A Lincoln-Lemington-Belmar resident outlined her argument Thursday in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas in her case seeking the ouster of city Councilman Ricky Burgess — a case that the city’s defense says won’t pass constitutional muster.

Carmen Brown argued before Judge Joseph James that Mr. Burgess’ simultaneous jobs as an elected official and as a professor at the Community College of Allegheny County violates both the city’s governing charter and ethics policies and should result in him losing his council seat.

“Your honor, the provision Section 308, members of council shall not hold any other office, position or employment in the government of the United States, commonwealth of Pennsylvania, the city of Pittsburgh or Allegheny County,” Ms. Brown said, citing the city’s Home Rule Charter.

Ms. Brown further argued that the city’s ethics code states that an employee, including elected officials, can teach at a university “as long as the city employee is an independent contractor and not directly employed by the college or university.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Burgess, who is in his fourth term representing the city’s 9th District, has been a tenured professor at CCAC since 1991, according to the city.

But the city’s Law Department, in defense of Mr. Burgess in his official capacity, argues that the local charter provisions are unconstitutional.

Assistant Solicitor Lawrence Baumiller, citing a 1995 Pennsylvania Supreme Court decision “In Re Petition Recall Reese,” argued that the commonwealth’s Legislature and the governor have narrow authority over removing public officials, rendering the city’s Home Rule Charter provisions on the matter “unenforceable,” he wrote in the trial brief.

Additionally, the city argues that a teaching position at CCAC does not qualify as a conflict for Mr. Burgess because the college is a “distinct legal entity incorporated under a different law than Allegheny County.”

“Dr. Charles Martoni, who has served on County Council, he not only taught at CCAC, he eventually became president of Boyce campus simultaneously,” Mr. Baumiller said, referring to the late county councilman who died in May 2019.

Advertise with us

“But no one ever objected to Dr. Martoni,” Judge James replied.

“No, but even under the ethics code [the city] doesn’t consider a teacher in a college to be a public employee,” Mr. Baumiller said. “... The two government entities don’t engage with each other and compete with each other for funding, and one does not rule the other.”

The city declined to comment further following the oral arguments, as it doesn’t comment on pending litigation.

Following the proceeding, which was held on a videoconferencing platform, Ms. Brown said the city’s argument “makes absolutely no sense.”

“How are you [Baumiller] a solicitor and you’re sitting there saying that your policies are unconstitutional?” she said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Burgess does not comment on pending litigation, said Shawn Carter, special assistant to the councilman.

Judge James said he expects to issue a decision next week.

Ashley Murray: amurray@post-gazette.com.