Owners and management of the Roosevelt Building cannot evict tenants without a court order, an Allegheny County judge ruled Thursday, telling attorneys for both sides their focus should be on finding housing for tenants of the fire- and water-damaged high rise.

Common Pleas Judge Patrick Connelly had already given a verbal order Wednesday saying tenants could not be forced out or locked out come Friday as they had been expecting for weeks.

“Defendants [LWE Roosevelt and NDC Real Estate Management] shall not engage in any actions to interfere with the occupancy of any tenants or to remove any tenant or tenants’ personal property from the Roosevelt Building,” Judge Connelly wrote in the order.

The order is a temporary one but a win nonetheless for residents who’d yet to vacate the partially condemned building and would otherwise have been without housing by the weekend.

Advertise with us

“Today the tenants stood up for their rights and the court has supported them,” said Dan Vitek, an attorney with the Community Justice Project, which is working with and representing tenants of the Roosevelt Building.

Residents will have to find new housing eventually, but the notion of eviction has been halted by the judge’s order. Tenants and attorneys said they’d been threatened with police intervention if they weren’t out by Friday and told they’d be locked out and forfeit any belongings left in the building.

The goal now, Mr. Vitek said, is to focus on finding housing for the roughly 30 to 35 people who still have no permanent place to stay. Judge Connelly will supervise that process, the details of which will come more into focus at a court hearing sometime next week.

Jon Kamin, the attorney representing building ownership and management, presented witnesses who argued that the entirety of the building was uninhabitable, not just the units condemned by the city.

A fire on the 12th floor Dec. 11 set the situation in motion. Although flames were brought under control in less than two hours, sprinklers ran for longer, causing water damage whose full extent wasn’t realized for several days.

Advertise with us

One woman died in the blaze, 80-year-old Barbara Johnson.

Residents, many of whom live in apartments subsidized by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, were evacuated to the David L. Lawrence Convention Center and then to local hotels. Some were initially allowed to return to their homes.

The entire building was initially condemned by the city, but that was modified once one elevator was restored. By Dec. 20, according to the court filing, only apartments on the 11th floor and two units on all other floors were condemned. Management notified residents Dec. 23 that they must be out by Jan. 13 so renovations could begin.

Eight residents filed a lawsuit Wednesday seeking an emergency injunction, arguing they would be homeless if the management made good on its promise to lock them out Friday.

In the second day of testimony Thursday, Jacob Colson, an industrial hygienist with Texas-based Ensolum, said water and fire damage had sent asbestos into the air, creating a hazard for anyone not specially equipped to be exposed to it during the abatement process.

Advertise with us

The water damage also creates conditions ripe for bacterial and fungal growth, he said, but noted that such growth was “assumed” in this case because of the sheer amount of water that collected. The sprinklers in part of the building ran for more than two hours, something he noted as unusual for the size and scope of the fire.

Beyond that, Mr. Colson said, the building won’t be fit for occupancy once abatement efforts and renovations are underway. He said stairwells and elevators will be unusable once they’re being used for staging equipment and hauling equipment, and the very nature of the work will clog hallways and create safety hazards.

He said the city’s condemnation order “isn’t representative of the damage.”

David Green, assistant director of the city’s Department of Permits, Licenses and Inspections, said the things like asbestos and air quality do not fall under the purview of his department, and so he stood by the updated condemnation order.