Pittsburgh police Tuesday said a “series of procedural failures” contributed to the incident that led up to the October death of Jim Rogers, the man who died a day after officers used a stun gun on him multiple times in Bloomfield.
The police department also announced that disciplinary action was pending for eight officers, including two supervisors, involved in the incident.
The death of the 54-year-old drew public condemnation and remains under investigation by the Allegheny County district attorney’s office. The county medical examiner’s office has not released the cause of Rogers’ death.
Police officials admitted that issues occurred during the incident as they announced procedural and policy changes recommended by an internal Critical Incident Review Board empaneled following Rogers’ death.
The recommendations include:
- Any use of force incident will require the presence of a supervisor on scene to complete a medical assessment and request appropriate personnel.
- Any incident involving the deployment of a Taser will require EMS personnel to assess the patient.
- City police personnel will be retrained in accordance with established training academy duty to intervene policy.
- Police will streamline its organizational review of Use of Force by both appropriate command staff and the training academy to expeditiously ensure policy compliance.
“It is imperative that every critical incident is reviewed promptly,” Wendell Hissrich, the city’s public safety director, said in a statement. “By identifying the problem, it allows us to expeditiously make corrections that are put into policy in a timely manner.”
Read More
The incident has drawn public scrutiny and protests critical of the police’s handling of Rogers’ arrest for what authorities said was theft of a bicycle on Harriet Street on Oct. 13. Neighbors said the bike was put outside to be given away because its owner no longer wanted it.
Witnesses said they saw a police officer use a Taser on Rogers multiple times after he refused to listen to the officer’s commands to put his hands behind his back. Although witnesses said he appeared not to be complying with the officer’s demands, they described Rogers as nonviolent and not aggressive.
Rogers was taken by police to a hospital after his arrest. He was pronounced dead on the morning of Oct. 14.
Eight city police officers, including two supervisors, will face varying levels of discipline for the incident, the department said, though details were not provided.
In response to Tuesday's announcement, Beth Pittinger, the executive director of the independent Citizen Police Review Board, said the discipline seemed "appropriate, and it's the right thing to do." It was "refreshing" to see supervisory accountability, she added.
But, looking more broadly, Ms. Pittinger said the industry should re-evaluate the efficacy of using Tasers in the field.
"As we've seen across the country, and now locally as well, it's not quite as non-lethal as it's been promoted," she said.
Prior to Rogers’ death, Ms. Pittinger said there were policy changes that essentially lowered the threshold for when an officer should use a Taser. The tactic may have been a way to promote de-escalation, she said, but resulted in an increased use in Tasers.
Now, she is working on a report for the police bureau on the efficacy of Tasers as a less lethal tool and a review of its position on the use of Tasers. She is planning to deliver that report in January.
"I think it's important across the board that law enforcement evaluate the use of Tasers," she said. "It's a tool of coercion, it is not a de-escalation tactic or skill."
Following the incident that led up to Rogers’ death, all city officers were required to complete a Taser refresher course followed by an exam, according to the department. The course was in addition to annual Taser recertification requirements for officers.
The department said it will also require its officers to become fully certified emergency medical responders.
“It is an absolute tragedy that Jim Rogers lost his life while in Pittsburgh Police custody — a failure of a system that should have protected his life,” Mayor Bill Peduto said in a statement. “This critical incident included multiple failures.”
Mr. Peduto called the police department’s announcement of pending disciplinary action and policy changes “a starting point.”
“We must continue to make reforms in policing and within society to do what we can to make sure this never happens again and that Mr. Rogers’ family receives the justice they deserve,” the mayor said.
The Black Political Empowerment Project, a Pittsburgh voter advocacy group, said in a statement that it was “encouraged” by the police department’s decision to use a critical Incident Review Board during the investigation.
“We appreciate that this tragic death was not ignored and that this needless death was apparently taken seriously by the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police and the Pittsburgh Department of Public Safety,” the statement said.
B-PEP mentioned the group sent a letter to the Department of Public Safety on Nov. 1 calling for a full investigation, and that they received direct response to from Mr. Hissrich promising an in-depth investigation.
In the statement, B-PEP added that they were “heartened” to learn that eight officers would receive disciplinary action.
“We also appreciate the admittance on the part of the City of Pittsburgh that though the city has been attempting to implement new measures meant to ensure additional accountability of how our Police Bureau performs its duties, including mandating de-escalation and implicit bias training, and efforts to further examine how trust could be increased on the part of the Pittsburgh community toward its police force, that they have not been able to fully meet that goal, and that more needs to be done,” the statement said.
Brandi Fisher, founder and CEO of the Alliance for Police Accountability, said, “While we are relieved the leadership of the Pittsburgh bureau of police not only held a number of officers involved in this case accountable, but also went beyond to enact policies to prevent such a tragedy to be repeated, we can’t help but notice the allotment of a top ranking officer to resign,” a reference to reports that one of the officers at the scene has left the force.
The report that came out Tuesday was more detailed and showed the department taking more ownership of accountability than in the past, Ms. Fisher said. That made her wonder what had prevented such information and action before.
Now, she said, she is urging to speed up the process from the medical examiner’s office.
Without it, “it holds up the process of accountability,” she said.
Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen Zappala also alluded to those reports in saying, "The substance of whatever document is being referenced, which apparently was communicated to the media by Mr. Peduto's police administration, is mostly already known to investigators. That being said, some of the substance is inconsistent with prior statements, thereby requiring review for the possibility of additional criminal conduct."
Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com; Lauren Rosenblatt: lrosenblatt@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.