South Side Flats, an entertainment and residential neighborhood, is referred to as a “parking enhancement district” – an area where parking meter revenue can be collected after 6 p.m. with specified pricing rates.
This area was converted to an enhancement district in 2016 as part of a pilot program with the intent of generating nighttime revenue in a specific location, which is then used for business-area enhancements in the same zone.
But an audit report released Wednesday by City Controller Michael Lamb found discrepancies in the district’s revenue reports from the Pittsburgh Parking Authority.
“We did identify some concerns while assessing the documentation of revenue, which comes from a single source: meter collection within the South Side Flats Parking Enhancement District,” Mr. Lamb said in a letter to Mayor Ed Gainey and the City Council.
According to the letter, all revenue is collected by the PPA, which provides an annual spreadsheet detailing the monies from parking payments in the district each year. These spreadsheets used “active” data when they were created.
For the audit, the controller’s office asked the PPA to generate reports from its Flowbird system using “historic” parking meter data from 2018 and 2019. These numbers were then compared to the annual spreadsheet data from earlier years.
But, PPA was unable to recreate annual or daily reports of revenue to support totals that were previously transferred to the city.
“We were advised by PPA administrators that its reporting system, Flowbird, was unable to capture historical data in the same fashion that active — or current data — is captured due to the time it can take for certain types of transactions to fully settle,” Mr. Lamb said in the letter.

In the current reports, the total revenue collection was $212,030.51 and $205,439.52 for 2018 and 2019 respectively. However, in previous annual spreadsheets, the total revenue collection for 2018 and 2019 was $216,275.11 and $208,401.09 respectively.
Immediately, the controller’s office noticed the difference between the two reports. PPA told the office that the discrepancies were a result of the reporting system, which used “historic data” to create current-day reports and “active data” to create the annual spreadsheets.
“It is important to note that PPA was unable to provide any further documentation or support justifying the differences between the original reports given to the City and the new reports generated during our audit,” Mr. Lamb said in the letter. “Therefore, our concern is that documentation available does not sufficiently account for the accuracy of the revenue totals reported to the City.”
Further documentation from the system also showed revenue divisible by $0.25 for coin and mobile payments, but not for credit card payments, meaning they were not in line with the $1.50 per hour dynamic pricing strategy. This was not present on all charges, but PPA was unable to provide a reason for anomalies, which produced amounts such as $1.05, $1.08 and so on.
A report provided at the beginning of the audit also detailed a total of 62 parking meters in the zone, but purchase reports given to the controller’s office at a later date, which showed daily item-by-item transactions for the district, listed 99 unique meter IDs.
Because of these issues, the controller’s office recommended the PPA obtain information on the processing times for all transaction types and why certain credit card transitions don’t align with the dynamic pricing strategy. It also recommended the authority confirm knowledge of how to run reports for specific dates in the past and generate the same data and how to run reports that consistently reflect the same total number of meters available.
David Onorato, executive director of PPA, said in a letter to Mr. Lamb that the PPA appreciated the audit’s constructive feedback and acknowledgement that the parking enforcement district is a first time thing for the city.
“The parking authority is fully committed to following the recommendations of this audit and, in most cases, solutions have already been identified and implemented,” Mr. Onorato said in the letter.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.