Pittsburgh has been named the No.1 city for LGBTQ homebuyers by Realtor.com. Places like San Francisco and New York City have a plethora of active gay-positive and queer-friendly communities and organizations, the site said, but cities like Pittsburgh and Providence, R.I., outweigh them in affordability.

Realtor.com’s data team considered cities with a score of 100 on the Human Rights Campaign’s annual Municipal Equality Index, the presence of a pride celebration festival and the average list price of a home in May when establishing a ranking.

According to their data, the median list price for a Pittsburgh home in May was $299,050. Realtor.com also cited Pittsburgh’s arts and culture scene when comparing LGBTQ-friendly trends with other locations.

John Petrack, executive vice president of Realtors Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh, said he feels Pittsburgh’s positive rating was deserved.

Advertise with us

“From my experience and knowing of certain communities within the Pittsburgh area, the city is very welcoming,” Mr. Petrack said. “Having been involved in the industry in the Pittsburgh metropolitan area and being familiar with their marketplaces, over time I have never seen any issue that would be unfriendly. I know thriving communities that have just been friendly.”

The report highlighted the city’s connection to prominent and historic members of the LGBTQ community, including author and playwright Gertrude Stein, who was born in Pittsburgh, and writer Willa Cather, who spent about a decade working in Pittsburgh in the late 1800s. The report also made references to the city’s art museums, including the Andy Warhol Museum and Mattress Factory, and local LGBTQ theater festivals, such as Pittsburgh’s Pride Theater Festival and Pittsburgh International Lesbian & Gay Film Festival.

According to Marty Healey, CEO of the Persad Center, an LGBTQ mental health agency in Western Pennsylvania, Pittsburgh has many opportunities for LGBTQ couples.

“If LGBTQ+ couples choose to raise a family here in Pittsburgh, there are terrific educational opportunities as well,” said Mr. Healey. “One of the benefits is that there is a tremendous amount of support for the LGBTQ+ community such as Persad Center.”

Mr. Healey also pointed out that Pittsburgh offers career stability, as “our corporations and non-profit organizations are aware of the benefits of hiring talent from various backgrounds and the incredible contributions that LGBTQ employees bring to the workplace.”

Advertise with us

“We continue to see all of our employers — large, small, for profit and non-profit — working to embrace the experience of the last year,” he said. “It is so important that we work to overcome the disparity for many that is certainly in all cities across the county, including Pittsburgh.”

“It is impossible to express how frightening it can be to ‘come out’ in your workplace for fear of being fired, and the city of Pittsburgh has been protecting employees by exceeding federal standards for years,” said Brian Larson, sales specialist with Coldwell Banker Real Estate in Pittsburgh.

David Onufer, a Realtor and RAMP board member, said the city’s leadership and community is why Pittsburgh is so LGBTQ-friendly.

“I think it starts top down,” Mr. Onufer said. “I know the mayor and his team has worked to be more inclusive. We also have so many great organizations. Pittsburghers are very welcoming and very accepting for the most part.”

In February, Mayor Bill Peduto appointed 17 people to Pittsburgh’s first-ever LGBTQIA+ Commission. It was the last step in a process that began in 2016, when Mr. Peduto created an advisory council. The commission will advise city government issues facing the LGBTQIA+ community.

Advertise with us

Mr. Larson, who filed for a same-sex domestic partnership with his husband in 2012, said the couple’s own experience in buying their Observatory Hill home was positive.

“Marriage wouldn’t be a legal option for us until 2015,” Mr. Larson said. “Pittsburgh offered us not only recognition of our relationship but increased protections before they would be seen on a state or federal level. The city is consistently progressing and I look forward to what is to come.”

To be included in the ranking, cities had to have at least 2.5 married or co-habitating same-sex couples per 1,000 residents based on U.S. Census Bureau data. The list also was limited to one city per state for geographic diversity.

Stacey Slie, 37, and Randi McKenna, 34, both of Brighton Heights, bought a house in the winter of 2018.

“We both spent the majority of our lives living within the North Side of Pittsburgh and have experienced first hand how accepting members of our community have been to the LGBTQ residents, so leaving this part of the city was never really a consideration for either one of us,” the couple said. “We have relationships and friendships with a wide spectrum of folks here regardless of their race, gender, age or sexual orientation and continuing to contribute to a community as inclusive as the North Side was a top priority for us.”

Advertise with us

They especially love “exposing their son to all of the culture, art, history and sports that the city has to offer.” Their experience with the Pittsburgh Public School system has also been incredibly positive, according to Ms. Slie and Ms. McKenna.

“There are some really wonderful magnet schools in the district and the experience our son has gained from going to a city school with teachers and kids from such diverse backgrounds is invaluable and has shaped him into a more well-rounded, accepting, versatile kid,” the said. “No one bats an eye at our unconventional blended family.”

Realtor.com highlighted Shadyside with the most LGBTQ nightlife in the city. To Mr. Healey, one of the most interesting things about Pittsburgh is the diversity of neighborhoods.

“Since there isn’t specifically one ‘gayborhood,’ per se, you’ll find LGBT couples in urban, suburban and rural settings living their lives authentically,” Mr. Healey said. “In Pittsburgh, as well as across the country, it’s important to remember that there are members of our community, specifically people of color and trans women of color, who certainly still continue to face discrimination, housing and employment challenges. My hope is that this type of recognition will help bring about change for all. Especially those who are still not served equitably.”

The Realtor.com rankings focused only on LGBTQ homebuyers and didn’t include other marginalized communities, such as Black or brown residents.

Hannah Wyman: hwyman@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1255