Ginny Kropf and Jennifer McLaughlin spent Saturday morning picking up bottles, cans, a discarded Barbie Doll leg, used meth bags and too many masks to count on several blocks of their Sheraden neighborhood as part of Pittsburgh’s fifth annual Garbage Olympics before heading back down the now-cleaned street where they had begun their work.

“It is satisfying,” Ms. Kropf, 62, a 37-year resident of the neighborhood in western Pittsburgh and president of the Sheraden Community Council neighborhood group. “But it’s depressing, too, when you know if you walk down here tomorrow, or even later tonight, and you know you’ll see more trash.”

Ms. Kropf and Ms. McLaughlin did make a dent in their neighborhood’s trash problem, collecting four bags full between them in the two hours allotted to the city-wide contest on Saturday. A city street survey had determined their area had some of the worst trash-strewn streets in that part of the city.

And the larger effort Saturday by all 22 members of Team Sheraden made an even bigger dent: 42 bags of trash, 12 tires, 12 TVs and e-waste, several bulk items (an old dryer, a barbecue grill, a wheelbarrow).

Advertise with us

“It is daunting,” said Ryan Wysocki, 42, co-organizer with his wife, Aimee, of Team Sheraden, who dressed in a fuzzy Oscar the Grouch costume to help draw attention to the event. “But it’s worth it because I know how much more there would be if we didn’t do this.”

Team Sheraden was one of 45 neighborhood groups participating -- exactly half of the city’s 90 official neighborhoods, and one suburb, Penn Hills -- a record total number for an event the city began five years ago with just five teams.

And this year for the first time, the lone suburb, Penn Hills, which had the second highest number of volunteers with 40, won the competition with 123 bags of trash, 33 tires, and even managed to find an abandoned shopping cart, a bike and two carpets. But it seemed to be an honor no one wanted.

“It’s sad to collect the most trash,” Faith Milazzo, team leader for the Penn Hills Anti-Litter Group, said after accepting the top prize - a handmade green and black trophy of a flaming trash can - at a ceremony at Threadbare Cider House in the Spring Garden neighborhood. “But we’re super proud. We have a very dedicated group.”

Mayor Bill Peduto presented the trophy not only to the 2021 winner, but gave “The Oscar” to last year’s winner, from the Carrick neighborhood, a prize delayed because COVID-19 fears forced the cancellation of the ceremony in 2020.

Advertise with us

Laura Doyle, a member of the Carrick Community Council, which organized last year and this year’s effort, accepted the trophy, a mock-up of Oscar the Grouch on a trash can that the city stopped using out of concern that Sesame Street might not like the copyright infringement.

“It’s kind of happy-sad that we had the most trash,” she told the crowd of about 100 people.

Overall, the first 33 teams to report in to the city by mid-afternoon Saturday had collected more than 1,100 bags of trash, a new record for the competition. In them were 191 TVs or e-waste items, 373 tires and 219 bulk items, with the count expected to rise significantly as the remaining 13 teams reported in.

Getting half the city neighborhoods, which was accomplished by three late team additions , “was the goal,” said Christopher Mitchell, the city’s trash czar whose official title is “Anti-Litter Specialist.”

“We hope this builds enthusiasm for anti-litter efforts,” he said.

Advertise with us

Lena Andrews, one of the co-founders of the Garbage Olympics and leader of the East Liberty Trash Warriors team, which won the first Garbage Olympics in 2016, said that as quirky as a two-hour competition is -- it includes a prize for “strangest item” found -- there is a much broader goal.

“We want to motivate neighborhood groups to clean up throughout the year, not just during the Garbage Olympics,” she said.

Those efforts are necessary all over the city, Mr. Mitchell said, because the traditional way the city has tracked where the most support is needed for trash and litter collection has been through calls to the city’s 311 line, which is supposed to be for non-emergencies like abandoned cars, problem houses and trash.

“We usually go by 311 calls because the thought was, ‘If we have more complaints of litter there, then there’s more litter there,’” he said. “But we found the inverse is true in our survey.”

Last year, Mr. Mitchell did a street-by-street survey of the city’s North Side and western neighborhoods, giving each block a rating based on the trash he saw.

Advertise with us

When he compared what he saw in the survey results versus the analysis of 311 calls, the worst blocks did not have the most 311 calls for trash. In fact, the places with the most 311 calls for trash tended to have significantly less trash on them.

“We believe that is because people feel like the litter in some neighborhoods is always going to be there, and they don’t feel connected to the city, so they don’t call 311,” he said.

Many blocks from the four neighborhoods in the what is collectively known as the West End, including Sheraden, had that inverse finding: lots of trash seen in the street survey, but not many 311 calls for trash on those blocks.

Ms. Kropf of the Sheraden Community Council knows all about that.

She believes a lot of that disconnect comes from a shift during the past three decades from homeowners who lived in their homes and cared about them to landlords who rent to people who don’t have that concern, as well as landlords who aren’t responsive to neighborhood or even city complaints.

Advertise with us

But it would not be a big lift to change that, she believes.

“You know what would be simple? If everybody just made sure the front of their house is clean,” she said as she picked up a nearly full bag of trash on one block of Glen Mawr Street. “It would make a world of difference.”

Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579 or Twitter: @SeanDHamill