Justin Dillon, organizer of Monday's planned protest against Pittsburgh City Council's proposed gun control legislation, is no stranger to going toe to toe with municipal governments. In 2013, the 31-year-old and his lawyers took a case in his native Erie to the state Supreme Court, successfully stopping the city from enforcing an ordinance that banned guns in parks.
So when Pittsburgh's municipal leaders announced plans last month to ban certain types of weapons and ammunition within the city, he and his group Open Carry Pennsylvania got involved quickly.
"What the mayor wants to do could affect everybody statewide, if it's allowed to pass," said Mr. Dillon.
Mr. Dillon forecasts over 500 attendees at the open carry protest he has planned for Monday afternoon on the portico of the City-County Building.
Pittsburgh Creative and Performing Arts, a public school located Downtown, will be on modified lockdown status Monday because of the rally, according to an email sent to parents of its students late Friday. Students will not be allowed to leave the building without prior permission from their parent or guardian, according to the email. Any visitors to the school will need an appointment, and extra school police and city police will be posted outside and inside the school.
"The protest is expected to last for a few hours and may delay school and Port Authority buses traveling through Downtown," the email warned. Most CAPA middle school students ride school buses, while high school students use public transit.
Read More
In 2013, Mr. Dillon was told by the Erie solicitor that protesters in a city park could not carry guns per an ordinance. His initial appeal to the state Supreme Court, asking them to step in and block the enforcement of the ordinance, was unsuccessful, and when he went ahead with the protest, he and seven others were charged.
On appeal in 2014, the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania found that state law prohibits municipalities and counties from regulating firearms or ammunition "ownership, possession, transfer or transportation" in any way that differs from state regulations. Charges against Mr. Dillon were overturned, and later that year Erie officially repealed the city park gun ban.
According to Mr. Dillon, the proposed Pittsburgh regulations violate the same state law as Erie's. At a press conference for the legislation in December, Mayor Bill Peduto said the city was willing to challenge the constitutionality of the state law if need be.
Mr. Dillon’s read on that: "They want us to obey the law, but they say they're not going to.”
The planned protest, which is scheduled to start at noon Monday, is intended to "show that we're not silent. The Second Amendment is important to us," Mr. Dillon said.
"[Open carrying] is our constitutional right. We're here, and we're responsible," Mr. Dillon said.
Mr. Peduto said Thursday that while he disagrees with the protesters, he recognizes their right to protest.
"We're going to call him out to have an open debate which is open to the public and the media,” Mr. Dillon said. “If he is all about safety and he is all about citizens, then let's have an open debate about."
"The city's guiding principle will continue to be protecting people's First Amendment rights while ensuring safety for all, including protesters, motorists who might be affected by road closures and all other city residents and visitors," said Chris Togneri, spokesman for Pittsburgh Public Safety.
Tim McNulty, spokesman for the mayor’s office, said Thursday that there would be a police presence in part to ensure the protest is separate from any counter-protests going on, but did not identify any specific planned counter-protests.
Shira Goodman, executive director of the gun control group CeaseFirePA said they support the proposed legislation but are not planning anything because “the people who come to our events are not so comfortable with lots of armed people.”
“An open carry rally is just a blatant intimidation tactic,” said Ms. Goodman.
"It'll be the safest place in Pittsburgh that day," said Mr. Dillon, who has repeatedly encouraged attendees to be peaceful and to keep all weapons in holsters or over shoulders.
The city will have “uniformed officers, plainclothes officers, and officers on motorcycles and bicycles and in vehicles to ensure public safety throughout the event,” said Mr. Togneri.
Mr. Dillon applied for a permit for “fewer than 200” to protest. Speakers scheduled, according to the Facebook event, include Mr. Dillon, state Rep. Aaron Bernstein, and Kaitlin Bennett, a gun rights activist who was photographed carrying an AR-10 rifle with her Kent State graduation cap, in a picture that went viral in May.
But Mr. Dillon said he expects many more — possibly in excess of 600 people — to attend the demonstration.
“I have people coming from Chicago, from Philadelphia, the middle of the state of Pennsylvania, not far from Erie. We have people coming from Ohio,” Mr. Dillon said. “So it's other cities and other states that are joining in our fight because they're just getting sick and tired of the infringement government officials are trying to do in the name of safety.”
Mr. Prince sent a letter to the city on behalf of the Allegheny County Sportsmen’s League and Firearm Owners Against Crime challenging signage put up at the City-County Building noting a ban on firearms inside the City-County Building. According to the letter, the signs must advertise the presence of free lockers for checking guns.
Mr. Togneri responded, “Signage is posted next to the Grant Street and Ross Street entries to the City-County Building stating that lockers are available, free of charge, for the temporary checking of firearms.”
City law already prohibits people from firing a gun within the city limits, with a handful of exceptions. The proposed changes would also prohibit carrying, storing, transferring, selling, buying or manufacturing assault-style weapons in the city.
The legislation generally defines assault-style weapons as guns that can switch between automatic fire, semi-automatic fire or burst fire, as well as guns that can accept large-capacity magazines, which are defined as magazines that hold more than 10 rounds. It also includes a list of specific guns that would be banned.
Gun owners who already legally possess such weapons would be grandfathered in and exempted from the new laws. Armor-penetrating ammunition and accessories designed to accelerate a gun’s rate of fire, like bump stocks, would also be prohibited under the proposal.
Council members Strassburger and O’Connor also hope to create “Extreme Risk Protection Orders,” which would allow the courts to authorize law enforcement to temporarily seize a person’s guns under limited circumstances.
Under the proposed legislation, either a law enforcement officer or a family or household member of a person “alleged to present a danger of suicide or of causing extreme bodily injury to another person” could petition the court for an order.
That petition would trigger a process similar to that followed for Protection from Abuse orders, in which a judge reviews the circumstances and the defendant is given an opportunity to argue his or her case in court. If a judge issued an extreme risk order of protection, it would include a warrant to allow law enforcement to search and seize the defendant’s firearms, typically keeping the weapons for a year.
Christopher Huffaker: 412-263-1724, chuffaker@post-gazette.com, or @huffakingit.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.