One common myth about tornadoes is that they cannot form and travel along mountain ridges, in hilly areas, or in high altitudes.
A walk along the 400 block of William Street in Pittsburgh fits that description. Located in the hilly terrain of Mount Washington, William Street juts off the meeting point of Boggs and Bailey Avenues, before winding down a leafy, wooded area near Emerald View Trail, which snakes down to East Sycamore Street. Homes line the northern side of the road, many two to three stories high with views of the Pittsburgh skyline and Monongahela River.
On June 2, 1998, the myth was debunked.
That day, witnesses saw at least 14 tornadoes rip through Western Pennsylvania, injuring dozens and leaving severe damage across the Pittsburgh metropolitan area. One tornado touched down northwest of the borough of Carnegie just before 6 p.m., before traveling toward Mount Washington — aiming right at the homes of Dana Barker, and Patrick and Jeannine Borelli.
All three survived, despite that tornado reaching speeds of 110 miles per hour. It left extensive damage to both properties. Ms. Barker recalled a quarter of her roof being torn off, while the Borellis had their entire roof thrown into the front yard as the cyclone wound its way through William Street. It then headed east, covering a path that was roughly 32 miles long, according to the National Weather Service.

Mrs. Borelli remembers cooking pork chops on the back deck that day, while her sons — 13-year-old Patrick, and 10-year-old Michael — were inside watching TV. Then, she saw three dark clouds in the distance .
“I thought, is that my imagination?” she recalled.
It wasn’t. A tornado was coming. She told her sons to get to the basement. Mrs. Borelli, who joked that her two sons would often ignore her commands, said they immediately got the message.
“‘It was your tone, mom. We knew it was serious,’” Mrs. Borelli, now 72, recalled them saying after the tornadoes hit.
Not too far away, Mrs. Borelli’s husband was driving home from work at Matthews International in Robinson Township, an industrial manufacturing firm. Patrick Borelli, now 69, was battling high winds and driving around trees, debris and parts of buildings in the streets near his home.
Living on Mount Washington, people would always say residents on top of the hill would never have to worry about the dangers of tornadoes or floods, Mr. Borelli said.
“They’re wrong about the tornadoes, but they’re right about the floods,” he said.

It was a miracle no one in Mount Washington was hurt, Mr. Borelli said. Debris as large as doors and pieces of roofs were flying through the air as he drove to the top of Wyoming Street, he said — and as he tried to exit his GMC Suburban, the wind was so strong it prevented him from opening the door.
At the next house up the road from the Borellis, two older women would often sit in the window facing the street. On the day of the storm, they took cover near that window, Mr. Borelli said. When a tree fell into their front yard, it narrowly missed their usual spot, he said.
“If it went three or four feet the wrong way, it would have crushed both of them,” Mr. Borelli said.
Further down on William Street, Dana Barker was busy unpacking in her second-story bedroom, she said. Ms. Barker had just moved into the home she began renting on June 1, 1998.
She was looking toward the skyline and suddenly saw a storm and funnel cloud forming. When it hit her house, she could feel all four walls expanding, she said.
Ms. Barker, now 55, took cover near a doorway, and waited it out.
“I can remember the sound: It was eerie and awful,” she said, echoing what she told the Post-Gazette a quarter-century ago.
Ms. Barker said after the tornado moved on, she returned the U-Haul truck she had used for her move to a local dealer. As she returned home, the Pennsylvania National Guard had blocked off William Street. She had trouble getting access to her house and belongings, she said — until she showed a guardsman her U-Haul order slip, the only paperwork she had with her William Street address.
It was a good thing she kept the slip, Ms. Barker said — because otherwise, she wouldn’t have been able to get clothes and other important belongings before moving to stay with a friend in the South Side Slopes.
Surveying the destruction
The whirlwind that tore through Mount Washington and continued eastward wasn’t the only one that hit the Pittsburgh area that day. According to the National Weather Service, nine tornadoes touched down from as far west as Beaver County, as far north as Jefferson County, and stretching into northern West Virginia and western Maryland. Reporting by the Post-Gazette at the time indicated there were at least 14.
Post-Gazette reporting in the days following the tornadoes detailed the destruction. At least 16 people were hospitalized around the city. One tornado in Salisbury — in Somerset County — destroyed 43 homes and businesses, injured 15 people and killed a 13-year-old girl who was walking home from a graduation party.
And the storms also left severe damage to St. Stephen Church in Hazelwood, ripping off the copper dome and cross atop the church’s roof, slamming them into the side steps. Rev. Neil McCaulley said at the time that it was a miracle none of the eighth-graders who were celebrating a graduation mass there were hurt or killed.
“If we had gone to the basement, we would have been on those steps when the cross came down,” Rev. McCaulley said. “And, coming down with the force it did, it would definitely have been lethal.”
A cyclone further to the west had moved a home off its foundation on the 100 block of Holt Road in Beaver County. In the days after, Randy Lyle was stunned as he walked around and assessed the damage, the Post-Gazette reported the next day.
Twenty-five years later, his daughter, Randi Lyle, recalled that the garage on the property was “completely gone, obliterated” by the tornado. She wasn’t home, but she was worried about a mixed-breed dog, named Scruffy, that was in the house.
Scruffy was fine. And things could have been much worse, said Ms. Lyle, who was nine when the tornado hit.
“Now that I’m older, knowing what damage can occur from a tornado, I’m lucky that where we were, we were safe … and knowing what happened, [that] it didn’t completely destroy our house,” Ms. Lyle said.
The science and history of tornadoes in the Pittsburgh region
Dan Malerbo was one of the people shocked to see a tornado touching down in Pittsburgh, given the city’s topography. Mr. Malerbo was working as education coordinator for the Buhl Planetarium at the Carnegie Science Center. He was on a ramp with colleagues inside the building facing Mount Washington when he saw a tornado traveling toward that neighborhood.
“We were in total shock, total disbelief that a tornado could touch down in the city of Pittsburgh,” said Mr. Malerbo, who retired in 2018. “We know they touched down north of Pittsburgh, in Crawford County or [south in] Washington County … but never in the city. “We thought of the misconception that the hills would protect us.”
But May and June are the worst months for weather in the Pittsburgh region, he said, due to the mixture of cold air sinking and warm air rising, which can create powerful storms — even tornadoes.
Lee Hendricks has worked as a meteorologist at the National Weather Service’s Moon Township location since 1985. He said that the same air mass — a cold front traveling southeast — helped contribute to the tornadoes on June 2, 1998.
Mr. Hendricks said it was fortunate that no one died in the city, given that the tornadoes touched down during rush hour. Post-Gazette reporting in 2020 highlighted a different deadly tornado outbreak in June 1944, when well over 100 people died and several hundred others were injured in storms that hit Port Vue, Boston, and the surrounding areas in Allegheny County.

