The latest plan for new housing in ever-hot Lawrenceville involves the conversion of an old Catholic Church once known as the “Polish Cathedral.”
After nearly a decade of conflict and delay, E Properties and Development is advancing a proposal to transform the former Holy Family Church at 250 44th St. into 25 condominiums, with another 21 townhouses to be built around it.
E Properties will brief the city planning commission on the proposal Tuesday, one that gained more traction after the developer withdrew a bid several years ago to demolish the church.
“We’re just excited to be here,” said Emeka Onwugbenu, principal of E Properties. “It’s been a long process that we had to work through.”
Lawrenceville-based E Properties at one point had pitched a plan to demolish the church, which was completed in 1940 and drew inspiration from prominent counterparts in Poland.
But that proposal ran into opposition from community groups, prompting them to nominate the church for a city historic designation to protect it, and Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto.
Read More
E Properties ended up dropping the demolition plan. A compromise eventually was reached that allowed it to raze the Holy Family rectory and school while retaining the church.
The developer has already started tearing down the school and the rectory. Mr. Onwugbenu hopes to start construction on the housing later this month or in January, with the first units to be ready in about a year.
All of the condos and townhouses will be three or four bedrooms. Mr. Onwugbenu said prices have yet to be set.
As part of Lawrencevile’s exclusionary zoning ordinance, five of the units must be affordable and sold to households below 80% of the area median income, or about $60,000 a year for a family of three, according to the Lawrenceville United community group.
Amenities within the development will include a gym, integral parking, bicycle parking, a wine room for the condos and a pet spa.
In a summary posted after a September meeting on the project, Lawrenceville United stated that community members in attendance “shared their excitement to finally see development move forward on the blighted property, where fires have occurred in recent years, and stressed the need to preserve and highlight the historic aspects of the church and its meaning to the community.”
It also stated that neighbors requested that the developer “address negative impacts of construction related to rodents, noise and parking.”
Dave Breingan, Lawrenceville United executive director, could not be reached for comment.
According to the Pittsburgh History and Landmarks Foundation, the Holy Family Church itself was established in 1902 at the corner of 41st and Foster streets. It was created by people of Polish descent moving into the neighborhood.
When the new church opened in 1940, it was considered one of the most visually appealing architectural landmarks in Lawrenceville, according to the nomination for city historic status.
It had five altars, with the main one featuring statues of the church’s patrons and statues of two angels flanking it.
The church closed in 2008.
E Properties has been involved in other developments in Lawrenceville, including the 24-unit Lawrenceville Lofts condo complex at 3725 Butler Street.
Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.