Ralph B. was sweeping up fallen leaves Tuesday afternoon, in a spot left bare in the cleanup of the First Avenue encampment. He was thinking about what’s next.

When he woke up that morning, he wasn’t quite sure where he’d be sleeping that night. City outreach workers had since told him they found openings in a McKeesport shelter and Wood Street Commons. Ralph had only stayed in this encampment for about a week or so before the notice came that he and other encampment residents must leave within a week. He’s figuring out his options.

“It was something that was in the works yesterday and then they solidified that and made it happen today,” Ralph said Tuesday. “I've been homeless for almost a year now, so I'm just bouncing around a lot. It's hard to stay at, you know, one location, as a solid location, because obviously places are being told that we have to move.”

The First Avenue encampment, which sits along Grant Street and Boulevard of the Allies, is among the first of several encampments expected to be cleared out as a city committee evaluates conditions at these sites. The public safety department said crime and safety concerns led them to prioritize First Avenue, and it’s the first clearing under a new city policy that dictates procedures around decommissions. 

Advertise with us

By Tuesday’s deadline, the encampment was not fully cleared, with removal of trash and personal belongings still in motion by city crews. A Department of Public Safety spokesperson said they are hoping to transition everyone out by the end of the week. All residents have “credible offers of housing,” but the city is not, according to the department, disclosing where people are going for “privacy reasons.” 

On Tuesday, people living in the roughly 10 tents in the area were tossing items in the back of pickup trucks, into bins and garbage bags. Residents lent helping hands to those in neighboring tents.

Outreach groups, workers from the city’s Office of Community Health and Safety, Department of Public Safety Director Lee Schmidt and County Councilwoman Bethany Hallam were among those overlooking the effort that day. 

Outcomes seem mixed, based on what residents and advocates had to say, with some opting for beds at local shelters like Wood Street Commons. One couple said they plan to move their tent somewhere else in the city and others were planning to do the same. They don’t want to stray too far from the people and area they know. 

By the afternoon, Ralph had already packed up his bike, spare shoes, tent and other belongings, and city workers transported them to a storage facility for later pickup. Though Ralph didn’t know where that was at the moment. He had a number to call to collect items, adding that workers told him delivery services were also available.  

Advertise with us

As the 5 p.m. deadline inched closer, Mr. Schmidt said people were making good progress, with a handful of tents still standing.

“The big thing is there's a lot of progress that's happened,” he said. “Quite a few tents are gone, and quite a few folks have been moved, so we're gonna keep at it … I think right now, it’s as successful as we kind of expected, as successful as it can be.”

Mr. Schmidt said the city is continuing to support people getting placed where they want to be based on the location and support services available. Some had expressed their desire to remain in tents and are finding an alternative spot to camp, he said.

“Some people do, and they tend to want to stay in tents,” he said. “There's people that have lived outside for a long, long time and they'll continue to do that. We just want to make sure they're in a safe space that they can be.”

But the ambiguity of where exactly is the right place to be remains a source of concern for advocates like Russell Beyer of Community Care and Resistance in Pittsburgh, which provides direct aid like cash, supplies and transportation for unhoused people and those recently released from the Allegheny County Jail.

Advertise with us

“You're nothing but shuffling chairs on the Titanic, right?” he said. “That's kind of what we're doing.”

Mr. Beyer came to the encampment with food, snacks, buckets and other necessities to aid the cleanup. He wanted to be there to keep watch over people and make sure officials were treating them “acceptably” in the process.

He is glad to hear the city has identified shelter spaces for the residents who want them. Though when it comes to larger encampments, he wonders how officials expect to see a similar outcome.

“It looks like there might be some placement of Wood Street Commons, where there is some availability,” he said. “But at the end of the day, this is a small percentage of the number of tents. There's another eight or nine behind the jail. There's Chestnut Street. You have 30 times this number of people, maybe 150 people, probably out there in tents. There's not 150 beds.”

He said the Gainey administration has made strides in addressing the crisis. City council has discussed several options to expand transitional housing, such as tiny homes. City spokesperson Maria Montaño has indicated that the administration has no intention to enforce their tent clearance policy unless unhoused people have a “credible offer of housing.”

Advertise with us

But with the shelter system already under so much strain, he wonders why the city is taking these steps to steer people out of encampments without a steady flow of beds to put them in. The committee designated to look at the issue is continuing to assess more possible sites to clean and clear out.

“This administration is doing more than the previous ones have done,” he said. “There's still not a solution. There's still not an answer. Why tell these people they can't be in a tent and then not tell them where they can be there?”

And while city leaders have set clear rules for how they would handle decomissions after sitting in a kind of policy limbo for two decades, Chase Archer Evans, a member of Allegheny County’s Homeless Advisory Board, said the policy has already fallen short of its promises. 

The policy not only outlines a process for notifying unhoused people, but those who work closely with the homeless population too. The memorandum states, “Notice will be faxed and emailed three (3) days in advance of posting to a list of homeless service providers, to be identified by Pittsburgh’s Homeless Outreach Coordinating Committee.”

Mr. Evans says he is on this list of providers, and the notification never came. Instead, he found out on his own just a couple of days ago. 

Advertise with us

“I helped make that list,” he said. “I put my name on it. Why wasn't I notified? If you didn't notify the list identified by us, the committee, then you didn't follow policy. It's that simple.”

He said based on what he saw Tuesday, overall, officials have handled the cleanup relatively well, and he understands that such encampment clearings will happen. But it’s the failure to follow the very policy they outlined that frustrates him most. 

“I hate it, but there's really nothing I can do but advise,” he said. “That's part of my job. It's a 100 percent the lack of communication. Like, that communication is a key point in how to do this, and whether you're doing it right or not.”

Mr. Evans expressed his frustrations directly to Mr. Schmidt during the cleanup in a tense exchange. Mr. Schmidt acknowledged the lapse in notifying Mr. Evans of the decision, and told the Post-Gazette that they will rectify this in future decommissions. 

“This is the first one since the policy was enacted,” he said. “Not everything's going to go perfect. We're going to learn and get better each time. There was maybe some miscommunication that happened, but we'll correct it. We did notify our providers that we work with on a daily basis but it just didn't quite get filtered to a large group.”

Advertise with us

In the meantime, Ralph said he is remaining optimistic as he transitions to a shelter. 

“It's not a choice to be homeless in a lot of aspects,” he said. “Sometimes, you know, people fall on hard times and those dominoes don't seem to stop falling and then they end up in this position ... But there's more outreach now than I've ever seen. I can tell you that.”