Two Pittsburgh police commanders and other public safety employees who formed a private for-profit business to sell training they teach for free as part of their jobs may have run afoul of the city’s ethics code, the mayor’s spokesman said Wednesday.

“The officers involved in this group likely have good intentions and want to spread the training to others,” spokesman Tim McNulty said. “However it is the opinion of Mayor [Bill] Peduto, the law department and the Department of Public Safety that it is not permissible for employees to use the training they have gained on city time to provide a private service, and that they are barred from doing so by the Pittsburgh City Code and the State Ethics Act.”

Cmdr. Jason Lando, who joined with Cmdr. Cristyn Zett and Officer Jeffrey Upson in September to create private company DBA Training Solutions, said Wednesday they’ve taken pains to avoid conflicts of interest or ethical violations.

“Anything we would do on the business side would be completely separate from the training we do for the city,” Cmdr. Lando said.

Advertise with us

The Pittsburgh Bureau of Police requires all officers to undergo training on implicit bias, and the bureau also teaches the training for free to community groups as part of a federal policing initiative aimed at improving community-police relations. The courses focus in part on identifying and combating subconscious bias.

Cmdrs. Lando, Zett and Officer Upson teach those trainings for the bureau. The company they founded provides “implicit bias” and “procedural justice” training to corporations, schools and community groups, according to its website.

“We built the presentation completely ourselves, we sent a memo to the [city] law department, everything we’re doing, we’re doing within the rules and regulations,” Cmdr. Lando said. “There is absolutely nothing — there is no bleed over between the two. We used all our own equipment, we did it on our own time.”

Scanned From a Xerox Multifunction Printer (PDF)

Scanned From a Xerox Multifunction Printer (Text)

Advertise with us

Cmdr. Lando said any organization that could get the training for free from the police bureau can still do so, and that DBA Training Solutions will instead focus on providing the training to private corporations, which the police department typically would not train.

He said the founders created the company because of an abundance of positive feedback and interest from participants in the city training who wanted to take the content back to their colleagues. Cmdr. Lando said they’ve done one private training so far.

But Mr. McNulty said the training should not be taught at all outside the bounds of the police department.

“It’s our feeling the training can’t be given outside of the police department’s role of giving it to community groups and to the officers themselves,” he said.

No formal investigations have been launched into the business, and city officials are still “studying the matter,” Mr. McNulty said.

Advertise with us

Commanders are among the police bureau’s highest-ranking officers, just under the level of assistant chief. Cmdr. Lando, who runs Zone 5 in Highland Park, is in charge of policing in parts of the East End, while Cmdr. Zett leads the department’s Zone 2 station in the Hill District, overseeing areas that include Downtown and the Strip District.

Both started on the force in 2000.

Pennsylvania State Police Trooper Robin Mungo and Barbara Morello, the city’s public safety community outreach supervisor are listed as trainers on the company's website. They, Officer Upson and Cmdr. Zett did not return requests for comment.

Pittsburgh’s code of ethics forbids city employees from using “information obtained in the course of his or her employment for personal use other than would be generally available to the public at large.”

However, city employees are allowed to work second jobs and can use expertise gained through the city employment in those jobs, said Pittsburgh Controller Michael Lamb. They just can’t use city equipment or resources to do so.

Advertise with us

“If I cut grass in the park for the city, I can also work as a landscaper on the weekend,” he said. “Obviously, I can’t use a city lawn mower to do it.”

The company created by the police commanders falls in a gray area, he said.

“As long as they are not using city time or city resources, they’re permitted to do this kind of thing, but they have to be very careful about that line,” he said.

On DBA Training Solutions’ website, the company’s testimonials page included feedback forms from city training sessions — Pittsburgh’s official seal, partially cropped, is visible on some testimonials.

Mr. McNulty said the use of the city’s feedback forms is unacceptable. Elizabeth Pittinger, executive director of Pittsburgh’s Citizen Police Review Board, said the forms are a “city asset.”

Advertise with us

“They’re taking that asset and making it their own for personal gain, and it’s using their city employment for personal gain,” she said.

Mr. Lamb agreed.

“They may be in violation; using feedback forms that they received while doing city work is probably not permissible,” he said.

Cmdr. Lando said Wednesday he is not opposed to removing the forms from the company’s website. By early Wednesday evening the testimonials had been removed.

The commander also said that he’d like to hear the city’s Ethics Hearing Board’s position on the matter. On Dec. 30, he requested an advisory opinion from the board, which is tasked with enforcing the city’s code of ethics.

Advertise with us

Such opinions offer guidance for city employees as they navigate areas that could cross the city’s ethics code. A formal opinion from the board that approves of an action can serve as protection against future complaints. The board’s opinion can also point out potential pitfalls to be avoided, said Leanne Davis, executive manager of the board.

She declined to comment on the particulars of this case, but said the board’s opinion on the situation will be issued by Feb. 10.

Several other public employees have come under fire for running private businesses in the past.

Former Pittsburgh police Chief Nathan Harper faced scrutiny in early 2013 for forming a public safety consulting firm with three of his officers to provide security training, background checks and executive protection. He was indicted on unrelated federal charges later that year, pleaded guilty and eventually spent time in prison.

And more than a decade ago, then-Allegheny County Coroner Cyril Wecht faced federal fraud charges concerning allegations he used county time and resources for his private pathology business. The charges were dismissed after a three-year legal fight and a mistrial.

Shelly Bradbury: 412-263-1999, sbradbury@post-gazette.com or follow @ShellyBradbury on Twitter.