A former University of Pittsburgh business professor, who also ran for state House 25 years ago, filed a civil complaint Friday claiming that he was slowly edged out of his teaching role after he complained that his career path was blocked due to age discrimination.

Neil F. Fogarty, 61, of Marshall, filed suit in U.S. District Court in Pittsburgh, citing the Age Discrimination in Employment Act and the Pennsylvania Human Relations Act.

His attorney, Massimo A. Terzigni, called it an unusual case.

"Nowadays, you don't always hear the direct discrimination and ageist comments of, 'advanced stage of your career', 'you should retire,'" Mr. Terzigni said Saturday. "I think this is just blatant."

Advertise with us

University director of media relations Joe Miksch said Pitt would not comment on pending litigation.

Mr. Fogarty worked at Pitt's Katz Graduate School of Business as a lecturer and instructor in its College of Business Administration, starting in 1986, according to the complaint. In 1994, he ran for a state House seat, as a Republican, but fell far short of unseating the incumbent, David J. Mayernik, D-West View.

A lawyer, Mr. Fogarty's teaching post was based on his professional qualifications, according to the lawsuit. He "has consistently received high ratings on his teacher evaluations" and "received six Teaching Excellence Awards from the school," according to the complaint.

Around five years ago, the complaint says, he wanted to get a doctoral degree so he could expand his teaching horizons, and the school had traditionally covered tuition for similarly situated instructors.

However, his superiors "stated that the money invested to provide additional training and education would be better spent on someone not at an 'advanced stage of [their] career,'" according to the lawsuit. They also told him that “'there are too many old men in our interest group, and they should all retire,'" according to the lawsuit.

Advertise with us

His interest in a teaching opening was ignored, per the lawsuit. And when, in 2016, he alleged age discrimination to higher-ups, his teaching assignments began to dwindle, from 18 credits all the way down to six. When he asked why, he received a reply by email that the reduction was "due to a 'desire for greater diversity,'" according to the complaint.

"He kept trying," said Mr. Terzigni. "He's always made efforts to progress, but he kept being blocked, essentially, from doing more. Their conduct coupled with their statements, it's blatant ageism."

In 2017, the school gave his office to a younger employee, according to the complaint. Finally, last year, he was removed from the teaching schedule for some periods and given one class in another semester.

Neither the former Katz dean, nor Mr. Fogarty's then-supervisor at the school responded Saturday to requests for comment.

Mr. Fogarty is now teaching for a satellite campus of the Pennsylvania State University, according to his attorney, but is being paid less than he was at Pitt.

Advertise with us

Mr. Fogarty "wants some justice," said Mr. Terzigni. "He wants the people who made those statements to be held accountable, which is difficult to do.”

Mr. Fogarty would consider returning to Pitt, Mr. Terzigni said. “But he wants to be able to progress and keep working, wherever that may be."

Rich Lord: rlord@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1542