One of them was a “big (F4) tornado that touched down and tore through 50 miles in Allegheny County near McKeesport, killed 17 people, destroyed 80 homes and damaged another 300,” the Post-Gazette reported in 2020.
The transitions of the seasons tend to lead to stronger cold fronts, Mr. Hendricks said. Combine that with warm, moist air ahead of them, and it can lead to severe weather, he said.
“If you have a very cold air mass pushing in, rapidly into warm, moist air, you’re going to have weather, and the stronger it is and faster it is, the more violent the weather,” Mr. Hendricks said.
The aftermath — and a thank-you to those who helped rebuild
The Borellis had to do a lot of work to rebuild their William Street home in the aftermath of the 1998 twister. The timing couldn’t have been worse. Mr. Borelli said he had already spent tens of thousands of dollars over a span of 20 to 25 years remodeling it, finishing the work weeks before the tornado hit.

He took out a $150,000 loan, and people around the city pitched in to help. The family moved out until March 2000, Mr. Borelli said. He’s thankful for all of the volunteers — especially a retired union contractor who served in the U.S. Army.
“John L. Price is the reason I got the house back … without him, I would have never gotten back into that house,” Mr. Borelli said.
Ms. Barker, walking along William Street recently, talked about the things that have changed in the past 25 years. Vegetation and greenery along the street and woods has grown denser, making it more difficult to see properties higher up the hill.
But she said it’s nice to know that people still come together after tragedies. Mrs. Borelli agreed.
“I worked my whole life, and never asked for anything for free,” she said. “But it was overwhelming, the kindness you felt, and the generosity of people.”
When Mr. Hendricks remembers the tornadoes of June 2, 1998, he thinks that numbers themselves don’t necessarily indicate a tornado outbreak is imminent. High temperatures need to be in the mid- to upper-80s, with dew points in the mid-60s or higher. That didn’t happen in this case, Mr. Hendricks said.
But with the right mix of conditions, strong tornadoes can happen, even in the Pittsburgh region.
“It’s kind of like cooking,” Mr. Hendricks said. You throw in all the ingredients and have a good pot of pasta sauce … This day, we had all the perfect ingredients to have the tornado outbreak that we did.”
Steve Bohnel: sbohnel@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.