed the award the same day. Mr. Swartzwelder, after the hearing, called the argument irrelevant.

“Whether it’s released or it’s not released, the fact still remains that Officer Edmonds — the charges against him were not proven,” he said. “And now you want to act like a signature page causes the award to be overturned, which is the most ridiculous thing I’ve ever heard.”

Another portion of the city’s argument, though, focuses on Mr. Winters’ interpretation of the police contract as it pertains to firings. The city’s contract with police relies on a separate, state-level statute as its guide for firings, which are also referred to as terminations, removals or discharges.

“The parties recognize that the procedure for appointments, promotions, and reduction of force, suspensions and discharges is as provided by the Police Civil Service Act …”

Advertise with us

That provision means that if one is looking for the policies on firing an officer, Ms. Thomas said, look to state law, and the state law says this: “No employee … shall be removed, discharged, suspended, demoted or placed on probation, except for just cause, which shall not be religious or political.”

The Police Civil Service Act, or PCSA, doesn’t define “just cause,” which is the term at the heart of a portion of the city’s argument.

But, the appeal claimed, while it’s not defined by the state, it has been interpreted by the courts over the years.

The argument by the city is this: It’s clear that Mr. Winters didn’t take into account the PCSA because his arbitration award makes no mention of the act and doesn’t cite any case law surrounding the interpretation of “just cause.”

The city alleges that if Mr. Winters had followed historical case law on the topic, he would have found that Officer Edmonds’ “violation of the rules and regulations constituted just cause for his termination.”

Advertise with us

Ron Retsch, the attorney representing the FOP, said in his argument that for all the city’s talk about case law, none of it is cited in the appeal.

“The city, in its arguments, never identifies controlling case law that identifies a set of elements or criteria that an arbitrator must use in every instance under the civil service act,” he said.

In short, the FOP’s argument is that regardless of case law, when “just cause” isn’t defined, the arbitrator has the power to interpret what that means.

“Since ‘just cause’ is not defined in the act, it’s not defined in the CBA, it’s not defined in Pennsylvania case law, it’s defined as a specific set of criteria in any case law provided by the city — it then becomes a matter of contractual interpretation of the arbitrator,” Mr. Retsch said.

On top of everything else, the city argues in its appeal, Officer Edmonds admitted in his testimony during arbitration that he violated numerous policies.

Advertise with us

Those alleged policy violations make up the crux of the city’s original reasoning for firing Officer Edmonds in the first place. The policies the city alleges he violated include those related to warrantless searches and seizures, de-escalation, use of deadly force, neglect of duty, handling of prisoners, and use of paper aerosol restraint spray.

For example, the appeal claims, Officer Edmonds “admitted that he tased Mr. Rogers because he would not ‘comply,’ ” which attorneys said is against bureau policy.

Mr. Winters, in his final arbitration ruling, conceded that Officer Edmonds did not follow policies and procedures, but he didn’t necessarily violate them to the point of termination. He wrote that while Officer Edmonds “may not have followed each and every policy, rule and regulation for which he was charged by the strict letter or strictest interpretation of that policy, rule or regulation, [Officer Edmonds] did not violate them either.”

The ruling continued: “Each policy, rule and regulation cited contains language that would permit officers to use their discretion and/or interpretation of the policies, rules and regulations based on the situation offering in front of [them] and/or the totality of the circumstances.”

The city settled a federal lawsuit with Rogers’ estate last year for $8 million.

Advertise with us

The day of the incident, Officer Edmonds was dispatched to Harriet Street after someone called 911 to report that a man might have been trying to steal a bicycle from a porch. Some neighbors, however, later would contend the bike was left outside and was free for the taking.

Video released earlier this year by an attorney for Rogers’ family showed the officer’s interactions with Rogers.

Rogers, the video shows, has no bike when the officer arrives. The interaction seems at first tense but nonviolent. Officer Edmonds tells Rogers to put his hands up. Rogers appears to become flustered when the officer reached into his pocket, and he starts trying to put his hands into his pockets. Officer Edmonds drops him to the ground.

The video shows the officer deploying his Taser around 10 times as more officers arrived on scene. Rogers appeared to become more disoriented and, while he tried twice to run away, he otherwise remained sitting or on his hands and knees.

Rogers was ultimately taken into custody and sat for 17 minutes in the back of a police cruiser, often screaming, banging his head, and shouting that he couldn’t breathe. He wasn’t breathing by the time he arrived at UPMC Mercy about 45 minutes after the original 911 call.