Nearly two weeks after a Pittsburgh Post-Gazette investigation showed that more than half the city’s low-income public housing developments had failed their inspections, the housing authority pledged to improve its oversight of the facilities while defending its management of thousands of apartments in the city’s neighborhoods.

The Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh issued the agency’s first public response on Friday during a virtual meeting, saying it conducted a review of the problems exposed by the newspaper’s investigation and had responded to some of the problems, including leaky pipes, broken toilets and widespread mold.

“We took this very seriously, these allegations. All of the commissioners took this very seriously,” said Valerie McDonald Roberts, the board’s chair. “We don’t want to jump to conclusions. We want to jump to fact.”

The virtual session was held 10 days after housing advocates and politicians held a press conference outside the city’s largest public housing complex, where they pleaded for better conditions and demanded the resignation of the authority’s CEO, Caster Binion.

Advertise with us

During the authority’s response on Friday, it challenged the Post-Gazette’s reporting by saying it had fixed several of the problems brought out in the story.

However, several of those breakdowns were not repaired until after reporters — in a recorded interview and emails — had brought them to the attention of the agency leaders.

The Post-Gazette’s investigation, built on scores of public records and visits to the facilities, showed that nearly 60% of the complexes owned and managed by the authority in neighborhoods across the city failed their most recent federal inspections, even as the vast majority of facilities nationwide have passed.

Additionally, the Post-Gazette found some of the same housing developments like Northview Heights and Bedford Dwellings had been regularly flunking inspections for two decades.

The Post-Gazette spoke to Housing Authority leadership for nearly 90 minutes on Sept. 29 when the Mr. Binion and other officials were made aware of several issues reporters observed, including filthy, crumbling stairwells, evidence of a sewage leak on a sidewalk, and an overgrown playground — all noted during a series of visits in September.

Advertise with us

The PG also shared with officials on that date specific addresses of residents who were willing to talk openly about problems they said had persisted for months.

Not until the Post-Gazette shared its findings with the housing agency did some of the deficiencies get fixed.

Tall weeds overtaking a jungle gym were finally cut the day after the Post-Gazette flagged the issues for leadership. A rotted medicine cabinet covered by rust was replaced on Oct. 5. Rusty jacks holding up a deteriorating shared staircase were removed and paneling replaced on Oct. 7.

Housing authority officials also said that by Oct. 7 a walkway had been cleaned of what residents said was dried toilet paper trailing from a water pipe where sewage had leaked.

Housing officials said the “grounds are cleaned daily,” but the Post-Gazette observed evidence of the sewage leak on three separate visits over four days in September.

Advertise with us

Marcus Reed, president of the tenants council in Northview Heights, said the housing agency was addressing problems that should have been resolved years ago and that the authority still needs to improve deeper, underlying management practices.

“These issues ain't new just because the Post-Gazette did a story,” said Mr. Reed, who listened to Friday’s virtual session.

The housing authority also said that its average score across developments for the inside of the units was 69%, claiming that the units were “passing.”

But that number does not take into account that 10 of the 17 low-income developments — the majority of the complexes — failed their overall inspections, a percentage far below the national average.

Across the nation, about 90% of developments passed — far higher than Pittsburgh's rate.

Advertise with us

Among its promises to improve public housing in Pittsburgh, authority officials said Friday that they will conduct a “customer survey” focusing on maintenance requests.

They also said the agency would provide written feedback to residents who have open work orders and “continue” to abate what it considers emergencies within 24 hours.

During its investigation, the Post-Gazette interviewed residents who said they waited anywhere from weeks to a year to get the agency to respond to problems within their apartments.

In one Northview Heights unit, a resident had complained of persistent mold as well as a leak from the upstairs bathroom that was seeping through the ceiling and into the kitchen.

The housing authority’s presentation stated that the kitchen was remediated, repaired and painted in 2019.

Advertise with us

However, records show a work order was fulfilled in June of that year for a leak in the kitchen ceiling and a lack of hot water, but issues in the apartment continued.

Inspectors from the county health department visited six times between July 2019 and February 2020, finding a broken shower, water seeping behind the bathtub and spongy walls, among other issues.

In March 2021, housing authority records show another work order for a leak coming down from the shower, noting that the resident said it had been going on for a year.

When reporters visited the unit in September, they observed the kitchen ceiling dotted with what appeared to be mold and bubbling paint from a leak in the bathroom above.

The resident had covered her bathroom walls with contact paper to stem the growth of mold.

Advertise with us

Mr. Reed said as the tenant council leader, he consults with residents who are fighting to get their complaints heard and said he often intercedes on their behalf when there are delays.

From his experience, he said “the housing authority has the tendency to avoid the tough questions.”

The authority criticized the Post-Gazette for not publishing the date of a photo taken of mushrooms growing from a Northview Heights’ kitchen ceiling.

However, the date of the photo — May 2019 — appeared on the front page of the newspaper’s print and pdf editions but was not in the online version. That has since been updated.

“How long does it take mushrooms to grow? And that was in 2019 when there was no COVID [delay],” Mr. Reed said.

Advertise with us

Only three members of the board of the commissioners were present at Friday’s online session. Ricky Burgess, the only member of city council who sits on the housing board, did not attend the session on Friday.

The housing authority is accepting public comments on the issues until Oct. 22 at community.affairs@hacp.org.

Said Ms. Roberts, the chairwoman: “We appreciate from the general public, and not just the media, to bring to the attention things that we need to do.”

Ashley Murray: amurray@post-gazette.com; Joel Jacobs: jjacobs@post-gazette.com