With three City Council members present, roughly a dozen residents expressed concern at a Monday hearing about a land swap in East Liberty between the city and the developer of the former Penn Plaza apartments site.

A parcel of the adjacent Enright Parklet is set to move to make way for the new Pennley Park South Inc. development — a nine-story, 246,090-square-foot retail and office complex.

The proposed project became a lightning rod issue for affordable housing activism in Pittsburgh after residents were evicted in 2015 from apartments that accepted low-income housing vouchers.

The 11 people who spoke at the evening hearing raised concerns that Pennley Park South wants to move on the land swap before providing funds for affordable housing — part of a consent order between the developer and community groups issued by the courts in late 2017.

Advertise with us

Several others asked council to guarantee that a street the developer plans to extend along the park will remain public.

“Those [housing] provisions and all of the things the city agreed to as part of that have not been met yet,” said Sallyann Kluz, organizer for the Enright Parklet Neighborhood Association. “Frankly, this is our leverage. We don’t see how this is going to be a benefit to the neighborhood unless we have the funding in place.”

The rectangular 2.2-acre park borders Amber, Topaz and Eva streets. The city and Pennley Park South are slated to swap two roughly equal-sized pieces of land — in essence turning the rectangle 90 degrees to configure the long side adjacent to Eva and South Euclid Avenue.

“We’re giving them more valuable land ... and then we’re going to give them a million dollars to rebuild this park,” Zach Gumberg, a principal of Pennley Park South, said after the hearing. “Then we’re going to rebuild a new street 100% on our property, and then we’re going to rebuild South St. Clair Street, which doesn’t exist [now]. We’re going open up this park to the entire neighborhood, north, south, east and west. This is going to create a more vibrant park and a more vibrant neighborhood. This is the community’s plan, not mine.”

Randall Taylor, a former resident of the Penn Plaza apartments, called the proposal “another sad day” and questioned Councilman Ricky Burgess’ support of the developers.

Advertise with us

Mr. Taylor was removed by a Pittsburgh police officer when he refused to stop speaking after his one minute expired. Mr. Taylor, who plans to run as an independent for Mr. Burgess’ seat in November, was not cited.

“The discussion around this property has probably been five years now,” council President Bruce Kraus said in response to testimony. “I don’t like the integrity of this council being impugned with speculation. If there are people who have been misinformed or ill informed, I apologize. We did our due diligence in scheduling this public hearing.”

Another resident called for leadership from the city.

“Perhaps from council and from the mayor’s office in bringing the different parties together, community interests, the developers, city officials, to really work through some of the complexity that’s attached to this legislation,” said Richard Swartz, head of the Bloomfield-Garfield Corporation.

“Hearing what you had to say, there isn’t any peace right now, and it needs to be worked out more,” Councilwoman Darlene Harris said. “I have to support the community. There is no resolution, so I am hoping that before we vote on it, there are more discussions between community and developer.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Burgess urged his constituents and the developer to continue the conversation in the Orphans Court Division of the Court of Common Pleas of Allegheny County, where land transfer must take place.

“Council is not the place for this conversation to continue,” Mr. Burgess said.

Ashley Murray: 412-263-1750, amurray@post-gazette.com or on Twitter @Ashley__Murray