An investigation by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette and ProPublica was named a finalist for the 2024 Goldsmith Prize for Investigative Reporting for stories that exposed how government regulators failed to act on hundreds of complaints about dangerous breathing machines made by Philips Respironics that were capable of spewing hazardous particles into the lungs of patients.

The investigation, With Every Breath, by Michael D. Sallah of the Post-Gazette and Debbie Cenziper of ProPublica, who co-led the project, and the Post-Gazette's Michael Korsh and Evan Robinson-Johnson along with Northwestern University's Medill Lab students Monica Sager and Margaret Fleming, is one of six finalists for the prestigious award from 170 entries submitted by news organizations.

The others include the New York Times, STAT, Streetsblog, Mississippi Today and a ProPublica series about questionable ethics involving Supreme Court justices.

The winner of the award, which is administered by by the Shorenstein Center on Media, Politics and Public Policy at Harvard, will be announced at a ceremony at the university's Kennedy School of Government in Cambridge, Mass., on April 3.

Advertise with us

“This year’s finalists went to extraordinary lengths to uncover the truth — mixing classic shoe-leather journalism with the kind of shrewd and scrappy reporting that inspires new generations to enter the field and seasoned reporters to stick with it,” said Nancy Gibbs, director of the Shorenstein Center. “In a time of great uncertainty, these finalists remind us of journalism’s vital role in our democracy.”

The Post-Gazette and ProPublica’s yearlong investigation showed how Philips, which operates two manufacturing plants near Pittsburgh, received more than 3,700 reports dating back more than a decade about an industrial foam in the popular devices that could break down and release cancer-causing materials into the air paths of the devices. Despite federal law, the device maker failed to turn over the complaints to the government until after the 2021 recall.

The reporters also showed the U.S. Food and Drug Administration received hundreds of complaints, including reports of contamination and foam degradation, but failed to launch an investigation or alert the public until after the recall. In the aftermath of the stories, Philips agreed in January to stop making the devices in the United States for years to come under a consent decree with the Justice Department, all but ending the company’s position as one of the top makers of breathing machines in the nation.

In addition, two prominent U.S. senators called for a government investigation into the FDA's oversight of Philips and the medical device industry. The Government Accountability Office, the investigative arm of Congress, said it would lead the probe.

The Goldsmith announcement comes just weeks after the Post-Gazette and ProPublica were named winners of the national George Polk Award for the Philips investigation. The reporters will be recognized at a ceremony in New York on April 12.